AMERICAN JEWS AND PRESIDENT OBAMA
By Edward Klein with Richard Z. Chesnoff
http://www.richardsilverstein.com/tikun_olam/wp-content/uploads/2008/06/obam
aaipac.jpg
An in-depth look at what went wrong. More importantly, how it happened
http://www.JewishWorldReview.com <http://www.JewishWorldReview.com/> | The
Jews have three veltn (worlds): di velt (this word), yene velt (the next
world), and Roosevelt.
-Judge Jonah Goldstein, the 1945 Republican candidate for mayor of New York
City.
In the nearly 80 years since President Franklin Roosevelt launched the New
Deal with a pledge to "help the forgotten man," relations between American
Jews and the Democratic Party have been as close as lips and teeth. Even as
Jews prospered and assimilated into the mainstream of American life, most of
them remained loyal to F.D.R.'s liberal vision and refrained from following
the pattern of other affluent groups by shifting to the Republican Party.
Over the course of the past 20 elections, 75 percent of the Jewish vote has
on average gone to the Democratic presidential candidate. As the old saying
goes, "Jews earn like Episcopalians and vote like Puerto Ricans."
If further proof of this were needed, it was provided by the 2008 election
of Barack Obama. On a key issue for many Jewish voters-support for
Israel-the hawkish John McCain had an advantage over Obama, whose past
associations with the anti-Semitic Reverend Jeremiah Wright and the
Israel-bashing Columbia University professor Rashid Khalidi raised troubling
questions. Yet, when the vote was tallied, Obama trounced McCain among Jews
by a staggering 57-point margin.
"After decades of involvement in the civil rights movement by American Jews,
Obama stirred deep emotions in the Jewish community," Bret Stephens, a
deputy editor of The Wall Street Journal's editorial page, told us. "The
black-Jewish alliance was shattered in the late 1960s, and Jews have yearned
ever since to restore it. Jews felt good about voting for Obama, for not
only were they voting for a guy they agreed with and liked, but they were
also voting for a kind of redemption."
All this should give comfort to President Obama as his party heads into the
fall's hotly contested mid-term elections and struggles to hold on to its
majorities in the House and Senate. Faced with public frustration over the
flailing economy, high unemployment, massive federal deficits, and
out-of-control illegal immigration, Democratic candidates need all the help
they can get. And although Jews represent a mere 4 percent of the American
electorate, their political activism and fund-raising prowess give them
leverage in important battleground states.
There's only one hitch. Today, a sizable number of American Jews are having
some serious misgivings regarding Obama. Recent polls of the Jewish
community reflect a significant decline in support from 2008, when 78
percent of Jewish voters pulled the lever for him. According to a recent
McLaughlin & Associates poll, nearly 40 percent of Jewish voters disapprove
of the president's handling of relations with Israel, and a majority of them
would now consider voting for someone else for president.
These poll numbers do not begin to measure the depth of displeasure felt by
many Jews over President Obama's performance. Their bill of particulars
covers a wide variety of complaints, including the president's frosty
behavior toward businessmen in general and Wall Street in particular. But
what really appears to irritate American Jews is the president's roughhouse
treatment of Israel.
Obama has recently backed off from his previous harsh stance toward Israel
and he even managed to convince the Israelis and the Palestinians to engage
in direct peace talks, replacing the indirect "proximity" talks that had
been going on for more than a year. But Obama is still not entirely out of
the woods with large segments of the Jewish community. And his awkward
comments about the proposed mosque at Ground Zero-he seemed to be in favor
of the mosque before he was against it, or at least neutral about it-didn't
help.
Malcolm Hoenlein, executive chairman of the Conference of Presidents of
Major American Jewish Organizations, the coordinating body for 52 Jewish
groups, estimates that Obama may have lost the support of as much as
one-third of Jewish voters. That may overstate the case, but, as we
discovered during interviews with more than a dozen Jewish leaders, many
Jews have become so annoyed with the Obama administration that they have
closed their wallets and are seriously thinking of sitting out the 2010
election. According to an analysis of Federal Election Commission records by
The Washington Post, contributions to Democratic candidates from the
financial sector are down 65 percent from two years ago. While much of that
is due to the Obama administration's widely perceived hostility to the
business community, at least some of it is attributable to the White House's
handling of Israel.
"I started breaking with Obama 12 months ago," says Martin Peretz, editor in
chief of The New Republic. "And I know that a lot of West Coast Jews are
also having buyer's remorse. The gut of it is Israel. Will Jews mobilize for
Obama in the fall elections? They might be too embarrassed to come out
directly against him. But I'll give you one sign of the times: Chuck Schumer
[New York's senior senator] waited a year and a half before he stood up for
Israel, and he's been having trouble raising money on Wall Street." (Schumer
did not respond to repeated requests for comment.)
"The assumption on the part of the Obama administration is that, because
Jews are liberals, they simply will not vote for Republicans," says the
Hollywood billionaire Haim Saban, one of the Democratic Party's mega-donors.
"Obama can invite the 10 most prolific Jewish campaign bundlers to the White
House for a discussion, and give a wonderful speech, and he'll think that
this may resolve all his problems with American Jews. And it may. Or it may
not."
"The idea that we saw a black president in our lifetime is wonderful," says
former New York City mayor Ed Koch. "It conveyed to us that this country has
come such a long way. But I never fully accepted that Obama didn't hear his
minister [Jeremiah Wright] make those awful anti-Semitic statements over 20
years. I wanted to believe him. I willed myself to believe him.. What he has
done is break that trust. Like Humpty Dumpty, once you break it, you can't
put it together again."
The Jewish problem with Obama can be traced back to his first full day on
the job. On January 21, 2009, he summoned his national-security team to the
Oval Office and laid out a tough new policy toward Israel. According to a
source who is in touch with the situation, Obama said that, in order to make
good on his campaign promise to extricate American troops from the war in
Iraq, the U.S. had to create a grand coalition of moderate Muslim states and
Israel to isolate Iran, which has made no secret of its ambition to become
the nuclear hegemon in the Middle East.
The only way to accomplish that goal, the president said, was to eliminate
the poisonous effect of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, which provides
Iran with an excuse to stir up trouble. Thus it was a vital national
interest of the United States to stop Israel from building settlements in
the occupied West Bank and housing in East Jerusalem, and to force the
Jewish state to resolve the Palestinian problem.
Previous administrations had made similar noises about bringing peace to the
Middle East, and at first Jewish leaders weren't alarmed by the leaks
concerning a fundamental change in American policy. However, a clue to
Obama's true intentions came in March 2009, when Abe Foxman, the national
director of the Anti-Defamation League, met with the president's chief of
staff, Rahm Emanuel.
"This is Israel's moment of truth," Emanuel said, according to Foxman. "This
president is determined to make peace between Israel and the Arabs."
To many Jews, it seemed highly improbable that a brand-new president would
choose to alienate Israel, America's oldest and most loyal ally in the
Middle East. But then, in April 2009, when Obama made his first trip
overseas, he visited Turkey, a Muslim country, and during a meeting in
London he bowed to King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia. Two months later, he
returned to the area and made a landmark speech in Cairo, where he announced
his intention to seek "a new beginning between the United States and Muslims
around the world."
Understandably enough, American Jews were annoyed that the president had
failed to include Israel in his trip to the Mideast. But what rankled them
even more was that Obama seemed to adopt the Arab narrative to explain the
existence of Israel-namely, that Israel deserved to exist because of past
Jewish suffering in Europe, particularly during the Holocaust. Nowhere in
his Cairo speech did Obama mention the fact that Jews had a 3,000-year
history in the Promised Land.
There was no discernible improvement when the president called a meeting of
Jewish leaders in July. Fourteen major Jewish organizations were
represented, including J Street, the newly formed left-of-center Jewish
lobby.
"I agree with your goal to bring peace to the Middle East," Abe Foxman told
the president. "But the perception is that you're only pressuring Israel,
and not the Arabs." Foxman said the president agreed.
Someone else at the meeting said, "If you want Israel to take risks for
peace, the best way is to make Israel feel that its staunch friend America
is behind it."
"You are absolutely wrong," the president reportedly replied. "For the past
eight years [under the Bush administration], Israel had a friend in the
United States and it didn't make peace."
"I came away from the meeting being convinced that the Obama administration
has introduced a new strategy and that it's revealing itself in steps,"
Foxman told us. "Unlike other administrations, this one is applying linkage
in the Middle East. It's saying that if you only resolve the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict most of the problems in the Middle East can be
ameliorated and the lions will lie down with the lambs.
Another source who attended the meeting also told us, "All the president's
advisers on the Middle East, starting with George Mitchell, believe in
linkage, and they're telling the president you have to prove to the Arab
Muslim world that you are different from previous presidents and that you
can separate yourself from Israel, distance yourself from the settlements
issue. After all, settlements are something that American Jews don't like
anyway, so it's a win-win proposition."
The Anti-Defamation League was the first mainstream Jewish organization to
openly criticize the president on the issue of the Middle East. Soon other
groups joined in. However, the great majority of Jews remained steadfast
behind Obama's liberal agenda. They simply were not ready to criticize their
country's first African-American president, in whom they had invested so
many of their hopes and dreams.
That is where things stood until March 9 of this year, when a relatively
low-level official in the Israeli Interior Ministry issued a permit for
1,600 new housing units for Israelis in the Ramat Shlomo section of East
Jerusalem, a neighborhood that has been entirely Jewish for more than 100
years. The ill-timed announcement came the day after Vice President Joe
Biden arrived in Israel to help kick-start a round of indirect peace talks
between Israel and the Palestinians. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu immediately apologized to Biden, who accepted his expression of
regret. But Mahmoud Abbas, president of the Palestinian Authority, called
off the "proximity talks."
According to our sources, the next day at the regularly scheduled Thursday
breakfast meeting between the president and Secretary of State Hillary
Clinton, Obama made his feelings clear. He was livid. As he saw it, the
Israelis had purposely humiliated the vice president and tried to sabotage
the administration's peace plan. It was a personal affront. He instructed
Clinton to call Netanyahu and read him the riot act.
The following day, during a 43-minute harangue, Clinton delivered a set of
ultimatums to Netanyahu. Prefacing each remark with the phrase "I have been
instructed to tell you," she demanded that Israel release a substantial
number of Palestinian prisoners as a token of goodwill; lift its siege of
Gaza; suspend all settlements in the West Bank and Jerusalem; and agree to
place the question of the status of Jerusalem up front at the peace-talks
agenda.
"If you refuse these demands," Clinton told Netanyahu, according to informed
sources, "the United States government will conclude that we no longer share
the same interests."
Netanyahu bit his tongue and remained noncommittal about the American
demands, though he did eventually agree to ease the blockade of Gaza.
That same Friday, Michael Oren, the Israeli ambassador to Washington,
attended a meeting at the State Department and was given a severe
dressing-down. Someone who saw Oren that night at a dinner described him as
"shaken."
And things did not end there. Ten days later, Netanyahu was invited to the
White House, where photographers were banned from the meeting, and the
Israeli prime minister was treated less than elegantly.
The White House seemed strangely indifferent to the feelings of resentment
that this treatment of Netanyahu aroused in the Jewish community.
Furthermore, shortly after Netanyahu returned to Israel, the president
risked provoking even greater Jewish outrage by insinuating that American
troops were dying in Iraq and Afghanistan because Israelis and Palestinians
could not agree to make peace. Conflicts such as the Israeli-Arab one are
"costing us significantly in terms of both blood and treasure," the
president said.
A perception began to spread throughout the Jewish community that the Obama
administration was not only outwardly hostile to Israel but perhaps, without
even knowing it, hostile to Jews as well. This thesis was forcefully argued
by Jonathan Kellerman, the best-selling suspense novelist and a professor of
clinical pediatrics and psychology at the University of Southern
California's Keck School of Medicine.
"My personal opinion . is that the bifurcation of Israel and Judaism is
structurally fallacious," he wrote. "The Land of Israel is an essential
ingredient of Judaism practiced fully. Thus, it is impossible to be
anti-Israel and not be anti-Jewish. And in fact, the war being waged against
Israel by the Muslim world is, at the core, a religious dispute. Radical
Islamists no longer talk about Zionists; they come right out and broadcast
their goal of eradicating worldwide Jewry."
The impression of an anti-Jewish bias at the highest echelons of the Obama
administration, though unproved, was reinforced in April when James Jones,
the retired Marine Corps general who then served as Obama's
national-security adviser, began a speech at the Washington Institute for
Near East Policy with a joke that was interpreted as flagrantly
anti-Semitic.
"I'd just like to tell you a story that I think is true," Jones began. "It
happened recently in southern Afghanistan. A member of the Taliban was
separated from his fighting party and wandered around for a few days in the
desert, lost, out of food, no water. And he looked on the horizon and he saw
what looked like a little shack and he walked towards that shack. And as he
got to it, it turned out that it was a little store owned by a Jewish
merchant. And the Taliban warrior went up to him and said, 'I need water.
Give me some water.' And the merchant said, 'I'm sorry, I don't have any
water, but would you like to buy a tie? We have a nice sale of ties today.'
"Whereupon the Taliban erupted into a stream of language that I can't
repeat, but about Israel, about Jewish people, about the man himself, about
his family, and just said, 'I need water, you try to sell me ties. You
people don't get it.'
"And impassively the merchant stood there until the Taliban was through with
his diatribe and said, 'Well, I'm sorry that I don't have water for you and
I forgive you for all of the insults that you've levied against me, my
family, my country. But I will help you out. If you go over that hill and
walk about two miles, there is a restaurant there and they have all the
water you need.' And the Taliban, instead of saying thanks, still muttering
under his breath, disappears over the hill, only to come back about an hour
later. And walking up to the merchant, he says, 'Your brother tells me I
need a tie to get into the restaurant.' "
Although Jones later apologized for his gaffe, many Jews began to wonder if
there was something more behind the Obama administration's confrontational
approach toward Israel than a simple difference of policy. As a result, they
began to take a second look at Obama's past for clues to his current
behavior. In particular, they were curious as to how Chicago's bare-knuckle
politics had shaped Obama's outlook.
End of Part One
EDWARD KLEIN is a well-known writer and editor with a distinguished career
in American journalism.
After serving an apprenticeship as a copy boy for the New York Daily News,
he went on to earn a master's degree from Columbia University's Graduate
School of Journalism, which awarded him a traveling fellowship to Japan.
There, he learned to speak Japanese and traveled throughout Asia as a
foreign correspondent for United Press International. Upon his return to New
York, he joined Newsweek, where he became foreign editor and then assistant
managing editor with jurisdiction over foreign and military affairs.
>From Newsweek, he joined The New York Times. As editor in chief of The New
York Times Magazine, he led this flagship publication of the Sunday Times to
new heights of public interest and editorial excellence. During his
editorship, The New York Times Magazine won the first Pulitzer Prize in its
history.
Since leaving The Times, Edward Klein has written many articles for Vanity
Fair and other national magazines. For Parade, he wrote "Walter Scott's
Personality Parade," the most widely read column in the English language.
JWR contributor and veteran journalist RICHARD Z. CHESNOFF was Senior
Correspondent at US News & World Report, and is now a columnist at the NY
Daily News and the Huffington Post. A two-time winner of the Overseas Press
Club Award and a recipient of the National Press Club Award, he was formerly
executive editor of Newsweek International. The paperback edition of his
critically acclaimed book, "Pack of Thieves: How Hitler & Europe Plundered
the Jews & Committed the Greatest Theft in History" is now on sale.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
------------------------------------
--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list,
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]
http://www.intellnet.org
Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe: [email protected]
Unsubscribe: [email protected]
*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods,
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,'
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/
<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To change settings via email:
[email protected]
[email protected]
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[email protected]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/