<http://frontpagemagazine.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=27570>
http://frontpagemagazine.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=27570
CAIR Must Be Fought, Pt. II             
By
<file:///C:/Program%20Files/Common%20Files/Microsoft%20Shared/Stationery/aut
hors.asp?ID=79> Henry Mark Holzer
New Media Journal | March 28, 2007 

Last week I wrote an article in these pages entitled
<http://www.newmediajournal.us/staff/h_holzer/03192007.htm> A Call To Arms:
Cair Must Be Fought. In my article I repeated what I have been saying (and
writing) since the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR) began
attacking the free speech rights of American citizens: that CAIR must "be
countered with a non-profit 501(c)(3) entity that could raise tax-deductible
contributions for the sole purpose of fighting CAIR in court." Examples of
CAIR's court cases, including its most recent on behalf of the "flying
imams," were discussed. 

As a result of my article, I've been asked exactly how CAIR could be fought
in court. There are many ways, and the remainder of this article explains
just one of them.

At least 23 states and one territory have statutes known by their acronym
SLAPP-"Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation." [1] Actually, the
laws are known as "Anti-SLAPP" statutes because they protect "public
participants" from lawsuits brought by people who want to silence them.

Since the "flying imam" flap originated in Minnesota, I'll use that states'
"Anti-SLAPP" statute as my example of what smart, tough lawyers can do to
the bullying thugs of CAIR. The statute appears in bold face below; my
comments are interspersed.

But before getting to that, I want to set the stage.

A broadcaster urges the FBI to search every mosque in America, a blogger
demands the state department deny visas to Muslims, a newspaper editorial
insists that the Attorney General prosecute citizen Islamofascists for
treason.  

Next, on behalf of itself and/or the allegedly injured parties, CAIR sues
everyone connected with the incident.  Also sued, as in the flying imam
case, are "John Does"-other people allegedly connected to the incident whose
names are not yet known to the plaintiffs.

These defendants are not powerless.  These defendants are not sheep going to
slaughter under CAIR's knife.  Every one of these defendants, every time,
should invoke an available "Anti-Slapp" statute, like this one.

Minnesota Statutes Annotated
554.01. Definitions

Subd 1. Scope. The definitions in this section apply to this chapter.

Subd. 2. Government. "Government" includes a branch, department, agency,
official, employee, agent, or other person with authority to act on behalf
of the federal government, this state, or any political subdivision of this
state, including municipalities and their boards, commissions, and
departments, or other public authority.

This is a broad definition of "government."  It is meant to include every
type of entity and individual.  If CAIR or another plaintiff claims that the
"government" requirement of Section 554.03 (below) is not satisfied, the
likelihood is that the court would interpret this section broadly to
embrace, for example, a "division" of an agency and a "representative" of an
"official."

Subd. 3. Judicial claim; claim. "Judicial claim" or "claim" includes any
civil lawsuit, cause of action, claim, cross-claim, counterclaim, or other
judicial pleading or filing seeking damages for an alleged injury. "Judicial
claim" does not include a claim solely for injunctive relief.  

This is an important provision, for two reasons.  First, it means that the
statute includes every conceivable manner in which a claim can be
formulated.  However, the statute textually embraces only those claims
seeing money damages.  Were CAIR for itself or another plaintiff to seek
only an injunction-unlikely because injunctions against speech are virtually
impossible to obtain-this statute would not be available to the defendant.

Subd. 4. Motion. "Motion" includes any motion to dismiss, motion for summary
judgment, or any other judicial pleading filed to dispose of a judicial
claim.

This is a standard, unexceptional definition.

Subd. 5. "Moving party" means any person on whose behalf the motion
described in
<http://web2.westlaw.com/find/default.wl?rp=%2ffind%2fdefault.wl&vc=0&DB=100
0044&DocName=MNSTS554%2E02&FindType=L&ReferencePositionType=T&ReferencePosit
ion=SP%3B2add000034c06&AP=&fn=_top&rs=WLW7.02&mt=Westlaw&vr=2.0&sv=Split>
section 554.02, subdivision 1, is filed seeking dismissal of an action under
this chapter.

This is a standard, unexceptional definition.

Subd. 6. "Public participation" means speech or lawful conduct that is
genuinely aimed in whole or in part at procuring favorable government
action.

This is one of the statute's most important provisions because it broadly
embraces speech and conduct so long as its intention is to influence
government action (like searching mosques), but not necessarily on behalf of
the speaker/actor who has now become a defendant in a SLAPP lawsuit.  The
only textual limitation in this definition is that the conduct be "lawful"
and that the speech and conduct be "genuinely" motivated.

Subd. 7. "Responding party" means any person against whom a motion described
in
<http://web2.westlaw.com/find/default.wl?rp=%2ffind%2fdefault.wl&vc=0&DB=100
0044&DocName=MNSTS554%2E02&FindType=L&ReferencePositionType=T&ReferencePosit
ion=SP%3B2add000034c06&AP=&fn=_top&rs=WLW7.02&mt=Westlaw&vr=2.0&sv=Split>
section 554.02, subdivision 1, is filed.

This is a standard, unexceptional definition.

554.02. Protection of citizens to participate in government

Subd 1. Applicability. This section applies to any motion in a judicial
proceeding to dispose of a judicial claim on the grounds that the claim
materially relates to an act of the moving party that involves public
participation.

Notice that four of the terms in this section-motion, judicial claim, moving
party, public participation-have been defined in the previous section.  

Subd. 2. Procedure. On the filing of any motion described in subdivision 1:

(1) discovery must be suspended pending the final disposition of the motion,
including any appeal; provided that the court may, on motion and after a
hearing and for good cause shown, order that specified and limited discovery
be conducted;

This subsection means that once a defendant who believes he has been sued to
punish him for "public participation-that is, for having said or done
something allegedly offensive to Islam, CAIR, or any of its interests-makes
a motion (i.e., asks the court) to dismiss the case because it is a SLAPP
suit, "discovery" stops.  In other words, neither party-subject to the
statute's proviso that the court can allow limited discovery-can take
depositions or seek to obtain documents.

>From the defendant's perspective this provision is the proverbial two-edged
sword.  Although the plaintiff can't harass the defendant by employing the
various oft-devastatingly time-consuming tools of discovery, the defendant
is unable to dig into the plaintiff's motives and evidence.  This is,
however, an acceptable price for a SLAPP suit defendant to pay for early
termination of a spurious lawsuit.

(2) the responding party has the burden of proof, of going forward with the
evidence, and of persuasion on the motion;

This is a crucially important provision (to be read in conjunction with
Subsection (3) below).   Ordinarily, in civil litigation the plaintiff who
has brought the lawsuit has the burden of proof-e.g., that the
broadcaster/defendant really did defame the plaintiff.  

This said, one would think that when a defendant claimed that the
plaintiff's lawsuit was a SLAPP suit aimed at silencing and/or punishing the
defendant for something he said or did, the defendant would have to prove
that.  Not so.  Under the statute, when the defendant makes the SLAPP motion
to dismiss the case, it is the plaintiff who has the burden of proof.  What
is that burden?  The next subsection contains the answer.

(3) the court shall grant the motion and dismiss the judicial claim unless
the court finds that the responding party has produced clear and convincing
evidence that the acts of the moving party are not immunized from liability
under
<http://web2.westlaw.com/find/default.wl?rp=%2ffind%2fdefault.wl&vc=0&DB=100
0044&DocName=MNSTS554%2E03&FindType=L&AP=&fn=_top&rs=WLW7.02&mt=Westlaw&vr=2
.0&sv=Split> section 554.03; and

In other words, CAIR sues, the defendant moves to dismiss the lawsuit on
SLAPP grounds, and CAIR must prove-not by the usual, lesser standard of
proof by a "preponderance" of the evidence, but by the higher standard of
"clear and convincing" evidence"-that the defendant was not immune from
suit.  We get to that immunity in a moment, once we pass the next
subsection.

(4) any governmental body to which the moving party's acts were directed or
the attorney general's office may intervene in, defend, or otherwise support
the moving party.

This subsection means that the government can, if it chooses, provide legal
assistance to the defendant-either by actually becoming a defendant itself,
or providing representation or otherwise supporting the defendant (which
could include financially).

554.03. Immunity

Lawful conduct or speech that is genuinely aimed in whole or in part at
procuring favorable government action is immune from liability, unless the
conduct or speech constitutes a tort or a violation of a person's
constitutional rights.

This is the core provision of the statute.  In the typical CAIR and
CAIR-like baseless intimidation case this requirement will not be difficult
to satisfy.  In my examples, the broadcaster did urge the FBI to search
every mosque in America, the  blogger did demand the state department deny
visas to Muslims, the newspaper editorial did insist that the Attorney
General prosecute citizen Islamofascists for treason.  There were no
ulterior motives-only speech "genuinely aimed...at procuring favorable
government action."  The same kind of speech used by the John Does in the
"flying imam" case to have the airline, backed by government police power,
to remove the troublemaking Muslims.  Clearly, in both my examples and in
the "flying imams" case none of the John Does engaged in conduct or speech
that constituted "a tort [civil wrong, like negligence] or a violation of a
person's constitutional rights."

554.04. Fees and damages

Subd 1. Attorney fees and costs. The court shall award a moving party who
prevails in a motion under this chapter reasonable attorney fees and costs
associated with the bringing of the motion.

Depending on how far into the litigation the motion to dismiss is made (an
important tactical consideration), and given the cost of legal fees today,
the amount assessed against the unsuccessful plaintiff could be substantial.

Subd. 2. Damages. 

(a) A moving party may petition the court for damages under this section in
conjunction with a motion under this chapter.

This section makes clear that not only can the defendant's lawyer(s) obtain
attorney fees, but so can the defendant.

(b) If a motion under this chapter is granted and the moving party
demonstrates that the respondent brought the cause of action in the
underlying lawsuit for the purpose of harassment, to inhibit the moving
party's public participation, to interfere with the moving party's exercise
of protected constitutional rights, or otherwise wrongfully injure the
moving party, the court shall award the moving party actual damages. The
court may award the moving party punitive damages under
<http://web2.westlaw.com/find/default.wl?rp=%2ffind%2fdefault.wl&vc=0&DB=100
0044&DocName=MNSTS549%2E20&FindType=L&AP=&fn=_top&rs=WLW7.02&mt=Westlaw&vr=2
.0&sv=Split> section 549.20. A motion to amend the pleadings under
<http://web2.westlaw.com/find/default.wl?rp=%2ffind%2fdefault.wl&vc=0&DB=100
0044&DocName=MNSTS549%2E191&FindType=L&AP=&fn=_top&rs=WLW7.02&mt=Westlaw&vr=
2.0&sv=Split> section 549.191 is not required under this section, but the
claim for punitive damages must meet all other requirements of
<http://web2.westlaw.com/find/default.wl?rp=%2ffind%2fdefault.wl&vc=0&DB=100
0044&DocName=MNSTS549%2E191&FindType=L&AP=&fn=_top&rs=WLW7.02&mt=Westlaw&vr=
2.0&sv=Split> section 549.191.

The first sentence of this subsection tracks the previous subsection.
However, this subsection adds the power of the court to award punitive
damages-which could be substantial since their purpose is not to make the
defendant whole (that's what actual damages are for), but instead to punish
the plaintiff and serve as a warning to others who also might be disposed to
intimidate someone's free speech rights.

554.045. Action in district court

A person may bring an action under this section in state district court
against a respondent who has brought a claim in federal court that
materially relates to public participation by the person. If the person
demonstrates that the respondent's action in federal court was brought for
the purpose of harassment, to inhibit the person's public participation, to
interfere with the person's exercise of protected constitutional rights, or
otherwise wrongfully injure the person, the court shall award the person
actual damages and reasonable attorney fees and costs. The court may award
the person punitive damages under
<http://web2.westlaw.com/find/default.wl?rp=%2ffind%2fdefault.wl&vc=0&DB=100
0044&DocName=MNSTS549%2E20&FindType=L&AP=&fn=_top&rs=WLW7.02&mt=Westlaw&vr=2
.0&sv=Split> section 549.20.

This subsection provides that a defendant who is sued in a federal court in
a SLAPP case can bring a SLAPP case of his own in a Minnesota court against
the person who brought the federal case.  Then, the federal court plaintiff
becomes the state court defendant-who must somehow get around the
"Anti-SLAPP" statute's immunity provision.

554.05. Relationships to other law

Nothing in this chapter limits or precludes any rights the moving party or
responding party may have under any other constitutional, statutory, case,
or common law, or rule.

This section makes it expressly clear that nothing in Minnesota's
"Anti-SLAPP" statute should be understood not to preclude any other legal
rights the SLAPP victim might have against the plaintiff.

And there are several such rights.

I'll discuss them in forthcoming articles.


 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to