Excerpts from Julien Vey's message of 2014-02-13 05:18:19 -0800: > Hi, > > I have some concerns about using Zuul in Solum > > I agree gating is a great feature but it is not useful for every project > and as Adrian said, not understood by everyone. > I think many Solum users, and PaaS users in general, are > single-project/single-build/simple git worklow and do not care about gating. >
The gate can be a noop. Easier to insert more gate tests when it matters than it is to swap out technologies at that time. > I see 2 drawbacks with Zuul : > - Tenant Isolation : How do we allow access on zuul (and jenkins) for a > specific tenant in isolation to the others tenants using Solum. Same way Trove has a mysql database per tenant I presume. > - Build customization : One of the biggest advantage of Jenkins is its > ecosystem and the many build customization it offers. Using zuul will > prohibit this. Nobody is saying you can't use Jenkins. People are saying use Zuul and get more than Jenkins. But go on and use Jenkins as well. > > About Gerrit, I think it is also a little too much. Many users have their > own reviewing system, Pull requests with github, bitbucket or stash, their > own instance of gerrit, or even a custom git workflow. > Gerrit would be a great feature for future versions of Solum. but only as > an optionnal one, we should not force people into it. Agreed on that. _______________________________________________ OpenStack-dev mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev
