http://gatewaypundit.firstthings.com/2010/07/is-the-tea-party-like-a-starfish-like-the-apache%e2%80%a6-like-al-qaeda/#more-40650

 

July 31, 2010

-By Warner Todd Huston <http://www.publiusforum.com/> 

Politico’s Kenneth Vogel has an interesting piece 
<http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0710/40492.html>  on a book that Tea 
Party activists are starting to glom onto as an administrative guidebook of 
sorts. The book, “The Starfish and the Spider: The 
<http://www.starfishandspider.com/>  Unstoppable Power of Leaderless 
Organizations,” is a book that explains how leaderless organizations work and 
can be effective. Of late tea partiers have accepted the tome as a way to 
explain the success of their movement as well as a way to legitimize their hold 
on a certain amount of power into the future.

The book, written by two lefty Stanford MBAs, has become what Vogel calls an 
“unlikely” guidebook for a conservative movement.

The principle of the book is in its title. The spider of the title is the 
typical top-down organization. Cut the spider’s head off and you have a dead 
spider and presumably, in the analogy, a dead organization. However, a starfish 
can regenerate itself if it loses an arm. Further that severed arm can also 
become a starfish that lives on because there is no “head” per se in a 
starfish. Cut up a starfish and you have many smaller starfish, not a dead one. 

The thought is that the tea party movement is like a starfish. No head, no 
hierarchy, no way to “kill” it in the traditional sense.

Now, I must say one thing about Vogel’s piece. It will certainly destroy the 
left’s contention that the tea party movement is an “astroturf” effort. For the 
entire first year of its existence the left has tried to claim, falsely, that 
the tea party movement was invented by Fox News, or is a top-down creation by 
folks like Dick Army, former Congressman and top man for FreedomWorks 
<http://www.freedomworks.org/> .

But the truth is easy for anyone that isn’t blinded by partisan hatred to see. 
The tea party groups are not coordinated in any way whatever. Even within each 
state the tea party groups aren’t connected one to the other in any meaningful 
way. In fact, that is the Republican’s main problem. They have no idea how to 
get their hands around the tea party groups and turn tea party passion into 
success at the polls for machine politicians.

But I think Vogel’s piece and perhaps even the Spider/Starfish book misses some 
important factors in gauging the tea party movement. Now I, too, have struggled 
with trying to gauge whether or not the tea party movement will have long-term 
legs in the political world but I don’t think anyone can really know what sort 
of long-term power the movement will have.

Me, I tend to fear it won’t have much long-term power. The main problem we have 
for longevity is precisely what created the tea party in the first place: 
frustration. People were frustrated with the un-American, left-wing, Euroesque 
path down which the United States went and the reaction against this left turn 
was the rise of the tea party groups. People threw their hands up against the 
Democrats, sure, but also against the GOP that proved to be Dem. lite with its 
“compassionate conservatism” which was just an excuse to spend us into a hole 
just like Democrats do.

So what is the worry? The worry is that the cynicism and frustration that gave 
birth to the tea party movement will also weigh it down and kill it. If things 
don’t change fast enough politically, will the tea party have the stamina to 
stick in the game and keep applying what pressure they can for their 
ideological druthers? Or will the tea party folks get frustrated too quickly 
and abandon their activism? I worry that it will all peter out soon after the 
2012 elections and will, in the end, be less an agent for change than it could 
be.

I certainly hope I’m wrong.

Additionally I think the main premise of the Spider/Starfish book is one that 
can easily mislead tea party folks into thinking this is the perfect 
explanation for their power, one that will assure their long-term success. In 
one case the book uses the example of the Apache people and how for 200 years 
they prevented the Spanish from seeping up from Mexico and over taking what 
would become the United States of America (this is pre-English America we’re 
talking about here). The reason the Apache were successful against the 
Conquistadors, the book explains, is because there was no Apache nation per se 
for the Spanish to conquer. The Spaniards were stymied because the hit and run, 
loosely organized, rootless Apache ran roughshod over them and thwarted Spanish 
power.

Sounds like a wonderful tale of Samson vs Goliath, no? One problem. The 
Spaniards were never able to bring the full force of their power to bear on the 
Apache because Spanish power was based in Europe, not the Americas. After all, 
what happened once the U.S. finally turned its attention to defeating the 
Apache? It was able to do so because its unyielding power was here, based 
locally, and able to be brought to bear on the smaller, disparate Apache 
structure. As to a starfish, what happens when a big, giant human pulls it out 
of the ocean and casts it casually upon the shore? It dies. Great power can, 
indeed, crush the leaderless organization, to be sure. Just being leaderless is 
no surety of success.

Look at al Qaeda. The book also likens the tea party to the somewhat amorphous 
al Qaeda movement. But al Qaeda, while not defeated, has been materially hurt 
by the might of the United States of America.

There’s one other problem with the whole concept of the leaderless structure 
and the supposed power it wields as delineated in the book. In almost every 
case in the book the “power” that the leaderless organization has was acquired 
accidentally. The book uses the example of Napster nearly toppling the music 
industry because an almost spontaneous organization of music downloaders 
crushed the old top-down business model controlled by the studios and music 
producers.

But here is the thing; no one created Napster with intention to bring down the 
music industry. It just happened. It was a great, spontaneous, accident. No one 
created the Apache people’s lifestyle with the intent to beat the Spaniards. It 
was an accident of fate. It just happened. 

I say this is a problem because a political ideology is not just a meandering 
accident. It is built on meaningful principles, history, and tradition. Further 
the sort of political change that tea party groups want to affect is based on 
American tradition, not some new, unheard of, amorphous set of ideas that have 
accidentally developed into a political power. We want to go back to tried and 
true American ideas, not remake things in some rush of creativity.

Worse, the book picks the abolition of slavery and the women’s suffrage 
movements as great examples of the starfish organization. This is also 
misleading for tea party folks. After all, abolition and universal suffrage had 
but one goal each. The tea party groups have all sorts of goals — some 
different from each other — so they don’t have a single, all consuming purpose 
to unite them as slavery abolitionists or women’s suffragists did.

Now, I almost hate to post this here at GatewayPundit. I have posted things 
like this before and invariably I get the outraged tea party guys wanting to 
claim that I wish to see them defeated, ignored or marginalized or that I am a 
shill for the GOP establishment. Nothing could be further from the truth. I 
want the tea party movement to succeed in pushing America back on the right 
track. But I’ll risk posting this here anyway because I know that this audience 
is smart enough to engage the ideas herein and approach it with logic and 
reason.

So, all this leads up to the main problem that the tea party folks have and 
that is how to affect political change. Politics, whether you like it or not, 
IS a top-down business. We elect a top man from our area and send him to the 
top headquarters in D.C. He acts the CEO for us while we act the board of 
directors and try to direct his actions. If we don’t like him, we fire him and 
elect a new CEO for our area. This is all as traditional as it gets.

The political arena is swayed by money and voting blocks. Unfortunately, the 
only way to bring those to bear is to organize a top-down effort. It cannot be 
affected by everyone looking around for someone else to take the lead. And 
this, I fear, is where the frustration will reoccur and the cynicism will 
deepen as the tea partiers throw up their hands in despair that our system can 
ever “work right” again.

And on top of all that, our system was created specifically to act slowly and 
to blunt the sometimes over reaction of “the mob,” so quick change is not 
really a feature of the American political system in the first place. Will the 
tea party movement understand that politics is for long haul? Will they “get” 
that they can’t just swoop in, make some sort of major changes, and then go 
home satisfied of a job well done finished with their activism?

This is what the left implicitly understands. They aren’t disgusted by the 
political process. They understand that this is a life-long project. The 
commies, for instance, always had a new five-year plan to topple the west. 
Alinsky understood that agitation was for the long haul. In fact, Alinsky rally 
didn’t have much else but agitation. He saw it as perpetual.

Will the tea partiers understand that they will have to gain the reins of 
old-fashioned power, will they “get” that this isn’t just a one or two election 
cycle project that will yield a return to the real America? Will they 
understand that this is not a single battle ahead of them but a 
multi-generational war that will never end?

Their enemy sure does.

If they don’t it won’t matter how many arms they can have cut off, they will 
still be ineffective and powerless. If the tea party groups don’t settle in for 
the boring, dirty, gritty world of politics, they simply won’t be able to push 
Washington back on the right track. Right now there is a lot of sound and fury 
in the tea party movement and the uprising has made politicians sit up and take 
notice. Certainly the pols are not yet too keen to anger the tea partiers. But 
unless some hard power is brought to bear, eventually politicians will realize 
that there isn’t any real power behind all the snarl of the tea partiers and 
they will start to ignore them. 

Sooner or later the tea party groups will have to step up to the plate with 
real candidates who have real (and quite old-fashioned) political 
organizations, all powered by real money.

And if they all refuse to at least step a little bit in this direction, the tea 
parties will be a hollow clang of fury signifying nothing. It will result in 
these activists sullenly going back home and the cynicism of the American 
people will deepen. If that happens we’ll all be worse off for it.

Now, certainly there will be many of you that will rail against me and claim I 
“don’t understand” the tea party movement. Some may think I am saying that I 
hope the movement fails — a claim that is absurd on its face (I did say I hoped 
I was wrong, after all). But that aside perhaps the best way to look at this is 
to see it as a reminder that politics is for the long haul, not just for an 
election or two after which all will be well.

Anyway, I find the tea party movement to be the best thing that has happened to 
the American political scene for a long, long time. The last time something 
this good happened was the Goldwater clubs that morphed into the Reagan 
revolution that helped set back liberalism for decades.

We need the next anti-liberal movement to work its magic. I am hopeful that the 
tea parties are it.

Now, I will be very interested to see what replies this posts brings, so have 
at it folks…



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to