The Myth of Israeli Democracy

Paul Eidelberg

 

Caroline Glick is to be congratulated for drawing a parallel between Angelo 
Codevilla’s exposé of America’s ruling class and its Israeli counterpart (see 
below). However, I venture to say that Codevilla, who I know is well versed in 
Aristotle’s political science, would take exception to Glick’s referring to 
Israel as a “democracy.”  

 

That Israel has a ruling class has been patently obvious since Likud leader 
Benjamin Netanyahu adhered to Labor’s policy of “territory for peace” when he 
first became Israel’s prime minister in 1996.  Since then, the present writer 
has referred to the Likud as the right-wing of the Labor Party.  This was 
confirmed when Netanyahu’s predecessor Ariel Sharon crafted the March 2003 
coalition agreement which bound the coalition parties to the Oslo or Israel-PLO 
Agreement of 1993. Nor is this all. 

 

Israel’s government had legal grounds for abrogating the Oslo Agreement in view 
of its blatant violations by the PLO.  Moreover, and as I have elsewhere shown, 
since the policy of “territory for peace” did not have the support of public 
opinion, there is good reason to believe that Israel is far from being an 
authentic democracy despite its periodic, multiparty elections. This was 
clearly demonstrated when Likud prime minister Ariel Sharon adopted Labor’s 
policy of “unilateral disengagement” from Gaza—a policy rejected by at least 70 
percent of the public in the January 2003 elections.  How one can persist in  
calling Israel a democracy when its prime minister effectively nullified that 
election boggles the mind. 

 

Hence I find it remarkable that an intrepid and brilliant political analyst 
like Caroline Glick refrains from saying that the power of Israel’s ruling 
class is perpetuated by Israel’s undemocratic system of governance, as I have 
repeatedly shown in books, policy papers, and countless articles. 

 

If a person of her prestige were to expose Israel’s regime flaws as she so 
frequently reveals Israel’s policy flaws, this might have significant political 
influence in Israel where she is greatly and deservedly admired. Alas, by 
perpetuating the myth of Israeli democracy, she obscures the institutional 
causes of Israel’s self-destructive policies.   

 

It may be objected that exposing this myth will only arm Israel-bashers and 
anti-Semites.  To this I say: “Has Israel’s reputation as a democracy disarmed 
these detractors?”

 

On the other hand, by exposing the myth of Israeli democracy (especially in the 
United States), this would arouse great fear in Israel’s ruling class.  Why? 
Because it is precisely the myth of Israeli democracy that legitimizes Israel’s 
ruling elites.  Only by arousing the fear of losing their respectability will 
these elites undertake the institutional reforms required to make Israel a 
genuine democracy, where governments cannot  ignore public opinion with 
impunity. Not that institutional reform is a panacea; but it’s a necessary 
means of minimizing the self-destructive consequences of its policies vis-a-vis 
Israel’s enemies. 

 

One last word.  Just as the Likud has become the right-wing of the Labor Party, 
so the Republican Party in the United States may be deemed the right-wing of 
the Democratic Party.  A political realignment may very well occur after the 
November 2010 elections.  The American constitutional system of checks and 
balances may then kick in and drastically reduce if not terminate the power of 
America’s current ruling class. No election has a chance of terminating the 
power of Israel’s ruling class under Israel’s current system of governance.

 

This means that the territorial policy of Israel’s government will not change, 
and that we shall therefore be very much in need of Ms. Glick’s perceptive 
political analyses. 

 

____________________________________________________________________

 

 



   

Israel's Ruling Class
by Caroline Glick, 

 <http://carolineglick.com/> CarolineGlick.com
July 29th, 2010

In a much discussed article in the current issue of the American
Spectator titled “America's Ruling Class,” Prof. Angelo Codevilla
describes the divide between those who run the US ­ the politicians,
bureaucrats and policy establishment ­ and the rest of the country.

He laments, “Never has there been so little diversity within America's
upper crust.”

In his view, the American ruling class “was formed by an educational
system that exposed them to the same ideas and gave them remarkably
uniform guidance, as well as tastes and habits. These amount to a
social canon of judgments about good and evil, complete with secular
sacred history, sins (against minorities and the environment), and
saints. Using the right words and avoiding the wrong ones when
referring to such matters ­ speaking the 'in' language ­ serves as a
badge of identity.”

The main unifying characteristic of the American “ruling class” as
Codevilla describes it is inexhaustible contempt for the majority of
their countrymen who are not part of their clique. In his words, “our
ruling class does not like the rest of America. Most of all does it
dislikes that so many Americans think America is substantially
different from the rest of the world and like it that way.”

Codevilla's article focuses on US domestic policy. He accuses the
ruling class of purposely spending the US into insolvency. He claims
that their goal is to aggregate power. The more Americans depend on
governmental largesse for their livelihoods, the greater the power of
the government to dictate norms of social and political behavior and
the greater the governing class's hold on power.

Codevilla claims that the Republicans are the permanent minority in
the ruling class which is naturally aligned with the Democrats. When
they are in power, the Republicans, he claims repress populist and
conservative voices within their ranks calling for small government
and do so to maintain their good relations with their colleagues in
Democratic ruling circles. His prime example of a ruling class
Republican is the first president George Bush.

Codevilla quotes former Soviet ruler Mikhail Gorbachev's retelling of
a conversation he reportedly had with the vice president Bush about
then president Ronald Reagan. Gorbachev claimed that Bush told him not
to take Reagan seriously because, “Reagan is a conservative, an
extreme conservative. All the dummies and blockheads are with him.”

THERE IS A clear foreign policy corollary to Codevilla's discussion.
Just as US bureaucrats, journalists, politicians and domestic policy
wonks tend to combine forces to perpetuate and expand the sclerotic
and increasingly bankrupt welfare state, so their foreign policy
counterparts tend to collaborate to perpetuate failed foreign policy
paradigms that have become writs of faith for American and Western
elites.

A prime example of this is US Middle East policy. Regardless of its
repeated failure over the course of four decades, since 1970, and with
ever-increasing urgency since 1988, the consensus view of the US
foreign policy elite has been that Israel's size is the cause of
violence and instability in the Middle East. If Israel would just
contract into the indefensible 1949 armistice lines, everything would
be wonderful. The so-called “extremists” in the Arab and Islamic
worlds will become moderates. Iran, Syria, the Saudis, the
Palestinians, al Qaida, Hizbullah and the rest would abandon terror
and beat their suicide belts and ballistic missiles into ploughshares.

An outstanding example of this sort of cross-partisan nonsense was the
2006 bipartisan Iraq Study Group's recommendations to then president
George W. Bush. The war in Iraq was going nowhere and the considered
view of esteemed Republican and Democratic policy hands was to stick
it to Israel.

In the considered view of these wise men, for the US to emerge from
Iraq with honor, it didn't actually have to defeat its enemies.
Instead, according to Republicans like James Baker and Brent Scowcroft
and Democrats like Lee Hamilton and Zbigniew Brzezinski all Bush
needed to do was force Israel to cough up the Golan Heights, Judea,
Samaria and Jerusalem. Then al Qaida in Iraq, the Shiite militias and
all the rest would shrivel up or ­ at a minimum ­ allow the US to
withdraw its military forces from the country without being
humiliated.

The likes of Baker, Scowcroft, Brzezinski and Hamilton and their
students comprise a permanent Middle East policy ruling class that
endures regardless of who is in power and what their actual views
about Middle Eastern realities happen to be.

But they couldn't survive if they didn't receive help from Israel.
Given that most Americans support a strong Israel and view Israel as a
vital US ally in the Middle East, they would be hard-pressed to
maintain their failed and unpopular policies if they weren't amply
assisted by their counterparts in the Israeli ruling class.

This week Ha'aretz ­ the trumpet of Israel's ruling class ­ gave us
all a primer in how this sort of thing works. In an article titled,
“Obama has ways and means to check on Netanyahu,” military commentator
Amir Oren disclosed the close collaboration between the Obama
administration and a handful of hard-left retired IDF officers against
the Netanyahu government.

Oren reported that ahead of Obama's meeting this month with Prime
Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, retired IDF brigadier generals Shlomo
Brom, Udi Dekel and Baruch Spiegel met secretly in Rome with retired
US rear admiral John Sigler who heads the Middle East research
institute at the US Joint Chiefs of Staff. The purpose of their
meeting was twofold.

First, as Oren put it, they were asked to “clarify whether in the
dispute between [the Obama administration and the Netanyahu
government] Netanyahu truly represent the majority in Israel.” That
is, they were supposed to tell Sigler how to drive a wedge between the
democratically elected government and the Israel voters who elected
it.

And second, they were supposed to furnish Obama with arguments to
reject Netanyahu's arguments for why Israel cannot retreat to the 1949
armistice lines. As Oren put it, “When Netanyahu tells Obama there is
something he can't do because it would be the death of him, experts
like the three brigadiers general can map out Israel's ranges of
flexibility to Sigler, and through him pass them along… to Obama.”

Activities like those Oren reports are a permanent feature in
Israelpolicy circles. Regardless of who is in office, the likes of
Brom, Dekel and Spiegel and their leader Yossi Beilin are always
working with the Americans and Europeans to force Israel to maintain
allegiance to the failed land for peace paradigm. Year in and year
out, these anti-democratic and strategically demented but well paid
former officials maintain what they euphemistically refer to as “track
two,” contacts with their counterparts in the European and American
ruling class to force the majority of Israelis who don't share their
derangement to accept their policy dictates.

Codevilla predicts that a clash between the ruling class and the ruled
in the US is just a matter of time, although he makes scant
predictions or recommendations for how that clash will play itself
out. Just so, the time has come for Israelis to confront our own
ruling class and develop methods for weakening its chokehold on
Israel's domestic and foreign policy.

For too long and to our unmitigated detriment Israelis have allowed a
small unelected minority to dictate our national policies. The views
and loyalties of this minority ­ like their counterparts in the US ­
are opposed to those of the majority of Israelis.

If our democracy is to have meaning and if our lives and country are
to be defended, we need to empower our elected leaders to stand up to
those ­ like Brom, Speigel and Dekel -who work actively to subvert the
principle of government by consent of the governed.

Originally published in The Jewish Press
 <http://www.jewishpress.com/pageroute.do/44651> 
http://www.jewishpress.com/pageroute.do/44651

 

  



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to