Faith, reason, and the war against jihadism

The events of 9/11 were a particularly lethal expression of the
globalization of religious passion.

http://www.speroforum.com/site/article.asp?id=14346
 
Monday, February 11, 2008
By George Weigel 
 
The events of 9/11 were a particularly lethal expression of the
globalization of religious passion. Yet those events were something else,
and something more. War had been declared upon us by an enemy whose
motivations were utterly alien to the 21st century sensibility of the West. 

It has taken us some time to grasp this new and dominant fact of
international public life. But now, six and a half years after 9/11, we
cannot not understand. For unless we grasp the character of this new kind of
war, our chances of prevailing against an adversary with a very different
view of the future-and a willingness, even eagerness, to die for the sake of
hastening that future-are weakened. 

The war is now being fought on multiple, interconnected fronts, in
Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, Lebanon/Syria, North Africa, Gaza, Somalia, Sudan,
southeast Asia; there is an intelligence front, a financial-flows front, an
economic front, an energy front, and a homeland security front. My purpose
here is to identity what we should have learned by now about the enemy and
about ourselves. 

Understanding the Enemy 

Lesson 1. The great human questions are ultimately theological.

How we think- or don't think- about God has a great deal to do with how we
envision the just society and determine the best means with which to build
it. This means taking theology seriously, which includes others' theologies
as well as our own. We certainly should have learned this over the past six
years. Yet commentators and statesmen continue to use "theology" or
"theological" as synonyms for "superstition" or "mindless." Such glib usages
are an impediment to clear thinking about our situation. 

Lesson 2. The trope that describes Judaism, Christianity, and Islam
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/0757522319?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=0757522319&adid=72fa2701-3d40-4b63-877
d-80f85a9ac5bb>  as "the three Abrahamic faiths" obscures more than it
illuminates, and ought to be permanently retired.

Of course the three faiths all trace their origins to Abraham, but in fact
the theological parallelisms are rather limited, especially with regard to
Islam. 



sponsored by
 <http://www.clearkitchen.com/> Sponsored by ClearKitchen.com -- new
products for cooking and entertaining.
Related Articles
Middle East <http://www.speroforum.com/site/subs.asp?idsub=125> 

Ahmadinejad
<http://www.speroforum.com/site/article.asp?idarticle=14352&t=Ahmadinejad+sa
ys+nuclear+program+%27threats%27+useless> says nuclear program 'threats'
useless

Ahmadinejad implored crowds at the rally in Teheran to voice their position
on the nuclear issue, and the thousands present responded by chanting,
"Nuclear power is our integral right!"
Open Democracy Security  <http://www.speroforum.com/site/subs.asp?idsub=196>
Briefings

'Waterboarding'
<http://www.speroforum.com/site/blog.asp?idarticle=14368&t=%27Waterboarding%
27+illegal%3F> illegal?

The CIA chief admits that a certain, controversial interrogation technique
may in fact contravene the country's laws. A ceasefire in the wilds of
Waziristan irks Washington. The UK extradites Abu Hamza, but ponders
bringing in Sharia law.
It is often suggested that there is an affinity between Christianity and
Islam that is virtually identical to what Rabbi David Novak calls the
"common border" between Judaism and Christianity; Islamic regard for Abraham
and Moses, Jesus and Mary, is often cited as an example of this affinity.
Yet as Alain Besancon has pointed out, "The Abraham of Genesis is not the
Ibrahim of the Quran; Moses is not Moussa.. Jesus is indeed granted a
position of honor in the Quran, but this Jesus is not the Jesus in whom
Christians proclaim their faith." 

Moreover, Islam's deep theological structure includes themes that render the
notion of "three Abrahamic faiths" unhelpful in understanding Islam's faith
and practice. Take the question of Islamic supersessionism-Islam's claim
that the revelation to Muhammad unveiled Judaism and Christianity as false
religions. Despite the supersessionist claims that some Christians have
historically made vis-a-vis Judaism, no orthodox Christian holds that God's
self-revelation in Christ negates God's self-revelation in the history of
the People of Israel. 

Then there is the nature of the Quran itself. The mainstream Christian
understanding of biblical inspiration was expressed by Vatican II in the
1960s: "To compose the sacred books, God chose certain men who. made full
use of their own powers and faculties so that. it was as true authors that
they consigned to writing whatever he wanted written, and no more." That
theological understanding of biblical inspiration provides for the
possibility of interpreting the sacred texts and for developing doctrine in
light of an evolving understanding of the full meaning of Scripture. The
Quran, by contrast, is understood to have been dictated by its divine
source, word for word, so that there is much less question of exegesis or of
a post-scriptural development of doctrine. Thus the Quran is described by an
influential Egyptian Islamic activist in these terms: "the Quran for mankind
is like a manual for a machine." 

Thus Islam is "other" in relationship to Christianity and Judaism in a way
that Christianity and Judaism cannot be to one another. The late Pope John
Paul II
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/006018793X?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=006018793X&adid=4c85af07-50a2-49fb-940
b-7fc9e6cbefee>  recognized this. In Crossing the Threshold of Hope, he
observed: 

"Some of the most beautiful names in the human language are given to the God
of the Quran, but He is ultimately a God outside of the world, a God who is
only Majesty, never Emmanuel, God with us. Islam is not a religion of
redemption. There is no room for the Cross and ... the tragedy of redemption
is completely absent. For this reason not only the theology but also the
anthropology of Islam is very distant from Christianity." 

That theological anthropology yields a view of the just society that is
dramatically different from that of Judaism and Christianity. Islamic
theological anthropology is one root of what Efraim Karsh has termed "the
fusion of religious and temporal authority" in Islam. That fusion has, in
turn, led to what Karsh calls "Islam's millenarian imperial experience"-and,
one might add, the millenarian political expectations of some Muslims today.
Islamic theological anthropology also helps explain Islam's difficulties in
creating the cultural preconditions for social pluralism. Whether Islam can
evolve into a religion capable of providing religious warrants for genuine
pluralism is thus one of the great questions on which the future of our
century will turn. 

Lesson 3. Jihadism is the enemy in the multi-front war that has been
declared upon us. 

There are many forms of Islam. Some of them, often called "fundamentalism"
or "Islamism," stress the need for a deep religious and moral reform within
the House of Islam and for the reestablishment of Islamic political power.
The specific form of Islamism which threatens the West is best described as
jihadism. 

Richard John Neuhaus recently defined jihadism as a "religiously inspired
ideology" which teaches that "it is the moral obligation of all Muslims to
employ whatever means necessary to compel the world's submission to
Islam."Its adherents are, de facto, in a state of belligerency against the
rest of the world. Neuhaus goes on to note, "It will be objected that, in
the Quran, jihad can also mean peaceful spiritual struggle. That is true, as
it is true that those Muslims who believe jihad means peaceful spiritual
struggle are not the enemy." Indeed, much of the history of this century
will turn on the question of whether the jihadists' definition of jihad
becomes the most culturally assertive definition within the many worlds of
Islam. 

Lesson 4. Jihadism has a complex intellectual history, which must be grasped
in order to understand the nature of the threat before us. 

Modern jihadism is rooted in a profound Islamic sense of Islamic failure.
One can see traces of that sense of failure in the inertia of the Ottoman
Empire before World War I. That inertia has a far longer pedigree, which
involved a kind of turning-off of intellectual inquiry in a Muslim world
that once found ample room within itself for an incorporation of the wisdom
of the classical world and helped transmit that wisdom to the medieval West.


The causal chain that takes us from medieval debates about Islamic law and
theology to the caves of Tora Bora and 9/11 involves numerous figures, among
them Ahmad ibn Abd al-Halim ibn Taymiyya (1263-1328), Muhammad ibn Abd
al-Wahhab (1703/4-1792), and two contemporary theorists, Hasan al-Banna
(1906-1949) and Sayyid Qutb
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/0939830086?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=0939830086&adid=50bc2f20-f42f-4852-a4f
4-afe870f40d92>  (1903-1966). 

To make a long story desperately short: At a time when the Mongols had
conquered much of the Islamic umma, ibn Taymiyya taught that the survival of
Islam required political power; that the pursuit of that power should be
undertaken by means of armed force; and that jihad involved both an absolute
love of God and an "absolute hatred" for all that God proscribes, which
includes "not only heretics, apostates, hypocrites, sinners, and unbelievers
(including Christians and Jews)...but also any Muslim who tried to avoid
participating in jihad." Ibn Taymiyya thus adumbrated the intra-Islamic
civil war that has now spilled over into jihadism's struggle against the
rest of the world. 

Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab emphasized that God's relationship to the world
is that of an absolute lawgiver: God is will, and there is no spiritual
wrestling with the divine will. Yet Wahhab had little influence in his own
time, or indeed for centuries afterwards; it would take a vast transfer of
western wealth to Saudi Arabia to make Wahhabism a potent force in the
world. 

Hasan al-Banna, Egyptian founder of the Muslim Brotherhood
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/0195084373?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=0195084373&adid=f7570f72-787b-4c22-859
5-3908c398798c> , condemned the "mental colonization" of Islam under
colonial rule and urged a struggle against a West that he perceived as
having thus far won a "ruthless war whose battlefield has been the spirits
and souls of Muslims." Al-Banna proposed an Islamic social reformation. The
educational, social, economic, religious, and charitable activities of the
Muslim Brotherhood would be one form of this reformation. Jihad would be
another, for God had given Muslims the privilege and duty of saving the
world. After cleansing the House of Islam, true Muslims would cleanse their
territories of infidels, beginning with Egypt. 

Sayyid Qutb, whose formative experiences included being scandalized at the
"decadence" he perceived at a church social in Greeley, Colorado, in 1949,
brought these various lines of jihadist thought together in a singularly
influential way. He, too, stressed the idea of God as Absolute Will, God as
the unique lawmaker; thus, for Qutb, liberal political thought-even
conservative liberal political thought-was a false religion, not simply bad
politics. In a harsher way than others before him, Qutb stressed that those
Muslims who did not live authentic Islamic lives were enemies to be fought
and, if necessary, killed, as were Jews, Christians, and unbelievers. Here
was a mind frozen in time, in which the Crusades and the Spanish Reconquista
were present realities, summoning forth a perpetual struggle, violent if
necessary, until the final global triumph of Islam. 

The power of jihadism derives from its theological roots. As Pope Benedict
XVI pointed out in his Regensburg Lecture in September 2006, the key
theological move that underwrites today's jihadism is the identification of
God as Absolute Will. If God is absolute will, God can command anything -
even the irrational. And so, in an extension of Qutb's thought, contemporary
jihadists believe that the murder of innocents is not simply morally
acceptable, but morally required, if such murders advance the cause of
Islam. Mercy comes to be understood as weakness. Justice is traduced into
revenge. Given Qutb's conviction that Islam and modernity were "utterly
incompatible," and given the defective theology that undergirds Qutb's
worldview, what seems incomprehensible to many westerners-the death cult
that forms the core of Al Qaeda and similar entities-begins to make a
certain perverse sense. As Fouad Ajami writes, jihadism thus creates a
"world without limits" in which, the battlefield "spans pizzerias, buses,
public squares, commuter trains, and subway stations." 

The line from Taymiyya and Wahhab that would later influence al-Banna and
Qutb came to one conclusion when Ayman al-Zawahiri and Osama bin Laden, an
Egyptian and a Saudi, a veteran political operator and propagandist and a
somewhat dreamy charismatic leader, joined forces to form Al Qaeda: the
result was global jihad. 

Lesson 5. Jihadists read history and politics through the prism of their
theological convictions, not through the prism of western assumptions about
the progressive dynamic of history.

Jihadists read the 1990s as a moment that revealed fatal western weaknesses.
To them, the Soviet defeat in Afghanistan (even if it was made possible by
western aid and technology) meant that modernity was on the run. This
provoked new patterns of aggression, which were reinforced when the
generally feckless U.S. response led to bin Laden's apotheosis as the
jihadist champion who had taken on the Great Satan and prevailed. Then, when
the U.S. failed to respond to the attack on the USS Cole in such a way as to
ignite the war in Afghanistan in which bin Laden hoped to trap the
Americans, he decided that something else was required: as Lawrence Wright
puts it, "he would have to create an irresistible outrage." The result was a
vast hole in the ground in Lower Manhattan, the loss of almost 3,000 lives,
and an economic cost of billions of dollars. 

Lesson 6: Necessary truth-telling is the prerequisite to genuine
interreligious dialogue.

In Pope Benedict's Regensburg Lecture, the Holy Father gave the world an
interreligious and ecumenical vocabulary to engage in a genuine conversation
about the threat jihadism poses: the vocabulary of "rationality and
irrationality." Criticized at the time as a diplomatic "gaffe," the Pope's
proposal has now drawn responses from international groups of Muslim
leaders, and a meeting in March at the Vatican is planned. This newfound
interest within senior Islamic circles in serious theological conversation
with the Pope about the right ordering of society followed, not the exchange
of banalities and pleasantries that too often characterizes interreligious
dialogue, but a robust critique of the theological roots of jihadism. Surely
there are lessons here for the future. 

One is that the western media acquiescence to Muslim complaints about
"Islamophobia" should stop: it is not "Islamophobic" for the Pope, or anyone
else, to pray in the presence of Muslims; to defend religious freedom; or to
condemn violence in the name of God-suggestions made by NPR, the New York
Times, the AP, and the New York Daily News during Benedict XVI's December
2006 visit to Turkey. It would also be helpful if the western press would
call things by their right names: murderers in Iraq are murderers and
terrorists, not insurgents or sectarians; suicide bombers are, in fact,
homicide bombers; and so forth. 

Lesson 7. This is a multi-generational struggle.

The below-replacement-level birthrates that prevail throughout virtually the
entire western world are another factor in this global struggle. As the
inimitable Mark Steyn puts it, given present demographic trends, soon "the
Belgian climate-change lobbyist will be on the endangered species list with
the Himalayan snow leopard"-a fact that, given Belgian parallels in the
Netherlands, France, Spain, and elsewhere, has already changed the political
landscape of western Europe. 

Yet Steyn notes that birthrates are already declining in some Islamic
countries, such that the jihadists' demographic advantage will eventually
decrease as well. So the historical window for the achievement of the
jihadists' most ambitious goals will likely begin to close in, perhaps,
twenty-five years or so. The demographics of the Islamic world, coupled with
the staying power of the passions unleashed by jihadist ideology, thus
suggest that the current phase of the contest for the human future will last
at least two or three generations. This is, indeed, a long war. We must
understand that and plan both strategy and tactics accordingly. 

Reconceiving Realism 

Lesson 8. Genuine realism must avoid premature closure in its thinking about
the possibilities of human agency in the world.

Grasping the inevitable irony, pathos, and tragedy of history; being alert
to unintended consequences; maintaining a robust skepticism about schemes of
human perfection; cherishing democracy without worshiping it-these elements
of the Christian realist sensibility associated with Reinhold Niebuhr
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/0664224741?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=0664224741&adid=8b008514-df03-4785-817
a-9ce1754696ac>  remain essential intellectual furnishing for anyone
thinking about U.S. foreign policy in the war against jihadism. Yet realism
must be complemented by a commitment to the possibility of human creativity.


As Dean Acheson said at another moment when history's tectonic plates were
shifting, the task he and Harry Truman faced "only slowly revealed itself.
As it did so, it began to appear as just a little bit less formidable than
that described in the first chapter of Genesis. That was to create a world
out of chaos." Our task today is not dissimilar. In carrying it out, we
would do well to remember the counsel of Charles Frankel: "The heart of the
policy-making process...is not the finding of a national interest already
perfectly known and understood. It is the determining of that interest: the
reassessment of the nation's resources, needs, commitments, traditions, and
political and cultural horizons - in short, its calendar of values." 

The Bush administration's efforts to accelerate change in the Arab Islamic
world were determined by a realistic assessment of the situation after 9/11.
Mistakes in implementation notwithstanding, the attempt to accelerate the
transition to responsible and responsive government in the Middle East
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/0812692179?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=0812692179&adid=02938425-3ad8-4bce-a62
e-ca272c24a270>  was a realistic objective, given an unacceptable status quo
that was inherently unstable; that was unstable because it was corrupt; and
that was producing terrorists and jihadists determined to challenge those
corruptions. 

Lesson 9. The objective in the Middle East is the evolution of responsible
and responsive government, which will take different forms given different
historical and cultural circumstances.

Bernard Lewis is, as usual, a wise guide here. As he recently wrote,
"Different societies develop different ways of conducting their affairs, and
they do not need to resemble ours... Democracy is not born like the Phoenix.
It comes in stages, and the stages and processes of development will differ
from country to country." 

The difficulties of post-Baathist political transition in Iraq should not,
however, blind us to the fact that the war against jihadism and the quest
for freedom are linked, and neither can succeed without the other. Moreover,
Lewis encourages us to think that there is enough in both the traditional
culture of Islam and the modern experience of the Muslims to provide the
basis for an advance toward freedom, rightly understood. Trying to support
and perhaps even accelerate that advance is the only realistic course of
action. 

Lesson 10. In the war against global jihadism, deterrence strategies are
unlikely to be effective.

This is perhaps most evident in Iran, or at least among Iranians like
President Ahmadinejad who believe that they can hasten the messianic age by
unleashing nuclear holocaust in Jerusalem. As Adam Garfinkle asks, how does
one deter people who are willing and even eager to turn their country and
their entire religious sect into a suicide bomb? 

Any deterrence value or dampening of jihadist enthusiasms that we might have
expected to gain from Iraq will be lost if the outcome there is perceived to
be an American defeat. Such an outcome would be little short of a
catastrophe. It may be that the final outcome in Iraq is not, ultimately, of
our determining-that the immediate future of Iraq will inevitably reduce
itself to the question of whether Iraqis want even a loosely federal state
more than they want to kill each other. But the premature abandonment of the
effort to prevent that nightmare scenario from playing itself out would be
read by global jihadists as a sign of fecklessness that will have untold,
but surely awful, consequences. 

Deserving Victory

I keep in my study a postcard copy of a World War II poster in which Winston
Churchill points a finger at you over the emblazoned slogan "Deserve Victory
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/0762415940?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=0762415940&adid=d39d9af0-5ee0-4e79-ac5
f-6739093885af> !" What must we do to deserve victory in the war against
global jihadism? 

Lesson 11. Cultural self-confidence is indispensable to victory in the
long-term struggle against jihadism.

The second part of Pope Benedict's Regensburg Lecture was a reminder to the
West that, if irrational faith poses one grave threat to the human future,
so does a loss of faith in reason. If the West loses its faith in the human
capacity to know the truth of anything with certainty, it will have disarmed
itself intellectually, culturally, and morally, unable to give an account of
its commitments to civility, tolerance, the free society, and democratic
self-government. Saying "No" to radical skepticism and moral insouciance is
very much part of homeland security. 

Lesson 12. Small concessions in the name of a false idea of tolerance
inevitably lead to further concessions and erosions of liberty.

This process is well-advanced in Europe, where enclaves of sharia law exist
in Great Britain
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/6303653634?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=6303653634&adid=95c01a59-e422-415c-a7a
b-6791c7ddbca9> , France, the low countries and elsewhere-enclaves where the
writ of local law does not run, even in the matter of "honor" killings. The
path to legal surrender was paved by cultural surrender, as when "Piglet"
mugs disappeared from some British retailers after Islamists complained that
the Winnie the Pooh character offended Muslim sensibilities. The Danish
cartoons controversy of 2006 was the most ominous expression of the problem
to date, for here, kowtowing to Islamist agitations led directly to the
infringement of classic civil liberties. 

The European experience of accommodation to Islamist and jihadist threats
and demands has shown where the first concessions lead. Becoming a dhimmi, a
second-class citizen, is not always a matter of accommodating to an imposed
Islamic law. As the European experience demonstrates, self-dhimmitude is a
danger when the nature of tolerance is misunderstood. Not only must the West
defend its core values at home; it should intensify its efforts to promote
religious freedom around the world. 

Lesson 13. We cannot continue to finance those who attack us.

Global jihadism would not be the threat it is had the West not transferred
some $2 trillion in wealth to the Arab Islamic world since World War
II-which, among other things, has allowed Saudi Arabia
<http://amazon.com/gp/product/B000EOHMHQ?ie=UTF8&tag=epact&link_code=em1&cam
p=212341&creative=384049&creativeASIN=B000EOHMHQ&adid=e7568500-2026-4e8a-9c0
d-99ad934e18f4>  to spend an estimated $70-100 billion spreading Wahhabi
doctrine all over the globe. The national security threat of oil dependency
is obvious and self-demeaning. 

Setting aside the details of various alternative energy strategies, there
ought to be broad agreement on former CIA Director James Woolsey's argument
that U.S. energy independence is preponderantly a problem related to oil and
its dominant role in fueling vehicles. Woolsey proposed two policy
directions to reduce this vulnerability: (1) encouraging a shift to far more
fuel-efficient vehicles, and (2) encouraging biofuels and other alternative
and renewable fuels. 

A nation that created the global revolution in information technology surely
can de-fund global jihadism by drastically cutting the transfer of funds
related to petroleum imports. It beggars belief that peoples who did not
discover a resource, much less the means to exploit it and make it the
source of vast wealth, have profited by its development in ways that now
threaten the very possibility of world order. This is dhimmitude of a global
economic sort, and it must stop. 

Lesson 14. Victory in the war against global jihadism requires a new
domestic political coalition.

If we are indeed "present at the creation" once again, we would do well to
adopt a lesson from Truman, Acheson, Marshall, and Vandenberg and create a
domestic political coalition that understands global jihadism and is broadly
agreed on the measures necessary to defeat it. There is a serious question,
though, as to whether the kind of coalition that was assembled in the late
1940s can be replicated today. But were such a coalition to be formed, it
should take as one of its tasks a rationalization of our homeland security
policy. We have not yet reached the point of Great Britain, where one of the
country's most wanted terrorists slipped through Heathrow in 2006 by wearing
a burka, as Scottish grandmothers bent over to remove their shoes at x-ray
machines. But we could get there, unless we decide that effective
counterterrorism is more important than political correctness in devising
airport screening measures. Risk-profiling and the development of
trusted-traveler identification cards would be two important elements in
rationalizing homeland security. 

Rationalizing homeland security will also require effective measures to rein
in those parts of the federal judiciary that put irrational obstacles in the
way of detecting terrorism plots. On a 2005 ruling by a federal district
court, the NSA can alert MI-5 if it intercepts a phone call from Peshawar to
London in which jihadists plot to attack London, but any NSA intercept of a
call between Kandahar and Chicago in which terrorists plot to attack
Washington is unconstitutional. This is insanity, and it, too, must stop. 

Lesson 15. There is no escape from U.S. leadership.

The challenge of global jihadism can be neither avoided nor appeased. The
war that has been declared against the West can only be engaged, and with a
variety of instruments, many of them not military. 

Whatever our incapacities, the fact remains that there is no alternative to
U.S. leadership in the war against global jihadism. As Michael Gerson has
put it, "There must be someone in the world capable of drawing a
line-someone who says, 'This much and no further.'" That someone can only be
the United States. President Bush must insure that, whatever else happens,
he leaves the American people, at the end of his term, with a clear
understanding of the nature of the threat, and the magnitude of the stakes
on the global table. There is no escape from the burden of American
leadership, but that burden can be an opportunity for national renewal.



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to