http://www.consultancyafrica.com/index.php?option=com_content
<http://www.consultancyafrica.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&;
id=573:celebrating-50-years-of-independence-an-evaluation-of-political-insta
bility-and-security-in-nigeria&catid=60:conflict-terrorism-discussion-papers
&Itemid=265>
&view=article&id=573:celebrating-50-years-of-independence-an-evaluation-of-p
olitical-instability-and-security-in-nigeria&catid=60:conflict-terrorism-dis
cussion-papers&Itemid=265 

Celebrating
<http://www.consultancyafrica.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&;
id=573:celebrating-50-years-of-independence-an-evaluation-of-political-insta
bility-and-security-in-nigeria&catid=60:conflict-terrorism-discussion-papers
&Itemid=265>  50 years of independence: An evaluation of political
instability and security in Nigeria

Written by Kingsley Orievulu

Sunday, 17 October 2010 08:08

 

Nigeria celebrates its independence day on 1 October 2010, marking its
golden Jubilee as an independent state. This is by no means a mean feat,
especially as the country is on course to consolidate democracy. However,
this journey has not been an easy one as the country battles to be
recognised as a strong state. Since independence, it has been riddled with
gross instability and tension in terms of politics and conflicts - indeed
the whole crisis of nation-building. Being a very populous country, with
more than 150 million people of different ethnic and tribal groups, each
with a unique approach to life, the country finds itself in a dilemma of
options. The goal to unite these "nations" and entrench this "imagined
community" called Nigeria has been quite challenging. History has shown that
this task is quite enormous and dangerous; hence, even in this epoch - the
Fourth Republic - the state keeps on battling with the issues inherent in
its quest to create a single united Federal Republic of Nigeria.

This article will, therefore, briefly evaluate Nigeria's nation-building
project as the country marks its 50th anniversary of independent governance
from colonialism. It examines the extent to which the country really claims
to be independent, especially with the preponderance of violent conflicts
and political instability. It re-examines issues that have plagued the state
before and after independence, as well as continuing challenges to its
nascent democracy - the phenomenon of military dictatorship, ethnicity and
religion; struggles for resource control and oil revenue; and the present
squabbles of leadership roles (for example, Nigeria versus Northern
interests in the People's Democratic Party (PDP)). Election violence is
another huge trend in the Nigerian political arena, coupled with the
glorified power to rig elections. 


Reminiscence of Nigeria's past


Nigeria only came into existence in 1914 through the amalgamation of the
Northern and Southern protectorates (by Lord Frederick Lugard) that were
hitherto separate colonies. The division of the country into three regions -
Northern, Western and Southern - submerged smaller ethnic groups into the
three major ethnic groups, namely: Hausa/Fulani, Yoruba and Igbo. This
implied that the minorities were de facto excluded from full political
participation and prone to marginalisation and exploitation. The 1958
Willink Commission Report(2) made an enquiry into the fears of Nigerian
minorities prior to independence as methods of allying them. Indeed this was
one of the major pointers to the problem of national integration in Nigeria,
and provided the context for Nigerian federalism.

The legacies of colonialism are vivid in the stratification of the
socio-political structure in Nigeria and led to huge ethnic animosity both
before and after independence. This included violence that politics. The
long span of military dictatorship (1966 - 1999) marked the dark days of
Nigerian politics, and its legacies still influence present day politics in
a great measure. The civil war of 1967 to 1970 was a clear indication of a
country divided by ethnic and economic interests. The interplay of greed and
grievances; the quest to establish state sovereignty; and the drive to
entrench a state that never really existed, by means of military might, were
culminated in the bloody civil war where reinforce the view that the concept
of a unified Nigeria exists only in principle.(3) Hence the long span of
political instability characterised by sporadic violence (ethno-religious)
especially in the North; violent struggles in the Niger Delta for control of
resources; electoral violence and other security issues that have remained
challenges to the task of nation-building in Nigeria.


50 years of political instability and insecurity: challenges to
nation-building 


The Nigeria Biafra civil war was the bloodiest conflict in Nigerian history.
The issues latent in this civil war border much on the whole hullaballoo of
national integration. Ethnicity was the major issue pronounced in the
conflict, but it remains clear that issues of economic marginalisation and
greedy contents were critical in this light. Political analysts argue that
in a state, where ethnicity is a pre-eminent issue, there is a great
propensity of violent conflicts, especially when there is mutual suspicion
or what they describe as a strategic dilemma.(4) This was basically the case
in the heydays of the Nigerian civil war as Igbos who lived in the North
were constantly attacked and killed by ethnic bigots. This trend thus led to
the move by the then Governor of the Eastern region to secede after earlier
calls for redress from the Federal Government had failed. The causes of the
civil war remain the unsettled squabbles between the Hausas and Igbo ethnic
groups. In politics, they are incompatible; at war, tribally, and
ideologically, the battle for political and ethnic supremacy ruled. The
political parties in the heydays of post-independence were symbolic of
Northern chauvinism as the names portrayed: Northern People's Congress
(NPC), National Convention of Nigeria Citizens (NCNC) and the Action Group
(AG). These were made up of factions from the North, East and West.

The emergence of the military in Nigerian politics wrote an entirely new
history for Nigerian politics and its governance mechanisms. It hindered the
state to develop as a democratic polity by stifling political activities and
deliberations during its long reign. One of its most grievous blows to
Nigerian democracy and political stability was the failed transition to
civilian rule in 1993, an event always referred to by the date of June 12(5)
in Nigeria. It was the annulment of the presidential election that truly
reflected the power of the electorate in Nigeria by the then dictator
General Ibrahim Babangida. The immediate reaction was steady violence(6) in
many parts of the country that culminated in the massacre of people,
especially in the western region, by military forces. This and many other
methods of military might to get things done have ensured a system of
military obedience instead of democratic deliberations. This is possibly the
root of the culture of violence and politics of bitterness even after
military rule, referred to by Nigerians as the military elements of civilian
rule.

Violent uprisings and carnages have also characterised the Nigerian
political environment since independence. Notable incidents include the 1980
Maitatsine crisis in Kano state, 1987 and 1999 Kafanchan crisis, 2000 Kaduna
crisis, and the sharia crisis in Jos and Kano in 2001. Many other covered
with religious propaganda, leading to the murder of thousands in cold blood.
Unfortunately, the country has never been able to tackle these problems
because the whole ethno-regional cum religious politics fundamentally
appears to be a structural issue of which state leadership is an integral
part.

Election violence and electoral malpractices are basically the fruit of
politics in a winner-take-all strategy. Violence during elections is a
normal phenomenon and the use of political thugs and para-military agents to
perpetuate this violence also portrays the win-at-all cost syndrome in
Nigerian politics. This trend is unfortunate because it has eaten deep into
the very heart of Nigerian politics of which the country's leadership is a
part.

Response to the agitation of resource control has been appalling, and the
repressive means by which the country's leadership has handled the situation
has culminated in the upsurge of militancy in the Niger Delta. Ironically,
most of these militants were ex-political thugs and assassins who worked for
and were armed by political groups to undertake so-called dirty jobs. It is
thus difficult to exert control over them when they become wild, especially
under the guise of a genuine struggle for the socio-economic and political
emancipation of the Niger Delta. 

In recent times, Nigeria has emerged as a terrorism haven in the eyes of the
international community. The (failed) Christmas day bomber, the resurrection
of the Boko Haram sect in the North, and other growing Muslim fundamentalist
elements emerging in (the north of) Nigeria not only pose security concerns
for the country and the international community, but are themselves huge
symptoms of state weakness. These are clear in the porous borders,
corruption, Al-Qaeda's interest in Africa as a whole, and the growing rate
of anti-Western sentiments in the mostly Muslim dominated northern Nigeria.
Furthermore, these issues will continue to pose serious questions for the
future of Nigeria as it reflects upon its achievements and marks its 50th
independence anniversary.


Attending to the challenges of a strong state: Where is Nigeria now?


Presently, the persistent question of national integration is seemingly the
most difficult. It is indeed the source and/or cause of the country's
political instability. The Federal character of a nation's(7) constitution
establishes citizenship rights for all, but creates room for indigenes as
opposed to settlers. Indeed, it portents a trend of opportunities,
privileges and exclusion for indigenes and non-indigenes. Though it has not
resulted in too many crises in other parts of the country, Jos - the Plateau
state - has become the epicentre of recent struggles between settlers and
indigenes, and has recorded tremendous violence that has been described in
recent times as genocide.(8) It shows how difficult it has been for the
state to really assert itself as a strong one. Dealing with this whole
situation of political instability and security has remained too cumbersome
for the state, as these issues impinge on the very character of politics in
Nigeria. It interacts with ethno-religious and election violence, resource
related conflicts or militancy, and indeed the drive towards consolidating
the whole democratic project. 

At the moment, the state appears to have lost ground in its drive towards
establishing itself as a force to be reckoned with in terms of political
stability. Though it is coasting on the successful transition from one
civilian rule to another in 2007, and hoping to achieve an additional feat
by means of a further transition process come 29 May 2011, it is important
to note that it has fallen short of religious conflicts that continually
besiege the country - reinforcing the fundamental animosity between ethnic
groups. These incidents in the North occur as often as possible because the
state lacks the political will to actually stamp out this ethnic bigotry
that is tied to religion and used to attain political goals.

Beside the incessant unrest in the North, the South has become a haven for
kidnappers, looters, militants and cult groups that violently terrorise the
region. Hence, while the struggle for socio-economic and political
emancipation is genuine, many criminal elements bank upon the same struggle
to unleash terror on the state through the aid of political godfathers and
cabals. Militancy has thus become an occupation that young people apply for
since unemployment is the state of affairs while militancy becomes the quick
route to affluence. It is quite pitiful that many of these militants are
employed and empowered militarily to engage in election rigging, political
intimidation and other extra judicial (illegal) activities by prominent
figures in the Government. In this light, they enable the destabilisation of
the political environment, while these leaders claim to be fixing things. 

Furthermore, the fatal drive for unlimited access to the national capital
has been a major driving force against the call for resource control in
Nigeria. While the Niger Delta region suffers the brunt of oil exploitation
and ecological degradation, it is denied full control of the revenue
accruable from oil. Besides that, it is offered a meagre 13% in the
derivative formula while unemployment, infrastructural decay, and poverty
remain on the hike. These are grounds for the 2011 referendum to be held on
the issues of resource control and Federalism. However, the state has
remained adamant because it appears to be in the hands of political elites
who only think of redistributing the wealth of the nation along their
patronage and clientele networks to the detriment of the general populace.
This is an unfortunate trend for a state that claims to be a "big brother"
in Africa.

Trends of electoral violence in Nigeria are so devastating that one wonders
how the next elections can be better off, because politicians believe that
they must win at any cost. The last elections in 2007 were generally marred
by sporadic violence condemned by the international community, of and which
the president acknowledged himself upon taking over office. It is quite
amazing that the then president - Yar'adua - failed to resign even after
acknowledging that he was not elected fairly into office. This shows the
height of the quest to acquire power in Nigerian politics at whatever
expense; thus, even Nigeria can be sacrificed by its politicians in order to
attain power. This too has been unhealthy for the whole quest for
nation-building.

Again, the security situation seems worse by the day, and the most recent
incident of the Nigerian-born suicide bomber became an eye opener for the
arms chair spectator Nigerian who, despite the trend of violence, still
believes that Nigeria is a safe country. True, the Nigerian military may be
well furnished to stabilise things when called into action, but the entire
security situation sometimes goes beyond them, and even indicts some of
them. In the crisis in Jos, the security chief was accused of inefficiency
and conniving with Muslims to kill Christians. This may or may not be true,
but it case of an ex-police commissioner in Bauchi state and his alleged
involvement with the Boko Haram sect.(9) The resurgence of this sect and its
threat to attack Western interests in Nigeria portends another major
security issue that the Nigerian state seems unable to resolve at this point
in time.

Finally, the forth coming elections foretell significant agitation for
Nigeria as it heads to the poles. The incumbent president - Goodluck
Jonathan - who was undecided with regards to running in the next elections,
finally declared his availability as a presidential candidate. The Northern
region that was meant to have two terms by the dictates of the PDP
gentleman's agreement seemed to have lost it - no thanks to the untimely
death of President Umar Musa Yar'adua. With Jonathan in the running, the
tendency is that the North fears that a minority ethnic region is taking
over power, and being from the Niger Delta region, he may be perceived to
carry the region's agenda. This may spell another period of political unrest
should he be (re)elected next year. 


Conclusion: where does Nigeria go from here?


At this juncture, Nigeria is faced with the huge challenge to assert itself
as a strong political entity. It is faced with the test of democratic
consolidation, and these challenges continue to present themselves in the
guise of violence and instability. However, it is exacerbated by the nature
of politics in the state and the motivation of politicians who are in
leadership positions. Nation-building is an excruciating task that demands
strong and effective institutions and structures that will elicit confidence
among the citizenry.(10) This will make for an effective state to present a
rallying point for all the groups in the country. 

However, at the moment, the only unifying factor in Nigeria is sports, while
politicians are more inclined to different primordial cleavages and
redistributing wealth instead of creating it. These are hard questions that
the state faces as it marks its anniversary. Indeed, Nigeria can come out of
this challenge as a stronger political force and a better democracy if its
drive towards nation-building is more genuine in order to eliminate the
negative angles to ethnic heterogeneity and the politics of bitterness. As
it marks its 50thindependence anniversary, it is a time for introspection
and re-evaluation to the extent to which the dividends of democracy can
really be seen in the life of ordinary Nigerian citizens.

NOTES:

(1) Contact Kingsley Orievulu through Consultancy Africa Intelligence's
Conflict and Terrorism Unit ( [email protected] This
e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled
to view it ). 
(2) 'The Willink Commission Report', Digitised by The AdakaBoro Centre in
collaboration with the Community Defence Law Foundation (CDLF), 1958,
http://www.adakaboro.org <http://www.adakaboro.org/thewillinkcomm> .
(3) Chukwuemeka, O., 1975. Ethnic identity, political integration, and
national development: The Igbo diaspora in Nigeria. The Journal of Modern
Africa, 13(3), pp. 399-413.
(4) Lake, D.A. and Rothchild, D., 1996. Containing fear: The origins and
management of Ethnic Conflict, International Security, 22(2), pp. 41-75.
(5) Ukiwo, U., Democratic consolidation in Nigeria", Journal of Modern
African Studies, 41(1), pp. 115 -138.
(6) Obadare, E., 1999. Democratic transition and political violence in
Nigeria, Africa Development, xxiv (1 & 2), pp. 200-219.
(7) Note that the concepts - nation and state - are used interchangeably in
this work to refer to the country and/or its leadership. They are not
conceptually differentiated in this work as is vivid from their application
here.
(8) Christopher, M., "Genocide Alert for Nigeria", Elsewhere in Africa,
2010, http://www.operationbrokensilence.org/
<http://www.operationbrokensilence.org/?p=3063> .
(9) Onuoha, F., 2010.The Islamic challenges: Nigeria's Boko Haram crisis
explained, African Study Review, 19(2), pp. 54 -67.
(10) Young, C., 1982. Nationalising the third-world state: Categorical
imperative or mission impossible? Polity, 15(2), pp. 161-181.

 
<http://www.consultancyafrica.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&;
id=573:celebrating-50-years-of-independence-an-evaluation-of-political-insta
bility-and-security-in-nigeria&catid=60:conflict-terrorism-discussion-papers
&Itemid=265> 


 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to