http://www.jihadwatch.org/2010/10/fjordman-medieval-muslim-scholars--.html

 

Medieval Muslim Scholars -- Their Contributions and Shortcomings
by Fjordman

Those who have read my essays know that I can hardly be called an apologist for 
Islam. I don't like Islam at all and make no attempt to hide this fact, but I 
also don't like dishonesty. I believe the so-called "Golden Age of medieval 
Islamic science" is absurdly overblown these days. Nevertheless, if you read 
history closely there is still room for granting some respect to a small number 
of scholars from a Muslim background who did decent work for their time.

I believe in giving credit where credit is due and have therefore, after 
spending years reading extensively about scientific history, prepared a list of 
the top dozen Muslim scholars before the Industrial Revolution who in my view 
deserve some respect for their work. I have only considered individuals who 
were at least nominally Muslims, not Christians, Jews or others who happened to 
live under Islamic rule. This means, for instance, that I have evaluated 
al-Razi, who came from a Muslim background although he wasn't personally a 
believing Muslim at all, but not Moses Maimonides (1135-1204), a Jewish rabbi 
and physician.

The indisputable number 1 on my list is Ibn al-Haytham (ca. 965-1039), known 
under the Latinized name Alhazen in Western literature. He was born in Basra in 
present-day Iraq but spent many years in Cairo, Egypt. He was a prolific writer 
on many aspects of science and natural philosophy. His multivolume Book of 
Optics (Arabic: Kitab al-Manazir‎) was the single most important work on optics 
to appear anywhere between Greco-Roman Antiquity and the Scientific Revolution 
in Europe. His treatise contained a substantially correct model  
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/738111/Ibn-al-Haytham> of vision: 
the passive reception of light reflected from other objects, not an active 
emanation of light rays from the eyes, and he combined mathematical reasoning 
with some forms of experimental verification. He provided the best model of 
human vision before Kepler in the early 1600s developed the first recognizably 
modern understanding of the retinal image.

David C. Lindberg indicates in the book Theories of vision - From al-Kindi to 
Kepler that although he relied heavily on scholarly contributions made by the 
ancient Greeks, his synthesis was nevertheless fresh and original: "Alhazen was 
neither Euclidean nor Galenist nor Aristotelian - or else he was all of them. 
Employing physical and physiological argument, he convincingly demolished the 
extramission theory; but the intromission theory he erected in its place, while 
satisfying physical and physiological criteria, also incorporated the entire 
mathematical framework of Euclid, Ptolemy, and al-Kindi. Alhazen thus drew 
together the mathematical, medical, and physical traditions and created a 
single comprehensive theory."

Deciding who should be ranked as number 2 was slightly trickier, but in the end 
my vote goes to the Persian physician and alchemist Muhammad ibn Zakariya Razi 
(ca. AD 860-925). He certainly belongs among the top five. Al-Razi 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/492607/al-Razi> , or Rhazes in 
Latin, came from present-day Iran. He was a freethinker in all things who never 
uncritically accepted the conclusions of any alleged scholarly or religious 
authority, past or present. He was a capable physician for his time, recognized 
the need for sanitation in hospitals and has been credited with being the first 
to clearly distinguish between the highly contagious viral diseases smallpox 
and measles.

Number 3 is Muhammad al-Khwarizmi (ca. AD 780-850), who authored the most 
significant works on algebra to appear between Greco-Roman Antiquity and 
Renaissance Europe. Al-Khwarizmi 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/317171/al-Khwarizmi>  helped 
introduce Indian or Hindu-Arabic numerals from India to the Middle East and 
later to Europe. Latinized translations of his name and one of his book titles 
live on as the terms algorithm and algebra. According to David C. Lindberg, his 
Algebra "contains no equations or algebraic symbols, but only geometrical 
figures and Arabic prose, and it would not be recognized as algebra by a 
mathematics student of the twenty-first century. Its achievement was to deploy 
Euclidean geometry for the purpose of solving problems that we would now state 
in algebraic terms (including quadratic equations)." The work circulated in 
Europe and contributed in the long run to the development of a truly modern 
algebra there.

Number 4 is Abu Musa Jabir ibn Hayyan (ca. AD 721-815), or Geber in Latin, 
probably the most gifted Middle Eastern alchemist/practical chemist of the 
Middle Ages. He has been credited with a number of advances and was perhaps the 
first person to prepare nitric acid.

 

Number 5 is Ulugh 
<http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/%7Ehistory/Mathematicians/Ulugh_Beg.html>  
Beg (ca. 1394-1449), a grandson of the brutal and influential Islamic conqueror 
Timur, often known as Tamerlane (1336-1405). His father had captured the city 
of Samarkand in Central Asia where Ulugh Beg proceeded to build an astronomical 
observatory. With improved instruments and careful observations, he made a new 
star catalogue with unprecedented accuracy for its time and even corrected some 
errors in Ptolemy's calculations.

 

Number 6 is the Persian scholar Omar 
<http://www-history.mcs.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Khayyam.html>  Khayyam 
(1048-1131), also renowned for the Rubaiyat poems attributed to him. He 
compiled astronomical tables and contributed to reform of the Persian calendar 
<http://www-istp.gsfc.nasa.gov/stargaze/Scalend.htm>  by introducing ideas from 
the Hindu one. The result was superior to the Julian calendar and at least 
comparable in accuracy to the Gregorian one. Khayyam was the first to solve 
some cubic equations and to see the equivalence between algebra and geometry. 
Further progress in this field did not take place in the Islamic world, only in 
Western Europe.

 

Number 7 is the Persian polymath Abu Rayhan Biruni, or al-Biruni (973-ca. 
1050), "perhaps the most far-ranging scientific writer of the Islamic world." 
Highly unusual for a Muslim scholar he knew several non-Muslim languages well 
and wrote about another society, India, with rare objectivity by Islamic 
standards.  Al-Biruni "had 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/66790/al-Biruni> varying degrees of 
proficiency in a number of languages, including Khwarezmian (an eastern Middle 
Iranian language), Persian, Sanskrit, Hebrew, and Syriac, in addition to the 
Arabic in which he wrote."

 

Number 8 is the Persian physician and philosopher Ibn Sina (ca. 980-1037), or 
Avicenna <http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/45755/Avicenna>  as he was 
called in Latin translations. He wrote widely on many topics, from physics to 
Aristotelian philosophy, and composed the Book of the Cure, an encyclopedia of 
general and natural philosophy. While not very original he was a competent 
physician for his time, and his Canon of Medicine was used as a medical 
textbook for centuries in the Middle East and Europe.

 

Number 9 is the North African historian Ibn Khaldun 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/280788/Ibn-Khaldun>  (1332-1406), 
generally considered to be a forerunner of a number of disciplines in the 
social sciences. He developed one of the earliest nonreligious philosophies of 
history, contained in his work the  
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/397776/The-Muqaddimah> Muqaddimah 
("Introduction") where he sought to explain the basic factors in the historical 
development of the Islamic countries. Yet he was limited by his traditional 
Islamic contempt for non-Muslim cultures.

 

Number 10 is  <http://www.jihadwatch.org/2010/10/goog_353498644> al 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/318068/Yaqub-ibn-Ishaq-as-Sabah-al-Kindi>
 -Kindi (ca. AD 801-870), the first notable Muslim philosopher, although his 
reputation in the Middle East was eventually eclipsed by that of al-Farabi (ca. 
AD 878-950). Al-Kindi flourished in Baghdad in the ninth century where he wrote 
on many subjects ranging from medicine, optics, mathematics, Indian arithmetic 
and basic cryptography to the manufacture of swords. The attempt to reconcile 
Islam with Greek philosophy was to last for several centuries, but ultimately 
proved unsuccessful due to persistent religious resistance.

 

Number 11 is Ibn Rushd 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/45595/Averroes>  (1126-1198), or 
Averroes, an Andalusian Muslim who was born in Córdoba in modern-day Spain and 
died in Marrakesh in Morocco. His attempts to integrate Islamic traditions with 
ancient Greek thought and Aristotelian philosophy were largely ignored in the 
Islamic world but were ironically studied in Latin Christian Europe. He faced 
trouble for his freethinking ways and is today hailed as a beacon of 
"tolerance," yet he was also an orthodox jurist of sharia law and served as an 
Islamic judge in Seville. He approved, without reservation, the killing of 
heretics in a work that was entirely philosophical in nature.

 

Number 12 on my list is the Egyptian astronomer Ibn Yunus (ca. 950-1009). "In 
<http://www.hps.cam.ac.uk/starry/ibnyunus.html>  many respects his astronomical 
works have a modern appearance; many of the parameters which he used in his Zij 
are much superior to those of his predecessors and he is also known for his 
meticulous calculations and attention to detail. . . . His observations are 
considered so reliable that some of the thirty eclipses reported by him were 
used by Simon Newcomb in the nineteenth century, in determining the secular 
acceleration of the moon."

 

A lunar crater has been named in Ibn Yunus' honor and another one in honor of 
Ibn al-Zarqali, Latinized as Arzachel, an eleventh-century Andalusian 
astronomer who was partly responsible for the so-called Toledan Tables. These 
were accurate for their time and were later translated into Latin and used in 
Europe. The mathematician al-Battani 
<http://www-history.mcs.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Al-Battani.html>  (ca. AD 
850-929) made measurements of the stars and planets, and the Persian astronomer 
and mathematician Abul Wafa 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/2127/Abul-Wafa>  (AD 940-998) did 
some notable work in trigonometry, to name just a few others.

 

Those mentioned above would constitute my personal choice for the top dozen. 
Their relative ranking can be debated and a few other possible contenders might 
be considered, for instance the Syrian-born physician Ibn al-Nafis (1213-1288) 
who worked in hospitals in Damascus and Cairo. He was the first person we know 
of to describe the pulmonary, or lesser, circulation of the blood between the 
heart and lungs, but the significance of his insight was overlooked and he 
avoided the practice of human dissection because of the sharia, the Islamic 
religious law.

 

Abu al-Qasim Khalaf ibn al-Abbas al-Zahrawi (ca. 936-1013), known in the West 
as Abulcasis or Albucasis, was an Andalusian physician born near the city of 
Córdoba in what was then Islamic-ruled Spain. He combined Middle Eastern and 
Greco-Roman Classical teachings with his own innovations and became "Islam's 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/2117/Abu-al-Qasim>  greatest 
medieval surgeon." As a matter of fact he was "virtually the only significant 
physician in the Islamic world who had practical experience with surgery. 
Surgery was neglected also by Rhazes and Avicenna."

 

What kind of conclusions can we draw from this list? The first one is the 
disproportionate number of Persians as well as the strong presence of 
freethinkers and highly unorthodox Muslims, sometimes combined in the same 
person. This was the case with Omar Khayyam, whom author Ibn Warraq in the book 
Leaving Islam calls the "Poet of Doubt." Ibn Khaldun himself admitted that "It 
is strange that most of the learned among the Muslims who have excelled in the 
religious or intellectual sciences are non-Arabs with rare exceptions."

 

It is interesting to notice that virtually all rationalists within the Islamic 
world were at odds with Islamic orthodoxy and frequently harassed for this. 
Whatever contributions they made were more in spite of Islam than because of 
it. While some, like Ibn Khaldun, were orthodox Muslims who supported violent 
Jihad against others to establish Islamic global supremacy, al-Razi apparently 
didn't believe a single word of the Islamic faith. Indeed, he was so hostile to 
all revealed religions that it is remarkable that he wasn't killed as an 
apostate from Islam.

 

In a few cases the ethnic identity of the individual is somewhat unclear from 
the historical sources. Geber's personal life is shrouded in mystery, but 
according to the  
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/298619/Abu-Musa-Jabir-ibn-Hayyan> 
Encyclopædia Britannica he was born in Iran and died in Iraq, well within the 
reach of Persian cultural impulses. It is a fair guess that he was a Persian, 
but his ethnic background is not beyond dispute. Al-Khwarizmi's ancestors 
presumably came from the Khwarizm region south of the Aral Sea in Central Asia. 
Although he spent years in Baghdad he probably wasn't an Arab.

 

It is striking to notice that not a single notable scholar throughout all of 
Islamic history ever lived and worked in the Arabian Peninsula, the cradle of 
Islam. Even those who, like Alhazen, were fluent in Arabic or had Arabic as 
their first language lived in far older centers of urban civilization such as 
Mesopotamia (Iraq), the Levant and Egypt. It is possible that al-Kindi's 
ancestors came from the Peninsula, but he himself was born in Iraq. He is 
called "the philosopher of the Arabs" precisely because the Arabs didn't 
produce many philosophers. The Arabian Peninsula has consistently been one of 
the least creative regions on the entire planet for as long as Islam has 
existed, despite the fact that it enjoys a favorable location in the middle of 
Eurasia and annually receives numerous pilgrims from different parts of the 
world.

 

Another notable feature is the total absence of any Turks among the top 
scholars. There is a persistent myth that the Scientific and Industrial 
Revolutions happened only because Europeans "plundered" other continents. This 
is easily disproved since there is little correlation between which countries 
had extensive colonial empires and which developed sophisticated 
scientific-industrial economies. Portugal held quite large colonies and 
participated extensively in the transatlantic slave trade, yet it is one of the 
poorest countries in Western Europe, in sharp contrast to Switzerland or 
Finland which have no colonial histories.

 

The Spanish brought much silver back to Eurasia from their colonies in Latin 
America, which had admittedly often been extracted by the natives under harsh 
conditions, but Spain never developed a leading role in science. Italian 
scientists were much more prominent than Spanish ones from the 1200s to the 
1800s although "Italy" as a state did not exist until the 1860s. Arguably the 
greatest astronomical revolution in recorded history took place in Western 
Europe from the 1500s to the 1700s, and this wasn't caused by "European 
colonialism."

 

Copernicus was born in Poland, which did not then nor later have any 
significant military presence outside of Europe. Tycho Brahe came from tiny 
Denmark and ended his life in the city of Prague in what is today the Czech 
Republic. Kepler was from Germany, which did not exist as a state until 
centuries later and even then held rather marginal colonies. When Galileo was 
born, the Ottoman Empire ruled much of the Mediterranean, and Turkish and North 
African pirates regularly raided the Italian Peninsula. England did eventually 
gain a vast empire, but it did not yet have this when Newton was a student. All 
of these men were greater scholars than any of those who have existed in the 
Islamic world at any point in its history.

 

If plundering other peoples had been the key to making scientific advances then 
Turkish Muslims should have been among the leading lights of science for many 
centuries, yet throughout its entire existence the Ottoman Empire contributed 
next to nothing to mathematics, science or practical engineering. If conquering 
distant lands was what triggered the Scientific Revolution then the world would 
now watch in awe as advanced Mongolian space probes explored the outer reaches 
of our Solar System. This clearly isn't the case.

 

The most extreme proof that wealth isn't a sufficient cause to generate 
scientific advances is oil-rich Saudi Arabia, which since the mid-twentieth 
century has received enormous sums from Westerners and Asians due to a simple 
geological accident. Yet despite what may amount to the greatest transfer of 
unearned wealth in human history the country hasn't given mankind a single 
useful invention, nor any great art or music that uplifts the spirit. The 
Saudis have used their massive wealth to buy gold-plated toilets and sponsor 
Jihad terrorism abroad.

 

Another point to emphasize is that the peaks of the European scientific 
tradition are not only much more numerous, but also much higher than those of 
the Muslim one. If scientists could be compared to mountains then the European 
and Western tradition would constitute the Himalayas, by far the highest and 
most massive mountain range on Earth. Newton, the highest peak in this 
tradition, would represent Mount Everest; the medieval Middle Eastern tradition 
might correspond to a regional mountain range and Alhazen a peak of maybe 
3,000-4,000 meters. That's respectable, but it still falls far short of the 
towering size of Mount Everest.

 

When I checked it, the English-language entry on Alhazen at the popular, 
Internet-based amateur encyclopedia Wikipedia stated that "The  
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_Optics> Book of Optics has been ranked 
alongside Isaac Newton's Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica as one of 
the most influential books in the history of physics." This is clearly 
hyperbole. Isaac Newton's Principia from 1687 is the single most important work 
ever published in the world history of science; only Albert Einstein's general 
theory of relativity from 1915 is comparable to it. Yes, Alhazen was good and 
deserves our respect, but he was not on the level of a Newton, Einstein or 
Galileo.

 

In Charles Murray's book Human Accomplishment, Alhazen enjoys a good 
medium-level ranking in physics with a score in the 20s. This is by far the 
highest of any scholar from the Islamic world, which is accurate in my view, 
but that still doesn't bring him to the global top 30 list, which is heavily 
dominated by European scientists plus some Ashkenazi Jews and is topped by 
Newton and Einstein, tied for the maximum score of 100. The same is even more 
true regarding Geber vs. the top-ranking Antoine Lavoisier in chemistry; Rhazes 
vs. Louis Pasteur in medicine or Charles Darwin and Aristotle in biology; Ulugh 
Beg vs. Galileo Galilei, Johannes Kepler, William Herschel, Pierre-Simon 
Laplace, Nicolaus Copernicus, Ptolemy or Tycho Brahe in astronomy; and Muhammad 
al-Khwarizmi or Omar Khayyam vs. Euler, Newton, Euclid, Gauss, Fermat, Leibniz 
or Descartes in mathematics. At least one, if not several, orders of magnitude 
separate these men's respective individual achievements.

 

It is true that the legacy of ancient Greek scholars in mathematical proof, 
geometry, logic and the creation of natural philosophy - what we today would 
call scientific theory - as far as we know exceeded that of any other ancient 
culture. Nevertheless, the Greeks did not create modern science. Western 
Europeans did, from the sixteenth, seventeenth and eighteenth centuries onward. 
While Greek logic was one factor contributing to this transformation, Europeans 
could only make this breakthrough after they exceeded the contributions of the 
Greeks and left their flawed physical theories behind. A similar transition 
never took place in the Middle East, nor anywhere else for that matter. As for 
practical engineering, rather few contributions were made by medieval Muslims 
that would have surprised the ancient Romans.

 

The top-ranking individual on my Muslim list, Alhazen, for all practical 
purposes constituted the culmination of ancient Greek theory. Given that 
Chinese optical studies stagnated and that East Asians suffered in the sciences 
by not having easy access to superior Greek geometry, the Middle East had in 
all likelihood produced the world's leading optical theorist by the eleventh 
century AD. Yet curiously, very few further advances were made there in that 
field after his death; almost all of them were made in Europe, from photography 
to spectroscopy.

 

Western Europeans by the late 1200s AD employed glass lenses to create the 
first indisputable eyeglasses for the correction of eyesight. The knowledge of 
how to combine fine glass lenses was extended around the year 1600 to create 
the earliest known microscopes and telescopes. Observations in telescopic 
astronomy were then used to make the first reasonably accurate measurements of 
the speed of light, which was shown to be very great, but finite.

 

As Toby E. Huff shows in his 2010 book Intellectual Curiosity and the 
Scientific Revolution: A Global Perspective, although the telescope was 
transmitted to China, Mughal India and the Ottoman Empire, those civilizations 
did not respond quite as Europeans had done to the new instrument. In Europe, 
curiosity fueled a great burst of innovations in microscopy, mechanics, optics, 
pneumatics and electrical studies. Newton's revolutionary new synthesis, which 
unified terrestrial and celestial physics (the two were believed by the 
ancients to be entirely separate) with the law of universal gravitation, had 
immense implications for modern society.

 

As late as the year 1800, "light" was thought to consist only of those types of 
rays visible to the unaided human eye. Then from 1800 to 1900, European 
scientists successively discovered other kinds of radiation such as infrared, 
ultraviolet, radio waves, X-rays and gamma rays, all moving at the speed of 
light. James Clerk Maxwell's equations demonstrated that visible light is just 
one of many forms of electromagnetic radiation, a conceptual breakthrough far 
greater than anything ever made by the ancients. With the quantum revolution in 
the early decades of the 1900s and the emerging dual wave-particle model of 
light, European scientists had done more in the space of merely five 
generations to advance our understanding of the basic physical properties of 
light than all other known civilizations on Earth had done combined during the 
preceding five thousand years of recorded human history. Essentially all of the 
astronomical observations and physical insights underlying Einstein's work, 
from Newton's concept of gravity to increasingly accurate measurements of the 
speed of light, evolved exclusively within the European scientific tradition, 
as did the mathematical language needed to describe these new theories with 
probability theory, calculus and non-Euclidean geometry.

 

Ibn Warraq in his books is critical of Islam, but at the same time gives proper 
credit to scholars within the Islamic world who deserve it, a sentiment which I 
happen to share. One of them is the Persian physician al-Razi. In his modern 
classic Why I Am Not a Muslim, Ibn Warraq suggests that al-Razi "was perhaps 
the first true chemist as opposed to an alchemist." He considered the Koran to 
be an assorted mixture of "absurd and inconsistent fables" and was certainly a 
freethinker, yet despite his fine qualities he appears to have been a committed 
alchemist who believed in transmutation and in the possibility of turning base 
metal into gold.

 

When speaking of "alchemy" we should not think that all of it was nonsense, 
only that what we would view as occultism was not clearly separated from real 
chemical knowledge. Chinese alchemists invented gunpowder, which was an 
eminently useful practical invention even if nobody at the time could properly 
explain exactly how it worked. Likewise, practical alchemists from Korea and 
India to Mesoamerica had been involved in medicine, clothing and cosmetics as 
well as serious metallurgy for thousands of years. Is it possible, then, to 
stipulate a specific date for when scientific chemistry was born, clearly 
distinct from ancient alchemy?

 

While such a dating is admittedly difficult, a major turning point was 
undoubtedly when chemists/alchemists had evolved something approaching a modern 
definition of what constitutes a chemical element. In that case it makes little 
sense to speak of chemistry prior to the mid-eighteenth century. Before that, 
scholars from China and Japan via the Middle East to Europe had traditionally 
talked about water, air, earth and fire as "elements." If you believed that 
gold and iron were not elements in their own right but consisted of more 
fundamental ones such as earth in different ratios, then thinking that you 
could turn base metal into gold by changing the ratios of those primary 
elements was erroneous, but not necessarily stupid.

 

Chemistry was born when scholars stopped talking about "water" and "air" as 
elements and instead started talking about "oxygen" and "hydrogen," by showing 
that water is not by itself an element but a compound of two chemical elements 
- oxygen and hydrogen - and that the air that we breathe consists of a mixture 
of different gases, not a single substance. This transition took place in 
Western Europe in the late 1700s, and only there. We might say that chemistry 
was born in Europe in the late eighteenth century, enjoyed its childhood and 
adolescence there during the nineteenth and reached maturity in the West in the 
twentieth century; claiming that this event happened a thousand years earlier 
with the relatively modest advances made by medieval Muslims or others at that 
time cannot be considered correct.

 

In addition to scientific disciplines, Murray in Human Accomplishment created 
rankings in Western music and Western art, Indian literature, Japanese 
literature, Chinese literature, Chinese painting and Japanese art, as well as 
listings of Indian, Chinese and Western philosophy, respectively, but no 
ranking for Islamic philosophy. A separate philosophy inventory was not 
prepared for Korea or Japan because so much of Korean, Japanese and Vietnamese 
philosophy derives from Chinese sources, or from India in the case of Buddhism.

 

While Chinese philosophy is in content often quite different from its European 
counterpart the Chinese certainly have a very extensive and well-developed 
philosophical tradition. By contrast, much of the philosophical writings in the 
Islamic world were simply commentaries on ancient Greek works, and even that 
was frequently considered suspect. Strictly speaking, there is no such thing as 
"Islamic philosophy" in the narrow sense of the word because Muslim scholars 
concentrated primarily on interpreting the Koran and religious texts. Western 
scholars read the Bible, yes, but they did many things besides that and created 
a vast literature of political and economic philosophy that is virtually 
non-existent in the Islamic world.

 

In Chinese philosophy, Confucius (551-479 BC) ranks far ahead of anybody else 
as the single most influential thinker in East Asian history, followed by many 
later interpreters of Confucian thought such as Zhu Xi, Menciusand Xunzi. The 
only other individual close to Confucius' level is Laozi or Lao-Tsu ("Old 
Master"), the shadowy figure who may have been a rough contemporary of 
Confucius and is traditionally viewed as the first thinker of Daoism. Aristotle 
comes out on top in Western philosophy, but not as dominant as Confucius in 
China.

 

In Indian philosophy, Adi Shankara in the eighth century AD added system to the 
haphazard insights of the ancient Upanishads, which had been transmitted orally 
for many centuries. He became the leading exponent of the Advaita Vedanta 
School of philosophy, whose thoughts still form the mainstream of modern 
Hinduism. Only in fourth place do we encounter Siddhartha Gautama or Gautama 
Buddha, who was either a contemporary with Socrates in the fifth century BC or 
a younger contemporary of Confucius. The Buddha was the founder of a major 
religion or philosophy whose total influence throughout much of Asia exceeded 
that of Hinduism (and for that matter Confucianism), but his ideas were 
secondary within India itself:

 

"The men at the top - Confucius, Sankara, and Aristotle - are where they are 
because each, in some important sense, defined what it meant to be Chinese, 
Indian, or Western. Confucian ethics, aesthetics, and principles of statecraft 
became China's de facto state religion in -3C and remained so for another two 
thousand years. As the man who shaped the Advaita Vedanta school of Hinduism, 
Sankara has pervasively shaped Indian thought down to the present day. In the 
West, there is more ambiguity. Plato preceded Aristotle, Aristotelian thought 
owes extensively to Plato, and it was, after all, Plato rather than Aristotle 
of whom Alfred North Whitehead famously said that all of Western philosophy is 
his footnote. And yet in the end Aristotle had had the more profound effect on 
Western culture. Some of Plato's final conclusions, especially regarding the 
role of the state, are totalitarian. In contrast, Aristotle's understandings of 
virtue, the nature of a civilized polity, happiness, and human nature have not 
only survived but have become so integral a part of Western culture that to be 
a European or American and hold mainstream values on these issues is to be an 
Aristotelian."

 

Only painting had a consistent tradition of named artists in China, which means 
that valuable contributions in sculpture and ceramics are not included. For the 
same reason, the only inventory for music is the Western one topped by 
Beethoven and Mozart, not because good music hasn't been made in other cultures 
but because only the European one had an extensive tradition of named 
individual composers. In Chinese painting, the scholar, painter and 
calligrapher Zhao Mengfu (1254-1322) is tied for first place with the artist 
and poet Gu Kaizhi (ca. AD 344-406).In Japanese art, the top score of 100 is 
achieved by Sesshu Toyo (1420-1506), a Zen Buddhist monk inspired by Chinese 
landscape paintings and a master of the style of monochrome ink painting, 
although he did use color skillfully later in his career.

 

In Chinese literature, the leading figure is without question the poet Du Fu(AD 
712-770). Murray notes that "Du Fu is barely known in the West. He is not only 
ranked first here but, according to those who are in a position to evaluate 
such things, was one of the greatest poets ever, anywhere. The problem for 
Western readers is that the aesthetic nuances and layers of meaning in great 
Chinese poetry cannot be retained in even the best translations." After him 
comes his contemporary Li Bai (AD 701-762) followed by yet another poet, Bai 
Juyi(AD 772-846). The Tang Dynasty was apparently a particularly strong period 
for Chinese poetry.

 

The Japanese literature inventory is characterized by a large number of writers 
who receive substantial attention rather than by a few dominant figures, as was 
the case with India. Number one is Basho (1644-1694), "by consensus Japan's 
greatest poet and the master of haiku; Chikamatsu (1653-1725), by consensus 
Japan's greatest dramatist, writing mostly for the bunraku (puppet theatre); 
Murasaki Shikibu (c. 978-1014), author of The Tale of Genji, by consensus 
Japan's greatest work of literature (and the highest ranking woman in any of 
the inventories); and Saikaku (1642-1693), writer of brilliant erotic tales and 
famous for his speed-writing of haikai, humorous linked-verse poems that were 
the source of haiku."

 

Charles Murray also prepared a separate inventory for Arabic literature, which 
includes some individuals who wrote in Persian. Al-Tayyib Ahmad ibn Husayn 
al-Mutanabbi (AD 915-965), born in present-day Iraq and widely hailed as the 
greatest poet in the Arabic language, tops ahead of Abu Nuwas (ca. AD 750-814). 
In addition to Arabic, Abu Nuwasknew Persian from his mother and was admired by 
Persian poets such as Omar Khayyam and Hafez for his style and for writing 
about wine, sex and subjects that were frowned upon by orthodox Muslims.

 

The blind Arab poet al-Ma'arri(973-1057) in third place led a more secluded 
life, although he, too, was a freethinker who questioned many Islamic dogmas. 
Number four is Imru' al-Qays, a shadowy figure that may have lived in the fifth 
or early sixth century AD and was the most famous Arabian poet of pre-Islamic 
times, remembered for his Mu'allaqat collection. Number five is Abu Tammam(ca. 
AD 800-845), born in Syria to Christian parents. Just making it to the top 
twenty list is the Moroccan Berber explorer Ibn Battuta(1304-1369). HisRihlah 
(Travels) describes his extensive travels from West Africa to Southeast Asia.

 

As the case of Imru' al-Qays demonstrates, even ethnic Arabs from the Arabian 
Peninsula admit that poetry has pre-Islamic roots in their culture. Arabic has 
been praised as a language well-suited for poetry, but the predominance of 
poetry is also because "Islamic literature operated under two theological 
constraints. Drama was considered to be a representational art and forbidden. 
Realistic fiction was considered to be a form of lying, and also forbidden."

 

By universal acclaim, the greatest poet in Indian history was the Classical 
Sanskrit dramatist Kalidasa 
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/310169/Kalidasa> . Little is known 
about him, but he probably lived in the Gupta period, perhaps in the fifth 
century AD, and may have been a Brahman (priest). Among the works ascribed to 
him, many of which are informed by Hindu mythology, is the drama 
Abhijnanasakuntala ("The Recognition of Sakuntala"), which was admired by 
Goethe and others when it was translated into European languages in the late 
1700s, and the lyric Meghaduta ("Cloud Messenger").

 

There never was anything resembling "theater" in the Islamic world. Neither is 
this region renowned known for its artistic traditions. Yes, fine Persian rugs 
can constitute works of art, but such handicraft traditions often have 
historical roots that predate the Islamic conquests. Regarding calligraphy, 
Muslims could make some fine works in this category, but we should remember 
that East Asians - not just the Chinese, but the Japanese, Koreans and 
Vietnamese, too - often excelled in this art form simultaneously with creating 
extremely refined works of painting and sculpture as well as exquisite poetry. 
On the whole, Islam served to severely restrict most possible forms of artistic 
expression. It would be accurate to state that Islam inhibited artistic 
creativity more than any other major religious tradition in the world.

 

In Western art, Michelangelo tops with no close competitor. As art historian 
Ernst Gombrich, normally a man of measured words, indicates, Michelangelo's 
ceiling of the Sistine Chapel in Rome is a masterpiece so astonishing and 
unique that it is hard to understand how a single person could have made it, 
especially considering that he was a better sculptor than painter:

 

"It is very difficult for any ordinary mortal to imagine how it could be 
possible for one human being to achieve what Michelangelo achieved in four 
years of lonely work on the scaffolding of the papal chapel. The mere physical 
exertion of painting this huge fresco . . . is fantastic enough. . . . But the 
physical performance of one man covering this vast space is as nothing compared 
to the intellectual and artistic achievement. The wealth of ever-new 
inventions, the unfailing mastery of execution in every detail, and, above all, 
the grandeur of the visions which Michelangelo revealed to those who came after 
him, have given mankind a quite new idea of the power of genius."

 

Those who have been fortunate enough to visit the Vatican and see the great 
Church of Saint Peter's in Rome cannot fail to be awed by the beautiful 
paintings and sculptures it contains. The Roman Catholic Church has received a 
lot of criticism over the years and has sometimes deserved this, but it should 
also be given credit for its positive contributions. It is unthinkable in Islam 
that religious leaders in the centers of Mecca or Medina would hire artists 
like Michelangelo or Raphael to decorate mosques with sculptures and paintings, 
as Catholic popes did. Muslim militants no doubt want the Sistine Chapel to 
suffer the same fate as countless un-Islamic works of art such as the destroyed 
Buddha status of Central Asia. If the ongoing Islamization of Europe continues, 
a dark day may come when they have their way.

 

Likewise, music wasn't widely used for religious services; there is no Islamic 
equivalent to Johann Sebastian Bach, who filled Lutheran churches in Germany 
with magnificent compositions designed to uplift the faithful. He gave God 
credit for his achievements, which included The Art of Fugue and the Toccata 
and Fugue in D minor, one of the most played works in the organ repertoire, The 
Well-Tempered Clavier and the Brandenburg Concertos.

 

To sum up, we can make the following points:

 

Advances made during the Middle Ages in the Islamic-ruled world were relatively 
modest even at the best of times and declined to almost nothing thereafter. 
Those contributions that did exist were made primarily by non-Arabs, and often 
by unorthodox Muslims who were harassed for their freethinking ways. Their 
scholarly contributions were primarily based on ancient Greek or other 
non-Islamic works and rarely moved much beyond these conceptually. They were 
made predominantly during the early centuries of Islamic rule, while large 
non-Muslim communities still existed in these countries, and normally in 
centers of urban culture that predated Islam by thousands of years. The Arabian 
Peninsula, the cradle of Islam, has contributed next to nothing of value to 
human civilization throughout Islamic history. Persians, who retained a few 
links with their pre-Islamic heritage after the conquests, produced some decent 
scholars, whereas Turks, who identified almost entirely with Islam after their 
conversion, produced practically none of any significance. If we combine these 
various factors, a very clear picture emerges: The rather modest - now often 
exaggerated - contributions made by certain Middle Eastern scholars during the 
Middle Ages were generally made in spite of Islam, not because of it. Orthodox 
Muslims rejected the Greek heritage.

 

On the other hand, while some minor advances were made in spite of Islam, 
tremendous damage was done to pre-existing non-Muslim cultures from India, 
Central and Southeast Asia to Europe that was directly caused or inspired by 
core Islamic religious teachings and texts.

 

A researcher from Denmark, Tina Magaard 
<http://fjordman.blogspot.com/2005/09/islam-is-most-warlike-religion.html> , 
spent years analyzing the original texts of different religions, from Buddhism, 
Christianity and Judaism to Sikhism. On the basis of a straight-forward reading 
of them she concluded that the Islamic texts are by far the most warlike among 
the major world religions. They encourage terror to a greater degree than the 
original texts of other faiths. "The texts in Islam distinguish themselves from 
the texts of other religions by encouraging violence and aggression against 
people with other religious beliefs to a larger degree. There are also 
straightforward calls for terror. This has long been a taboo in the research 
into Islam, but it is a fact that we need to deal with," says Magaard. There 
are many dozens of verses in the Koran explicitly calling for fighting and 
armed struggle against people of other faiths. "If it is correct that many 
Muslims view the Koran as the literal words of God, which cannot be interpreted 
or rephrased, then we have a problem. It is indisputable that the texts 
encourage terror and violence. Consequently, it must be reasonable to ask 
Muslims themselves how they relate to the text, if they read it as it is."

 

At the end of the day it is hard to pinpoint exactly what kind of positive 
cultural, scholarly or artistic contributions, if any, Islam by itself has 
brought to mankind. The ancient Greeks borrowed the alphabet from the 
Phoenicians, medical and artistic ideas from the Egyptians and finally 
mathematics and planetary astronomy from the Mesopotamians; this was one of the 
most significant external impulses to the Western scientific tradition 
throughout its history, more fundamental than anything that came out of the 
Islamic-ruled Middle East.

 

Generally speaking, in ancient times it was an advantage for Greeks to be close 
to the Middle East, which partly explains why they were among the first 
Europeans to create an urban, literate culture. During the Middle Ages, the 
Middle East gradually went from being a global center of civilization, which it 
had been for thousands of years, into the global center of anti-civilization it 
is today. Suddenly, being close to the Middle East was a serious disadvantage. 
This massive transformation took place after the Islamic conquest, which is 
hardly coincidental.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to