<http://www.gcn.com/cgi-bin/udt/im.display.printable?client.id=gcn&story.id=
44996>
http://www.gcn.com/cgi-bin/udt/im.display.printable?client.id=gcn&story.id=4
4996 
 

Your call may be monitored

09/10/07 
By Patrick Marshall,



Speech analytics is becoming a hot technology for call centers, though few
want to talk about it

   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif>   &ltSCRIPT
language='JavaScript1.1'
SRC="http://ad.doubleclick.net/adj/N3271.Gov_Comp_News/B2434254.4;abr=!ie;sz
=336x280;click=http://media1.gcn.com/accipiter/adclick/CID=00002cdcf10ec1ae0
0000000/site=gcn/area=PRINTER_FRIENDLY/pos=BOX_R1/aamsz=336x280/content=/acc
_random=601311/pageid=601311/relocate=;ord=601311?"></SCRIPT>&ltNOSCRIPT>&lt
A
HREF="http://media1.gcn.com/accipiter/adclick/CID=00002cdcf10ec1ae00000000/s
ite=gcn/area=PRINTER_FRIENDLY/pos=BOX_R1/aamsz=336x280/content=/acc_random=6
01311/pageid=601311" target="_blank">&ltIMG
SRC="http://ad.doubleclick.net/ad/N3271.Gov_Comp_News/B2434254.4;sz=336x280;
ord=601311?" BORDER=0 WIDTH=336 HEIGHT=280 ALT="Click Here"></A></NOSCRIPT>
<http://media1.gcn.com/IMPCNT/ccid=11484/site=gcn/area=PRINTER_FRIENDLY/pos=
BOX_R1/aamsz=336x280/content=/acc_random=601311/pageid=601311>  
You know the drill. You call a sales line or even some federal agencies, and
you're put on hold. You hear a recording informing you that "your call may
be monitored to improve customer service." Then you're connected to either a
live agent or an automated, interactive recording. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
What the recording doesn't say is that your call is not merely monitored: It
may be put through rigorous analysis that can determine not only what you
say but also your emotional state. The information can be combined with your
phone number and, potentially, other private information such as your credit
history. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Call centers have been through a technological revolution during the past
decade. But it's a strikingly quiet revolution. Not many in either the
public or private sector want to talk about their capabilities. Despite
numerous inquiries to federal call center managers, we got no response to
our requests for interviews. We were not able to determine how much that may
have had to do with summer vacations. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Even vendors are notably closemouthed about specific implementations. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Ron Twersky, president at Utopy, a major provider of speech-recognition
solutions, said nondisclosure agreements prevent his company from discussing
the details of call center technology implementations in either the public
or private sector. "In the enterprise sector, they want to keep a strategic
advantage over their competition," Twersky said. He added that he doesn't
understand the government's reluctance to talk but speculated that it may
have something to do with privacy concerns. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 


Dan Kaufmann, regional manager at Nice Systems, said his company also is
precluded from discussing specific implementations. "Due to the public
nature of our company and the sensitivity involved in working with
government agencies, we are unable to divulge the details of present case
studies in the government sector." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Much of the concern, said Donna Fluss, president at DMG Consulting, seems to
be over the speech-analysis capabilities of call centers. "I can't tell you
exactly how they're using [speech analytics] today," Fluss said. "Some of
the stuff we know. We know they're using it on our phone calls, right? We
know they're using it to analyze battle activities. We know they're using it
to protect constituents. These are things we know." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Two-way access
In its simplest form, a call center can be a room with little more than a
telephone. A good example of an informal call center is the old-fashioned
police station where calls are routed from one desk to another until they
are answered. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Formal call centers today, of course, add a variety of tools to make them
more effective. For starters, calls are routed according to choices callers
make in response to a live operator or - more typically - prerecorded
messages. In the old days, callers would press buttons on their telephones
to make those choices. Now, thanks to speech recognition software, they can
respond orally. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Call centers also typically provide computer resources that offer access to
supporting databases. Agents at banks, for example, can quickly check
details about your account or credit card purchases. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
And the click of a button can generate reports showing any combination of
the collected data. What's more, in a modern call center, you can work back
from the report to specific calls and even a recording of the call itself. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
"Today, a marketing manager can have a report sent to his e-mail with all
the interactions that express satisfaction or dissatisfaction about a new
product or campaign," said Eyal Rudnik, product manager at Nice Systems.
"This is something that was not available - not thinkable - in the past." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
But the cutting edge of call center technology is clearly speech analytics. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Speech recognition is being employed to recognize callers' spoken choices
and route them appropriately. The technology is continually being improved,
but it is relatively easy to recognize responses from a limited range of
choices. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Researchers have, however, delivered far more ambitious speech analysis
tools to call centers. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
"We have developed a new model for interaction analysis," Rudnik said. "It
is a multidimensional one, because there is much more about an interaction
than just the spoken word." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Nice's Insight from Interactions system employs a number of building blocks,
he said. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
First, the system captures the conversation in a stereo recording and
separates the caller's words from the agent's. The conversation is
recognized and a digital transcript is created. Keyword analysis and other
types of content analysis can then be performed on the transcript.
Recognition accuracy is 85 percent to 95 percent, Rudnik said, which is
remarkably high for systems not trained to callers' voices. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
"If you're trying to find out if an agent was promoting your new product,
you might want to look for all the calls where your product name wasn't
mentioned," Rudnik said. "Then you can listen to the calls and see why it
wasn't mentioned. Was it just an omission?" 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Second, the system can perform emotion detection. "We have the ability to
take a baseline reading of your emotional state at the beginning of the call
and to see if there is any deviation from that baseline," Rudnik said. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
To measure emotion, the system examines 20 voice variables, including tone
of voice, cadence and pace. "It's a very sophisticated algorithm," Rudnik
said, noting that two callers might both say "thank you very much," but one
might be saying it sincerely and the other sarcastically. "We can spot this
difference." And that's not the end of it. Speech analytics also can be
employed to analyze patterns. "We can look for cases in which there is
awkward silence during the conversation," he said. "That may allude to the
fact that the agent doesn't know what to say, he doesn't have the knowledge
or he doesn't know how to manage complicated situations in which, for
example, the customer is irate. We can also look for instances where there
is overlapping [conversation], which means that the agent doesn't allow the
customer to voice his comments, where he is not polite." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
If it seems a bit like Big Brother is watching, he is. And agents in the
call center are even more under the microscope than callers are. That's
because call center software can also perform screen content analysis, in
which the content of the agent's screen can be lined up with the call's
development. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Finally, these tools are all integrated. "You can ask the system to tag all
the calls in which the competition's name is mentioned, the customer was
irate and there was a rather awkward silence during the call," Rudnik said. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Twersky is not as confident as Rudnik that speech analytics is capable of
reliably differentiating between sincere and insincere utterances. But he
does agree that a lot of information can be gathered by speech analytics.
"We don't know of a capability to detect cynicism or a criminal tone,"
Twersky said. But "you can distinguish between a customer who is angry or
not angry." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Government's call
The pace of innovation in call center technologies has been rapid, but its
adoption by government agencies and departments has been spotty, Fluss said.
"The great news is that the government is adopting call center technology." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Nevertheless, she added, "the federal government is still lagging and in
need of some very significant upgrades, not only of their technologies, but
of their practices. They really do need to catch up." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
State and local governments, she said, have been quicker to adopt the
emerging technologies, as is demonstrated most significantly by the growing
use of 311 call centers designed to relieve 911 call centers' load by
handling nonemergency calls. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
"The fact that state and local governments are realizing that they have a
responsibility to their constituents - and they're setting up call centers -
is interesting," she said. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Federal agencies and departments may not be as quick off the mark, but they
are also starting to adopt more advanced call center technologies. A great
example of that is the Internal Revenue Service, Fuss said. "Over the past
couple of years, they've invested a fortune in setting up call centers." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
The IRS call center - which operates around the clock 365 days a year - is
one of the largest anywhere. It has 42 automated call distributors,
thousands of phone lines and peripheral devices in locations nationwide. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
The Postal Service is another major federal adopter. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Ron Dull, vice president of program management at Convergys, said his
company installed systems for USPS to manage both customer calls and
internal help-desk calls. "We've improved automation rates very
significantly" for customer calls, he said. "That is, we're getting over 20
percent more citizens to use the automated, self-service technology. At the
same time, we're improving their level of satisfaction with that channel." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Dull said the new system at the internal help-desk call center has saved
USPS $9 million in the past two years by reducing to almost zero the number
of misdirected calls. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Fluss also said the military services are setting up call centers but added
that "I'm not going to go into detail on that." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
It is not clear, however, which government call centers employ speech
analysis. "Speech analytics is heavily in deployment by the federal
government right now," Fluss said, adding that she was not free to talk
about implementations. Twersky said call centers employing speech analytics
would be ideal for congressional offices, because they could essentially
enable virtual public-opinion polling. "If there are repeated issues that
come up, this can be picked up on by speech analytics. You can generate
reports on the percentage of people angry about a certain issue." He added,
however, that he was not aware of any congressional offices employing such a
system. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Privacy concerns
When talking to vendors and analysts about the use of call center
technologies in the government sector, two broad trends emerge. First is a
general belief that broader implementation of new call center technologies
is inevitable. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
"In terms of emotion analysis and analysis of interactions between live
agents and customers, I expect over the next several years we'll continue to
see a pretty significant increase in that being commercially applied and
being applied to civilian applications in government," Dull said. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Second, there is general acknowledgement among vendors that those
technologies are already in widespread use in military and national-security
agencies, though they are precluded from talking about details of those
implementations. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
What could be slowing the broader implementation of call center technology -
or at least public discussion of it - is the issue of privacy. 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
"In the government space, dealing with the privacy issues is a
consideration," Dull said. "In many ways, we're constrained by the rules and
legislation that particular agencies operate under in terms of to what level
we're able to keep and capture information about specific citizens or
individuals." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
But Lillie Coney, associate director of the Electronic Privacy Information
Center, a nonprofit advocacy group, said the Privacy Act protections Dull
referred to are often difficult to apply to new technologies. "Because
computing technology is moving so quickly, there are not a lot of laws in
place to ensure that the rights of consumers and citizens are protected,"
she said. "If they're using this technology to make determinations about the
person calling in, noting that information to a file or record, making
determinations or decisions based on this analysis, it puts the consumer or
citizen at a disadvantage." 
   <http://www.gcn.com/images/clearpixel.gif> 
Coney also said the warnings offered when people call into the centers are
not sufficient. "There needs to be full disclosure," she said. It needs to
advise that "the call will be recorded, it will be retained, and it will be
analyzed based on speech patterns or whatever."  



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to