Pilot to TSA: 'No Groping Me and No Naked Photos'

by  <mailto:[email protected]> Michael Roberts


 

        

 

 

October 15, 2010 - My name is Michael Roberts, and I am a pilot for
ExpressJet Airlines, Inc., based in Houston (that is, I still am for the
time being). This morning as I attempted to pass through the security line
for my commute to work I was denied access to the secured area of the
terminal building at Memphis International Airport. I have passed through
the same line roughly once per week for the past four and a half years
without incident. Today, however, the Transportation Security Administration
(TSA) agents at this checkpoint were using one of the new Advanced Imaging
Technology (AIT) systems that are currently being deployed at airports
across the nation. These are the controversial devices featured by the media
in recent months, albeit sparingly, which enable screeners to see beneath
people's clothing to an extremely graphic and intrusive level of detail
(virtual strip searching). Travelers refusing this indignity may instead be
physically frisked by a government security agent until the agent is
satisfied to release them on their way in what is being touted as an
"alternative option" to AIT. The following is a somewhat hastily drafted
account of my experience this morning.

As I loaded my bags onto the X-ray scanner belt, an agent told me to remove
my shoes and send them through as well, which I've not normally been
required to do when passing through the standard metal detectors in uniform.
When I questioned her, she said it was necessary to remove my shoes for the
AIT scanner. I explained that I did not wish to participate in the AIT
program, so she told me I could keep my shoes and directed me through the
metal detector that had been roped off. She then called somewhat urgently to
the agents on the other side: "We got an opt-out!" and also reported the
"opt-out" into her handheld radio. On the other side I was stopped by
another agent and informed that because I had "opted out" of AIT screening,
I would have to go through secondary screening. I asked for clarification to
be sure he was talking about frisking me, which he confirmed, and I
declined. At this point he and another agent explained the TSA's latest
decree, saying I would not be permitted to pass without showing them my
naked body, and how my refusal to do so had now given them cause to put
their hands on me as I evidently posed a threat to air transportation
security (this, of course, is my nutshell synopsis of the exchange). I asked
whether they did in fact suspect I was concealing something after I had
passed through the metal detector, or whether they believed that I had made
any threats or given other indications of malicious designs to warrant
treating me, a law-abiding fellow citizen, so rudely. None of that was
relevant, I was told. They were just doing their job.

        

Eventually the airport police were summoned. Several officers showed up and
we essentially repeated the conversation above. When it became clear that we
had reached an impasse, one of the more sensible officers and I agreed that
any further conversation would be pointless at this time. I then asked
whether I was free to go. I was not. Another officer wanted to see my
driver's license. When I asked why, he said they needed information for
their report on this "incident" - my name, address, phone number, etc. I
recited my information for him, until he asked for my supervisor's name and
number at the airline. Why did he need that, I asked. For the report, he
answered. I had already given him the primary phone number at my company's
headquarters. When I asked him what the Chief Pilot in Houston had to do
with any of this, he either refused or was simply unable to provide a
meaningful explanation. I chose not to divulge my supervisor's name as I
preferred to be the first to inform him of the situation myself. In any
event, after a brief huddle with several other officers, my interrogator
told me I was free to go.

As I approached the airport exit, however, I was stopped again by a man whom
I believe to be the airport police chief, though I can't say for sure. He
said I still needed to speak with an investigator who was on his way over. I
asked what sort of investigator. A TSA investigator, he said. As I was by
this time looking eagerly forward to leaving the airport, I had little
patience for the additional vexation. I'd been denied access to my workplace
and had no other business keeping me there.

"Am I under arrest?" I asked.

        

"No, he just needs to ask you some more questions."

"But I was told I'm free to go. So. am I being detained now, or what?"

"We just need to hold you here so he can."

"Hold me in what capacity?" I insisted.

"Detain you while we."

Okay, so now they were detaining me as I was leaving the airport facility.

We stood there awkwardly, waiting for the investigator while he kept an eye
on me. Being chatty by nature, I asked his opinion of what new procedures
might be implemented if someday someone were to smuggle an explosive device
in his or her rectum or a similar orifice. Ever since would-be terrorist
Richard Reid set his shoes on fire, travelers have been required to remove
their footwear in the security line. And the TSA has repeatedly attempted to
justify these latest measures by citing Northwest flight 253, on which Umar
Farouk Abdulmutallab scorched his genitalia. Where, then, would the
evolution of these policies lead next?

"Do you want them to board your plane?" he asked.

"No, but I understand there are other, better ways to keep them off.
Besides, at this point I'm more concerned with the greater threat to our
rights and liberties as a free society."

        

"Yeah, I know," he said. And then, to my amazement, he continued, "But
somebody's already taken those away."

"Maybe they have," I conceded, watching the throng of passengers waiting
their turn to get virtually naked for the federal security guards.

As a side note, I cannot refrain here from expressing my dismay and
heartbreak over a civil servant's personal resignation to the loss of civil
liberty among the people by whom he is employed to protect and serve. If he
no longer affirms the rights and freedom of his fellow citizens, one can
only wonder exactly what he has in view as the purpose of his profession.

The TSA investigator arrived and asked for my account of the situation. I
explained that the agents weren't allowing me to pass through the
checkpoint. He told me he had been advised that I was refusing security
screening, to which I replied that I had willingly walked through the metal
detector with no alarms, the same way I always do when commuting to work. He
then briefed me on the recent screening policy changes and, apparently
confused, asked whether they would be a problem for me. I stated that I did
indeed have a problem with the infringement of my civil rights and liberty.

His reply: "That's irrelevant."

It wasn't irrelevant to me. We continued briefly in the conversation until I
recognized that we were essentially repeating the same discussion I'd
already had with the other officers and agents standing by. With that
realization, I told him I did not wish to keep going around and around with
them and asked whether he had anything else to say to me. Yes, he said he
did, marching indignantly over to a table nearby with an air as though he
were about to do something drastic.

        

"I need to get your information for my report," he demanded.

"The officer over there just took my information for his report. I'm sure
you could just get it from him."

"No, I have to document everything separately and send it to TSOC. That's
the Transportation Security Operations Center where we report."

"I'm familiar with TSOC," I assured him. "In fact, I've actually taught the
TSA mandated security portion of our training program at the airline."

"Well, if you're an instructor, then you should know better," he barked.

"Really? What do you mean I 'should know better'? Are you scolding me? Have
I done something wrong?"

"I'm not saying you've done something wrong. But you have to go through
security screening if you want to enter the facility."

"Understood. I've been going through security screening right here in this
line for five years and never blown up an airplane, broken any laws, made
any threats, or had a government agent call my boss in Houston. And you guys
have never tried to touch me or see me naked that whole time. But, if that's
what it's come to now, I don't want to enter the facility that badly."

        

Finishing up, he asked me to confirm that I had been offered secondary
screening as an alternative "option" to ATS, and that I had refused it. I
confirmed. Then he asked whether I'd "had words" with any of the agents. I
asked what he meant by that and he said he wanted to know whether there had
been "any exchange of words." I told him that yes, we spoke. He then turned
to the crowd of officers and asked whether I had been abusive toward any of
them when they wanted to create images of my naked body and touch me in an
unwelcome manner. I didn't hear what they said in reply, but he returned and
finally told me I was free to leave the airport.

As it turned out, they did reach the chief pilot's office in Houston before
I was able to. Shortly after I got home, my boss called and said they had
been contacted by the TSA. I suppose my employment status at this point can
best be described as on hold.

It's probably fairly obvious here that I am outraged. This took place today
(now yesterday, when I wrote all this down), 15 October 2010. Anyone who
reads this is welcome to contact me for confirmation of the details or any
additional information I can provide. The dialog above is quoted according
to my best recollection, without embellishment or significant alteration
except for the sake of clarity. I would greatly appreciate any
recommendations for legal counsel - preferably a firm with a libertarian
bent and experience resisting this kind of tyrannical madness. This is not a
left or right, red or blue state issue. The very bedrock of our way of life
in this country is under attack from within. Please don't let it be taken
from us without a fight.

Malo Periculosam Libertatem Quam Quietum Servitium

Michael S. Roberts
3794 Douglass Ave.
Memphis, TN 38111
901.237.6308
 <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected]

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to