Politics Upside Down

Posted By Victor Davis Hanson On October 9, 2010 

Suddenly the same-old, same-old does not work this year

All the old reasons why entrenched congressional representatives, senators,
and state and local officials are usually ensured reelection - the brag of
securing pork-barrel earmarked projects, boasts of years of incumbency and
insider experience, habit and rote, seniority on committees and boards -
aren't quite working this year (although they did as recently as just two
years ago).

People suddenly don't care as much that their representatives won yet
another recreation center or office building in their district named after
themselves, or that a newly paved stretch of highway is named after a
favorite congressman. Instead, to the degree politicians voted for $3
trillion more in debt the last two years or a federal takeover of health
care, they face rising and blanket voter resentment. The problem is not just
that we know the deficits are unsustainable, or that the borrowed money
spent so haphazardly (remember that Joe Biden was supposed to monitor how
the hundreds of billions were consumed?) has so far had little long-term
benefit. The problem is more a spiritual one.

I think at the heart of the tea-party revolt and public anger in general is
simply sheer disbelief at the astronomical debts, red ink that has increased
by $3 trillion in just two years - and will fall due one day mostly on a
generation that did not incur or enjoy the borrowing. People are depressed
that even a restoration of the Clinton tax rates would now still leave a
trillion in annual deficits, given the vast level of federal spending.

They are increasingly ashamed too that a great nation like the United States
is the world's greatest debtor, that we are the object of global financial
ridicule while an authoritarian government in China, flush with trillions in
cash, is admired and courted for its money. And so the public does not react
to political rhetoric and promises as they have in the past. Show us the
bottom line of balancing a budget the people instead demand.

When a once shoo-in Senator Russ Feingold, Sen. Patty Murray, or Rep. John
Dingell is in trouble, then we know the rules are changing. True, Reagan,
like Obama, nosedived in the polls in his first and second years. So did
Clinton. But in the former case, policies in 1981-3 were aimed at assuring
businesses that profit was a good thing; in the latter, remorse in 1994-5
reassured them that as well. The result was that private enterprise was
confident of only a temporary downturn, not a rewrite of the game. Not so
now: Obama, in a word, shows no signs that he wants private enterprise to
make lots of money rather than have them concede at a certain point that
they've already made enough for his tastes.

So something is different this year, as trillions of dollars sit out the
economy until the November elections. Job creators and buyers want proof
that there is an end to greater regulation, higher taxes, more
redistributive spending, cap-and-trade, and more gratuitous name-calling.

When the president says to his rallies "Don't make me look bad [in the
November election]" I think he means that he is more worried about his own
standing than the scores of congressional Democrats who both took him at his
word that his hope and change agenda was the wave of the future, and now are
suddenly deemed expendable. The presidential worry seems not about fifty or
so representatives that won't be around in January, but more his own loss of
face.

Slurs mean nothing

The media does not seem to be able to stop the rising public anger either.
The tea-partiers, as their clout grew, have gone from being ignored, to
being racists, to supposedly kindred spirits who are not really conservative
as much as protesting against the entrenched and powerful. Meanwhile, media
editorializing means very little. Newsweek after all sold for a dollar. The
New York Times is in growing percentages leveraged. Whether it is CNN or
Time, the constant is a shrinking audience.

Everything seems to be in play in this year without rules and precedent. A
six-term congressman in a safe seat can be ahead by 10 points and a month
later poll dead even. Democrats can run the most engaging ads - bragging on
voting against the Obama agenda.

What are we left with then? 

The greatest misreading of public unhappiness in recent political history.

Somehow Obama, after a brilliant campaign, thought that either America was
ready for European-style socialism or could be persuaded that it was, as if
his own election had nothing to do with McCain's lackluster campaign; the
September 15, 2008, meltdown; the Bush-Iraq war; the novelty of electing the
first African-American candidate; or the centrist, "across-the-aisle" Obama
rhetoric - but was rather an endorsement of campaign slips like "spread the
wealth" and the Pennsylvania clingers speech.

Obama also apparently concluded that the public anger with Bush was that he
was too conservative, rather than too liberal, in the sense of spending too
much money, too lax on illegal immigration, and too prone to creating new
unfunded government agencies and programs. Instead of breaking with Bush, he
simply trumped him to the nth degree.

The result is politics upside down, as fainting crowds vanished; books about
the brave new progressive age are remaindered about when they appear; and
elected majority party officials run on everything but the public's worry
over joblessness and massive debt. I cannot remember a party prepping for an
election by either ignoring its legislative record or attacking it.

A McCarthyite Attack from the Stanford Daily

Recently, the
<http://www.stanforddaily.com/2010/10/07/editorial-hoover-institution-should
-renounce-hanson's-racist-remarks/> Stanford Daily [1] accused me of being a
racist for comments on the university in general that appeared here on Works
and Days, and were later excerpted in the Wall
<http://topics.wsj.com/article/SB20001424052748703859204575526090709113292.h
tml>  Street Journal [2]. Here is the passage I wrote now in question:

Diversity is Orwellian: the university is the most politically intolerant
and monolithic institution in the country, even as it demands the
continuance of tenure to protect supposedly unpopular expression. Even its
emphases on racial diversity is entirely constructed and absurd: Latin
Americans add an accent and a trill and they become victimized Chicanos;
one-half African-Americans claim they are more people of color than much
darker Punjabis; the children of Asian optometrists seek minority and victim
status.

The Stanford Daily wrote the following:

At the risk of stating the obvious, we would like to point out this passage
for what it is: absolute trash. If Hanson wants to engage in discussion
about affirmative action or the role of race in higher education, we would
applaud that and welcome his viewpoint. But this sort of homogenous
denigration is no intellectual commentary. It is at best vitriolic
ignorance. Combining the toxic assumption that all members of an ethnicity
group act the same way with the mocking reference to "an accent and a trill"
veers dangerously into bigotry.

And then this:

Hanson's words, tragically, not only hinder this discussion, but deride
stakeholders and concerned parties with callous and shrill remarks. If he
was trying to draw attention to the topic, he has instead shifted the focus
onto himself.

Worse yet, Hanson's words reflect badly on Stanford through his association
with a research center supported by this university and housed on this
campus. The editorial board understands the Hoover Institution cannot be
held responsible for all the public statements of its scholars, but strongly
urges the institution to repudiate or, at the very least, review Hanson's
remarks. Surely, gross generalities couched in racially charged language
cannot fit with Hoover's mission.

It is worth stressing that the Hoover Institution includes preeminent
scholars in a variety of disciplines. From Nobel Laureates to former
high-level public policy officials and advisers, many of the foremost minds
at Stanford and other universities contribute to Hoover's work. These
professors offer serious academic research that adds significant value to
policy discussion and to the intellectual community on campus.

Hanson's despicable words provide the Hoover Institution the perfect
opportunity to clarify its role in American politics. Purposeful academic
research or derisive, unfounded cheap shots: which will it be? The editorial
board expects and hopes that an institution producing distinguished research
to inform policy debates will wholeheartedly reject the sort of remarks
Hanson made.

Thus, we issue this editorial as an open challenge to the Hoover
Institution. If you find fault with Hanson's grossly generalizing remarks
and wish to be a leader in the discussion of modern American universities,
then please: let us know.

If you do not, we hope you realize the damage you do to this university's
standing and to the well-being of higher education in America.

Note first that this unsigned and generally despicable editorial reflects
badly on Stanford University. It is entirely ad hominem and provides no
proof for its accusations. It simply does not address the point of my
remarks, which suggested that universities in general are Orwellian in using
racialist rubrics to attempt to correct past racism.

First, the university application of racial preferences has no definable or
consistent logic, at least any that are readily understandable to the public
that supports higher education. Preferences are not necessarily predicated
on assumed contemporary racial prejudices based on skin color or necessarily
an identity with an historically oppressed group.

Nor are racial or ethnic preferences necessarily class- or income-based.
Hence my point that some people of color, such as Punjabi students, do not
qualify for racially- or ethnically-based considerations, but those who are
in part African-American do. Are not those with Spanish surnames per se
often considered minorities for university purposes, regardless of national
origin, ethnic background, or citizenship? Do the children of professionals
qualify for special considerations based on their racial heritage? Would the
children of Barack Obama in theory qualify for affirmative action? Did a
middle-class younger Barack Obama, of mixed white and African heritage and
without direct experience with the African-American ordeal, qualify for
affirmative action - and if so, on the basis of race per se, membership in a
particular group that experienced past racism, or economic need?

My examples were not cheap, toxic, or despicable, but drawn from my own
experience with higher education over some 40 years as both student and
professor, in which tragically the university often discriminated against
students of all races and heritages by applying fossilized racial categories
that have no place in 21st-century America.

Again, the too frequent defense of using race to categorize applicants and
job seekers is to call critics racists rather than to present a logical and
consistent defense of the so often illogical and inconsistent. That simply
will not work anymore.

So I offer an open challenge to the Stanford Daily: either apologize for the
baseless slur of racism and the cheap language (e.g., "trash,"
"toxic,""despicable"), or at least show how I was in error, and that, in
fact, there are logical and consistent criteria that qualify some groups for
racial preference in admissions and hiring in the university and not others.
Second, if race is used as a criterion, what then qualifies one as belonging
to a particular targeted race or group? Does one warrant special
consideration if he is one-half, she one-fourth, they one-eight of a
particular targeted lineage? Or is the distinction merely ad hoc and
impressionistic? Does the university employ such percentages? If so, such
usage has a nightmarish tradition dating back to the antebellum South.
Simply invoking the generic idea of "diversity" does not mean, de facto,
that racial profiling should not require some concrete, explicit rationale.

These are not racist inquiries, but genuine concerns, as I wrote, that
universities themselves are race-obsessed in an increasingly multiracial
society where intermarriage, immigration, and assimilation are making race
an obsolete criterion for addressing past collective discrimination.

For the Daily to level charges as "despicable" and "cheap," then surely it
must provide proof that they are so. Note again, the anonymous authors of
the editorial did not refute anything I wrote as untrue; they only stooped
in McCarthyite fashion to invoke charges of racism and to challenge my
institution to silence my views that they found unappealing. All that is
beneath the daily newspaper of a great university.

But as a classicist and historian, I do not need lectures from the Stanford
Daily about scholarship. As someone with a long familial relationship with
Stanford dating back over 65 years, I do not need reminders about Stanford
tradition and decorum. As someone who lives at the heart of illegal
immigration from Mexico in Selma, California, with a racially diverse
extended family, I do not need lectures about campus notions of racial
insensitivity.

Just as Hoover is connected with Stanford University, so Stanford University
is affiliated as well with the Hoover Institution; each conducts itself with
logical argumentation rather than easy invective like "trash." A university
newspaper that so easily casts charges of racism and wishes to silence the
views of others is obligated to demonstrate why and how its allegations are
true. The Daily did neither.

  _____  

Article printed from Works and Days:
http://pajamasmedia.com/victordavishanson

URL to article:
http://pajamasmedia.com/victordavishanson/politics-upside-down/

URLs in this post: 

[1] Stanford Daily:
http://www.stanforddaily.com/2010/10/07/editorial-hoover-institution-should-
renounce-hanson's-racist-remarks/

[2] Wall Street Journal:
http://topics.wsj.com/article/SB20001424052748703859204575526090709113292

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to