Why would any half-way intelligent, civilized human being wish to find an
accommodation with sharia?

 

Where's Churchill?

 

B

 

http://www.economist.com/node/17249634?story_id=17249634
<http://www.economist.com/node/17249634?story_id=17249634&fsrc=rss>
&fsrc=rss

 

Sharia in the West

Whose law counts most?

Finding an accommodation between Islamic law and Western legal codes is
difficult. But there are some ways forward 

Oct 14th 2010 

http://www.economist.com/sites/default/files/images/images-magazine/2010/10/
16/ir/20101016_ird001.jpg

ANY Western politician, judge or religious leader desiring instant fame or a
dose of controversy has an easy option. All you need do is say "sharia" in
public.

Sharron Angle, a Republican candidate for the Senate, proved the point when
she suggested that Frankford, Texas, and Dearborn, Michigan, were both
subject to a sharia regime, as a result of the "militant terrorist
situation" that existed in those places. Critics retorted that Frankford,
after its absorption by Dallas, no longer existed as an administrative unit.
Dearborn's mayor, Jack O'Reilly, tartly told her that his town's 60 churches
and seven mosques were flourishing happily under American jurisdiction. But
for some tea party fans, she was guilty at worst of slight exaggeration.

Less weirdly, but just as controversially, Archbishop Rowan Williams, leader
of the world's 80m Anglicans, will never be allowed to forget saying in
February 2008 that some accommodation between British law and sharia was
"inevitable". Lord Phillips, then England's senior judge, drew equal ire by
adding that sharia-based mediation could have some role as long as national
law held primacy.

It is easy to see why the word sharia has emotional overtones, especially
today. The appalled reaction to the case of Sakineh Ashtiani, an Iranian
woman who has been sentenced to death by stoning for adultery, has stoked a
global campaign for her acquittal. The sentence was suspended last month,
but her fate looks dicey. She could still face execution on a murder charge.

Such cases reflect only one part of sharia: the system of corporal and
capital punishments such as stoning for adultery, death for murder or
apostasy (abandoning Islam), whipping for consuming intoxicants or the
cutting off of a hand for theft. Muslims themselves disagree over how, if at
all, these penalties should be practised in the modern world. Tariq Ramadan,
a prominent European Muslim thinker, caused a furore in 2003 when he
suggested that stoning and other physical punishments should be "suspended".
Hardline Islamists regarded that as backsliding. Nicolas Sarkozy (then the
interior minister, now the president of France) pointed out that the
formulation could imply a future resumption of physical punishment.

Horrifying as these punishments might be to modern sensibilities, there is
no prospect of their exercise in any Western country. Muslims living in the
West may (as has sometimes happened) take the "law" into their own hands by
killing an apostate. But that counts as murder pure and simple. 

Where sharia poses genuine dilemmas for secular countries with big Muslim
minorities is not in the realm of retribution but in its application to
family matters such as divorce, inheritance and custody. English-speaking
countries boast a strong tradition of settling disputes (commercial or
personal) by legally binding arbitration. This already includes non-secular
institutions such as longstanding rabbinical tribunals in Britain and many
other countries, or Christian mediation services in North America. Now
Islam-based outfits are entering the market.

Perhaps inevitably, the procedures and general ethos of Muslim mediation are
very different from those of a secular court. Many of Britain's 2m or so
Muslims come from socially conservative parts of South Asia, such as rural
Kashmir. The practice of sharia-based family law both reflects and to an
extent mitigates that conservatism. A network of sharia councils-whose two
main founders come from purist schools of Islam, the Deobandis and the
Salafis-has offered rulings to thousands of troubled families since the
1980s. Much of their work involves women who have received civil divorces
but need an Islamic one to remarry within their faith. The councils can
overrule a husband's objections. Few would decry this. But the woman may
well also forfeit her mahr (marriage settlement). Critics call that unfair.
They also complain that, when faced with domestic violence, these councils
merely administer a scolding or prescribe an "anger-management" course,
rather than the safe house and prosecution that the state-run system should
offer.

Still, British sharia arbitrators may alleviate a peculiarly British woe.
Some Muslim Britons contract an Islamic marriage (but not a civil one) and
then fail to confer on the bride the marriage settlement that would be
obligatory in say, Pakistan. If the union sunders, such men then escape
their obligations under both English law and Pakistani custom. The councils
advise against such deviousness.

A rival set-up, the Muslim Arbitration Tribunals, now offers dispute
resolution in half a dozen British cities. Founded in 2007 by followers of
the Barelvi school of South Asian Islam, they are less strict than the
Deobandis. But when asked to divide up an intestate's assets, they follow
Islamic law, giving daughters half as much as sons. The tribunals say they
operate under the Arbitration Act of 1996. That makes rulings binding once
both parties have given authority to the arbitrator. 

In Canada legislation framed with secular arbitration in mind but used by
religious courts is a hotter issue than in Britain. In 2003 a Toronto
lawyer, Syed Mumtaz Ali, proclaimed an "Islamic Institute of Civil Justice"
and urged Muslims to use it. The province of Ontario reacted in 2005 by
stripping religious tribunals (including Jewish and Catholic ones) of legal
force. It also stiffened rules on arbitrators' qualifications and
record-keeping. Quebec tightened its law too.

That has not stopped devout Canadian Muslims from seeking religious guidance
on family and personal matters. As Harvey Simmons, a York University
professor, wrote last month: "Because religious arbitration now takes place
mainly outside the scrutiny of the Ontario courts, there is no way to tell
whether women are being treated well or badly by informal religious
arbitration."

In the United States both secular and religious arbitration are firmly
established, operating under a Federal Arbitration Act that gives robust
standing to the procedure but also allows the parties to counter-appeal to
ordinary courts on certain grounds (though America's church-state separation
stops courts hearing arguments about doctrine). Christian and Jewish
arbitration is well-organised. The Muslim variety is lower-key and less
formal, but so far not (barring outbursts from tea-partistas like Ms Angle)
especially controversial.

The legal and political systems in continental Europe are most prescriptive
and leave little room for cultural exceptions, at least in theory. But
knotty issues of Islamic family law have arisen in courts all over Europe.
Many residents of France and Germany remain citizens of their native
countries. Courts usually deal with foreign passport-holders in the light of
their home countries' law, while also upholding the principle that outcomes
must not violate "public order" (ie, outrage local opinion).

One tricky issue is polygamy. French law explicitly outlaws it, and denies
second wives the right to join their husbands in France (though if a second
wife dies, her children are sometimes allowed to join their French-based
father). Another is a form of divorce known as talaq in which a man simply
renounces his wife. That has no standing in French or German law, but when
both parties to a failed marriage freely testify that a talaq has taken
place in some Islamic country, European courts have been forced to
acknowledge the fact. 

When high legal principles clash with a quite different social reality, the
results are inevitably messy. Islamic rules on religiously mixed marriages
have harsh consequences for many couples in Italy, for example. Islam
prohibits Muslim women from marrying non-Muslim men (the reverse, however,
does not apply). Italian marriage rules require a woman from Algeria or
Egypt, say, to obtain her embassy's consent, which is likely to be refused
unless the would-be husband converts (or "reverts", in Islamic parlance).

In most parts of Europe migration has made sharia a pressing issue. But in
one European region, by a quirk of history, a community with deep local
roots lives under Islamic family law. This is northern Greece, where a
Muslim community of at least 100,000 was allowed, under the 1923 Lausanne
treaty, to retain cultural autonomy, including widespread jurisdiction over
family matters for local muftis. 

Nothing stops a Greek Muslim from going to the state courts, but communal
pressure impels most people to settle family affairs through the muftis. The
community, which is sensitive to perceived slights from the state, would
react badly to any change. "People see sharia as their cultural right and
they would be angry if it was taken away," says Ali Huseyinoglu, a doctoral
student from northern Greece. "If Muslim tribunals are starting in Britain,
it would be odd to abolish sharia in a place where it has been applied since
Ottoman times."

 

 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to