Obama Causing America's Stature in the Middle East to Deteriorate


Heavy handed U.S. intervention has stalled the Arab-Israeli peace process


By  <http://politics.usnews.com/topics/author/mortimer_zuckerman> Mortimer
B. Zuckerman   US News

 

Why did the Palestinians terminate the
<http://politics.usnews.com/opinion/mzuckerman/articles/2010/10/15/obama-cau
sing-americas-stature-in-the-middle-east-to-deteriorate_print.html>
Arab-Israeli peace talks? The justification cited was the Israeli refusal to
extend the moratorium they had put on construction in the settlements. It is
a phantom excuse, the product of President Obama's heavy-handed
intervention.

It is never a good idea to expect parties in conflict to negotiate in the
glare of publicity. Attitudes are struck to appease partisans, and they
impact negatively on the "private" talks. Why Palestinian President
<http://politics.usnews.com/opinion/mzuckerman/articles/2010/10/15/obama-cau
sing-americas-stature-in-the-middle-east-to-deteriorate_print.html> Mahmoud
Abbas pulled out is itself a piece of grandstanding that does not serve the
Palestinians, since in Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu they have a
leader who can deliver. Netanyahu has a strong parliamentary coalition and a
high degree of public support. He has already made a public commitment to an
independent Palestinian state, and he is the first Israeli prime minister to
commit to a moratorium on all settlement construction.

Both the Israelis and Palestinians have negotiated for almost 20 years
without settlement construction becoming a fundamental impediment. A peace
agreement was achieved with Egypt without prohibiting settlements. The
Palestinians signed the Oslo accords without a moratorium on settlements and
even acknowledged that Israel would be building on the West Bank, not to
mention that the Israelis evacuated all the settlements in Gaza. To this
day, all of the Israeli construction put together doesn't even cover 2
percent of the West Bank. And this doesn't take into account that Netanyahu
was clearly prepared to consider maintaining, at least informally, a partial
moratorium in the form of limiting building solely to agreed-on blocks that
would be retained by Israel in any final peace agreement. This was hardly
the first time Israel responded to American calls for a moratorium in the
hope of enticing Palestinians to agree to talks. President Carter induced
then Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin to agree to a three-month
settlement freeze during the Camp David negotiations. It made no difference
to the Palestinians; they just kept on refusing to negotiate.

So why should the settlements have become the one issue to kill the talks?
The key reason is that from the very beginning of his presidency,
<http://politics.usnews.com/opinion/mzuckerman/articles/2010/10/15/obama-cau
sing-americas-stature-in-the-middle-east-to-deteriorate_print.html> Obama
put the construction in the settlements at the center of his Middle East
strategy. It was the original sin that has hamstrung the possibility of
successful talks. Public advocacy of the freeze not only put Israel in a
bind, but it also put the Palestinians in an even tighter bind, giving both
little room to maneuver. When Obama spoke repeatedly for a construction
freeze in the West Bank as a public condition for the renewal of talks, it
turned the settlement freeze from a dignified wish into a threshold demand
that needed to be met in full. It also set a bar that made it impossible for
the Palestinians to compromise. Abbas cannot be less Palestinian than the
U.S. president.

This wasn't the only American miscalculation. Having gotten Israel to agree
to a 10-month moratorium, why did the United States tolerate Abbas's
spending the first nine months equivocating? Then the president publicly
demanded an extension ahead of the 10 months, thereby rewarding the
Palestinian Liberation Organization for its delay.

The effect of all this was to put the Israeli prime minister into a box,
limiting his choices to a humiliating capitulation or direct confrontation
with the United States. If he had continued the freeze without any
Palestinian reciprocity, he would have been seen as betraying the settlers
and his previous commitment, too. His pledge to limit the moratorium to 10
months would have proved worthless. He would have destroyed the last
vestiges of the trust he needed, and still enjoys, with the pro-settlement
wing of his party. In Middle East culture, it is critical to stick to one's
word and not be seen as buckling under pressure. For Netanyahu to do
otherwise, while the Palestinians were not required to do anything to
advance the peace process, is not a workable arrangement in an arena where
unilateral concessions are seen as a weakness rather than a constructive
contribution.

This was especially sensitive since the Palestinians initially asserted the
moratorium was not significant. Indeed, it was part of their rationale for
not entering direct talks and then wasting nine of the moratorium's 10
months. Now something that was originally deemed insignificant is suddenly
indispensable.

In other words, the crisis over the moratorium was Obama's creation. As it
is said in the Middle East, both parties were put up in a high tree and left
without a ladder to get down. Paradoxically, the whole issue of the
settlements is of secondary importance, because it would have been resolved
by definition once the parties agreed to boundaries. Settlement construction
on the Israeli side of the line would then be permitted, and the other side
of the line would be turned over to the Palestinians.

Even the notion of a two-month extension of the moratorium made little
sense. Why not a longer extension? Nothing much could have happened in two
months except for the fact that it would have carried over past the U.S.
congressional elections. Even worse, extending it by two months would have
given the Palestinians the power to blackmail Israel indefinitely, as they
would have the opportunity to renew their threat to cease negotiations at
the end of the two-month period.

The net result was to pressure Netanyahu into an unnecessary concession that
he is unable to make politically. Furthermore, the American obsession with
the settlement freeze also cornered Abbas. The United States was urging him
to go back to the table while making it impossible for him to get there.
Even worse, it raised the question among Israelis of whether Abbas was
inflating the issue of settlement construction as a way of skirting the need
to make the tough decisions in a serious negotiation. Or perhaps his hope
was to provoke a crisis in U.S.-Israeli relations, as well as to get the
world to blame Israel for the failure to commence a serious dialogue.

Obama's public focus on the freeze has also frozen his own capacity to be a
peacemaker. The Arab leaders view the freeze as a test of the effectiveness
of the
<http://politics.usnews.com/opinion/mzuckerman/articles/2010/10/15/obama-cau
sing-americas-stature-in-the-middle-east-to-deteriorate_print.html>
Obamaadministration. They now think that if Obama can't enforce the freeze
on Israel, he'll be unable or unwilling to force his opinions on the
Israelis during the ongoing negotiations. The Israelis also view the freeze
as a test of their credibility, for it will dramatically reduce their
ability to say no. In turn, this might induce the Palestinians to become
even more hard line, tempting the United States to press the Israelis again
and again. At risk, then, would be the political support Netanyahu needs to
deliver; remember, this is a democracy not a dictatorship. No wonder the
Israelis feel they are being punished for the misjudgments of the Obama
administration, which failed to distinguish between the crucial and the
marginal issues.

What should Obama have done? He should have told the parties it was up to
them to work out these differences. The result of meddling is that almost
the entire Middle East leadership looks upon American diplomacy as
amateurish. What has come out of this administration is an unending number
of speeches and press conferences that have placed the Israeli-Palestinian
issue under the media spotlight. Progress requires truly private
negotiations-far from the cameras, spotlights, microphones, and press
conferences. The historic breakthroughs have been achieved through private
channels and private diplomacy: consider how Richard Nixon and Henry
Kissinger achieved the opening to China. The landmark Oslo accords were
achieved through private talks and in complete secrecy and should serve as a
model for all Middle East negotiations.

It is not surprising that America's stature in the Middle East continues to
deteriorate. Iran is advancing toward nuclear capabilities and scorning
Obama as it destabilizes the region. Meanwhile, a Shiite prime minister has
been elected in Iraq with the help of Iran's ally Syria and may very well
open Iraq to greater influence from Iran, especially in the Shiite south.
Indeed, the Shiite Sunni conflict is becoming ever more extreme. Turkey has
become more radicalized and seems to have joined the Iranian-Syrian axis.
Hezbollah now threatens to destabilize the government in Lebanon and, along
with Hamas, has gained significant political and military strength from
their alliance with an expansionist Iran. America is sinking deeper and
deeper into the Afghanistan quagmire of an unwinnable war. Worst of all, the
United States has not succeeded, nor even truly tried, to build an effective
strategic alliance of moderate Arab states.

There is still a little time for this administration to bring fresh thinking
to its team managing the Middle East peace process. Otherwise, the period
will be marked down as four more years of failure.



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to