http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/257438/wrong-rauf-andrew-c-mccarthy

 

Andrew C. McCarthy 

Archive <http://www.nationalreview.com/author/52265>     |    Log In
<http://www.nationalreview.com/user/login?destination=articles%2Fprint%2F257
438>  


January 19, 2011 4:00 A.M.

Wrong on Rauf 
Sarah Palin did not libel the Ground Zero imam.

Imam Feisal Rauf, the cleric behind the provocative Ground Zero Mosque (GZM)
project, as one critic put it, "is no moderate. He presents himself as a
peacemaking Islamic Gandhi, but he is in fact an apologist for the terrorist
outfit Hamas, which he refuses even to identify as a terrorist
organization."

You might be forgiven for thinking that came from Sarah Palin. If you've
been reading NRO lately, you saw published here on Monday "Palin Libels Rauf
<http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/257320/palin-libels-rauf-henry-payne
> ," an essay by Henry Payne. Payne accuses the former Alaska governor of
"libel" - his word - because she described Imam Rauf as a Hamas apologist
who refused to identify that terrorist organization as a terrorist
organization. But the quoted words were written by the editors of National
Review. On August 4, 2010, as controversy raged over the GZM, NRO published
an editorial
<http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/243608/not-ground-zero-editor>
describing Rauf as a wolf in sheep's clothing. Based on a number of
disturbing facts that have not to this day been refuted, the editorial ("Not
at Ground Zero") portrayed the imam as a faux moderate collaborating with
Muslim Brotherhood front groups to build a huge mosque and Islamic center on
what the editors described as "the gravesite of 3,000 Americans who died at
the hands of Islamic radicals" - a prospect the editors quite rightly called
"unseemly."

Now, I'm all for a good debate. That's what NRO is here for. But a debate is
a discussion in which adversaries actually address their points of
disagreement. Payne doesn't address any of the troubling matters that have
been raised about Rauf, not only by NR's editors and Sarah Palin, but by
many, many others. Allowed to exploit NR's megaphone, he treats our readers
to a mendacious puff piece, leveling the weighty charge of libel while
whitewashing the rich underlying basis for regarding Rauf as an apologist
for Islamist terrorists in general, and for Hamas in particular.

According to Mr. Payne, Governor Palin "has spread libel herself about the
Ground Zero Mosque imam, Feisal Rauf," by claiming that "Rauf refuses to
recognize that Hamas is a terrorist organization dedicated to the
destruction of our ally, Israel."

Libel, of course, is a legally actionable defamation, entitling the wronged
party to sue for money damages against the alleged slanderer. That's serious
business. In fact, to conclude that a public figure like Rauf has been
libeled is to maintain that the purported slanderer made her baseless
accusation either knowing it was untrue or in reckless disregard of its
falsity.

Why does Payne claim Palin is guilty of libel? Because recently - as
recently, in fact, as a radio appearance in Detroit last week - Rauf has
taken to asserting that "Hamas is a terrorist organization. They have
committed terrorist acts." So one might ask Mr. Payne, "You mean to tell me
Rauf didn't refuse to call Hamas a terrorist organization? Are you saying
that Palin knew Rauf had called Hamas a terrorist organization yet publicly
claimed that he refused to do so?"

Don't hold your breath waiting for Payne's answers. They're sure not in his
essay, which is just as cavalier about flinging libel accusations as he
baselessly accuses Palin of being when it comes to Rauf. Not to mince words,
the essay is an embarrassment. Its speciousness is betrayed in the first few
lines. There, he acknowledges that Palin's remarks were made "on her
Facebook page last year" - that is, many months before Rauf repackaged
himself as the scourge (sort of) of Hamas.

Was Payne just singling out the controversial former governor and potential
presidential candidate in order to draw attention to himself? Was she alone
in taking Rauf to task over Hamas? Judge for yourself. Here is what NR's
editors said last year about why they considered Rauf "in fact an apologist
for the terrorist outfit Hamas, which he refuses even to identify as a
terrorist organization":

Nor is Rauf exactly full-throated in his rejection of terrorism, offering
only this: "The issue of terrorism is a very complex question." While he
cannot quite bring himself to blame the terrorists for being terrorists, he
finds it easy to blame the United States for being a victim of terrorism: "I
wouldn't say that the United States deserved what happened, but the United
States policies were an accessory to the crime that happened."

In my NRO columns, Corner posts, and public statements during the summer of
2010 - including an August 28 column called "Why They Can
<http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/245004/why-they-can-t-condemn-hamas-
andrew-c-mccarthy> 't Condemn Hamas" - I several times recounted that Rauf
could not bring himself to admit that Hamas is a terrorist organization, and
that he had contended the United States was more guilty of wanton murder
than al-Qaeda.

Moreover, in a widely cited Corner post
<http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/242832/ground-zero-mosque-imam-they-fe
el-need-conflagrate-robert-verbruggen>  on August 9, 2010, NR associate
editor Robert VerBruggen reported that "NRO has obtained yet another
interview <http://www2.nationalreview.com/dest/audio/rauf_interview.mp3>  in
which Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf, the leading figure behind the Cordoba House
(the 'Ground Zero mosque'), explains away terrorism. 'They feel the need to
conflagrate,' he says of Muslims who feel they've been 'humiliated' and
'ignored.'" VerBruggen concluded that as the GZM "project's supporters press
on in the face of overwhelming public outcry, and as Rauf's beliefs come
increasingly into the light, arguments that the community center and mosque
are meant as anything but a finger in the eye of America become less
believable." Not leaving it at that, NR later published a lengthy study
<http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/print/246269> , "The Two Faces of
Feisal Rauf," by Ibn Warraq, who analyzed Rauf's "reluctance to call Hamas a
terrorist organization," as well as Rauf's work with Hamas sympathizers,
from the perspective of a renowned scholar of Islam who had read actually
Rauf's scholarship.

We at NR were far from alone. Here, from his weekly column
<http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704868604575433214247852860.h
tml?>  on August 17, 2010, is the Wall Street Journal's Bret Stephens on
Imam Rauf: "[A] man who claims to condemn all forms of terrorism yet refuses
to call Hamas a terrorist group is not a moderate by American standards,
which happen to be the relevant ones when you're trying to build a mosque
two blocks from Ground Zero."

At the Weekly Standard in July 2010, Stephen Schwartz reported
<https://www.weeklystandard.com/articles/mosque-grows-near-brooklyn>  that
"Rauf's refusal to acknowledge that Hamas is a terrorist organization" had
become an issue in the New York gubernatorial election. A few weeks later,
on September 1, TWS's Michael Goldfarb noted
<http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/ground-zero-mosque-spokesman-refuses-co
ndemn-hamas-terrorist-attack>  not only that Rauf was "unwilling to condemn
[Hamas] as a terrorist organization," but that Rauf's Park51 organization
had turned down Goldfarb's pointed invitation to reconsider its reticence in
the wake of a Hamas attack in which four Israeli civilians, including a
pregnant woman, were murdered.

I could go on for the rest of the day. Suffice it to say that Feisal Rauf
did not file a libel suit against Sarah Palin or any of the numerous other
commentators and publications that discussed his refusal to call Hamas a
terrorist organization. Truth, after all, is a complete defense to a
defamation claim. The evidence that Rauf recoiled from denouncing Hamas is
irrefutable.

In a well-publicized radio interview <http://www.wnd.com/?pageId=168797>  by
Aaron Klein in June 2010, which Payne conveniently elects not to discuss,
Rauf was repeatedly pushed on whether he agreed with the State Department's
designation of Hamas as a terrorist organization. It's a straightforward
question. Still, Rauf would not answer it: "I'm not a politician. I try to
avoid the issues. The issue of terrorism is a very complex question.#.#I'm a
bridge builder. I define my work as a bridge builder. I do not want to be
placed, nor do I accept to be placed in a position of being put in a
position where I am the target of one side or another."

Of course, one needn't be a politician to concede the obvious: Hamas targets
innocents for slaughter in order to further its agenda (destroying Israel)
and is therefore a terrorist organization. Rauf, however, couldn't bring
himself to say this. So Klein tried again, pointing out that Hamas targets
civilians and asking whether that wasn't enough to make it a terrorist
organization. Rauf replied with characteristic caginess: "The targeting of
civilians is wrong. It is a sin in our religion. Whoever does it, targeting
civilians is wrong." Yeah, a lot of things are wrong, but is Hamas a
terrorist organization? Rauf wouldn't say - insisting that "I will not allow
anybody to put me in a position where I am seen by any party in the world as
an adversary."

Well, tender as that may be, sides have been chosen on the matter of Hamas's
terrorism. Most people understand that they don't get to be above it all on
that one. Not Rauf, though. His fury was reserved not for Hamas terrorists
but for Klein: "You are killing the messenger," whined the imam. Klein,
though, pointed out yet again that he was simply trying to get an answer out
of the messenger, "and yet you refuse to tell me Hamas is a terror
organization," an assertion Rauf did not dispute - for how could he?

It is not enough to say Rauf declined to admit that Hamas is a terrorist
organization, just as Palin, NR, and a host of others have claimed. His
position was entirely predictable for anyone who has taken the time to study
his career.

For example, in another episode Payne omits, Rauf published in Malaysia a
book provocatively titled, A Call to Prayer from the World Trade Center
Rubble: Islamic Dawa in the Heart of America Post-9/11. "Dawa" is Islamic
missionary work which, as informed by Muslim Brotherhood spiritual leader
Yusuf Qaradawi - admired by Rauf as the world's most influential Muslim
cleric - is jihad by stealth: the infiltration of sharia principles (Islamic
law) in Western law, culture, and institutions. It is the means by which
Islam will "conquer America" and "conquer Europe," exclaims Qaradawi - who
has issued fatwas approving Hamas's preferred tactic, suicide bombing, as
well as the killing of U.S. soldiers and support personnel in Iraq.

When Rauf decided to distribute his book in the United States, he knew the
offensive title would be a problem, so he changed it to What's Right with
Islam Is What's Right with America (as Warraq observes, it's now called
What's Right with Islam: A New Vision for Muslims and the West). Further
ignored by Payne are Rauf's partners
<http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/243536/raufs-dawa-world-trade-center
-rubble-andrew-c-mccarthy>  in the American distribution of the book. They
are the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) and the International
Institute of Islamic Thought (IIIT). Both have deep ties to the Muslim
Brotherhood, whose Palestinian branch is#.#Hamas.

Fundamental to the mission of both these Rauf partners is the promotion of
Hamas in the United States. Indeed, in the Justice Department's successful
prosecution of the Holy Land Foundation (HLF) for underwriting Hamas to the
tune of millions of dollars, ISNA was proved to have housed HLF in its
offices and to have used its bank account to funnel hundreds of thousands of
dollars to Hamas leaders overseas. Interconnected to ISNA and the
Brotherhood through its board members, IIIT
<http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/233574/international-institute-islamic
-thought-and-muslim-brotherhood-andy-mccarthy>  is not only a longtime Hamas
apologist but a key supporter of Sami al-Arian, the convicted terrorist who
helped run the American branch of Palestinian Islamic Jihad, another
formally designated terrorist organization.

Payne discusses none of this. And what he does discuss is almost as
egregious as what he leaves out. He asserts that Rauf is just "[l]ike most
American Muslims who have fled the horrors of Mideastern religious
intolerance for America's shores" In point of fact, Rauf was born in Kuwait,
the son of Muhammad Abdul Rauf, an Islamist contemporary of Muslim
Brotherhood founder Hassan al-Banna. The elder Rauf had fled Egypt in 1948 -
at the very time many Brotherhood operatives were fleeing a brutal crackdown
by the Nasser regime (after the Brotherhood had tried to assassinate
Nasser). Far from fleeing intolerance, young Feisal Rauf was educated in the
U.K. and the U.S. His father, in the interim, established a huge Islamic
cultural center cum mosque on Manhattan's upper East Side which, Salah
Choudhury writes
<http://www.weeklyblitz.net/759/rauf-and-his-mosque-at-ground-zero> , sports
a housing complex restricted since 1984 to Muslim residents only.

Payne also misleadingly faults Palin for saying it would be "intolerable" to
permit Rauf's GZM dream to be built on "such hallowed ground" as the site of
the felled Twin Towers. Rauf, Payne writes, "has had a mosque on this
'hallowed ground'" for 27 years. But as Payne well knows, the lower
Manhattan mosque Rauf has long operated is not the "hallowed ground" Palin
was talking about. It is several blocks north of the World Trade Center
complex. By contrast, the former Burlington Coat Factory proposed for the
GZM was actually struck by the wreckage of a hijacked plane on 9/11 and lies
within the perimeter where remains of those killed are still being
recovered.

Payne absurdly adds that "Rauf is passionate about our liberties, our
Founding Fathers, and heroes of freedom like Ronald Reagan." Actually,
Rauf's life's work is a Sharia Index project that aims to pressure countries
into compliance with Muslim law. Sharia, it may interest you to know,
rejects core American liberties - to take just a few examples, the right of
free people to make law for themselves irrespective of any religious code;
freedom of conscience (apostasy from Islam is a capital offense); equal
protection of the law (sharia favors men over women and Muslims over
non-Muslims); privacy (sharia makes homosexuality a capital offense, and
severely punishes other social behavior regarded as none of the state's
business in the West); and freedom of speech (sharia forbids any criticism
of Islam and its prophet).

Rauf is nothing if not clever. Realizing bad PR from his refusal to
acknowledge Hamas's terrorism was compromising his sharia mission, he is now
conceding it. But observe how easily Payne is taken in by the imam. Payne
writes that Rauf's website states: "Hamas is both a political movement and a
terrorist organization. When Hamas commits atrocious acts of terror, those
actions should be condemned. Imam Feisal has forcefully and consistently
condemned all forms of terrorism, including those committed by Hamas, as
un-Islamic."

As we have seen, Imam Feisal has not consistently condemned terrorism or
Hamas - he has often rationalized terrorism as the fault of its victims and
he has squirmed to avoid attaching the label "terror" to Hamas. But apart
from that, note that when Rauf says Hamas is "both a political movement and
a terrorist organization," he is careful to say (at long last) that only its
"acts of terror" should be condemned. Here's the thing: Insofar as Hamas is
a "political movement" (and let's indulge for argument's sake the claim that
its aims and its methods are severable), the brazenly stated goals of this
"movement" are the destruction of Israel and the furtherance of the global
Muslim Brotherhood campaign to Islamicize societies. Rauf - the "moderate" -
has no problem with this "political" campaign; he just wishes (or at least
now says he wishes) that Hamas would stop blowing people up to achieve it.

No need to worry, though. Payne assures us of Rauf's claim to be "a
supporter of Israel." Again he is taken in by the seductive words he wants
to hear, but the rest of us need not be as resolutely uncurious. As I've
previously recounted
<http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/244528/imam-rauf-and-one-state-solutio
n-israeli-palestinian-conflict-andy-mccarthy>  on the Corner, in the same
appearance at which he claimed the United States has more innocent blood on
its hands than al-Qaeda, Rauf announced that he favors a "one-state
solution" for this Israel that he so supports. It so happens that this is
the same solution favored by the Muslim Brotherhood, and is not materially
different from Hamas's endgame. In the one-state solution, Muslims achieve
the elimination of Israel's character as a Jewish state by democratic means.
That is, fortified by Israel's already swelling Arab population and the
"right of return" for millions of Palestinians that Muslims demand as the
price of a peace settlement, Muslims would vote to end Israel's character as
a Jewish state. Israel becomes "Palestine" and the Israeli Jews living there
become like any other Jewish minority living in a Muslim country. As the
Jews fleeing Iraq will tell you, good luck with that.

To anyone not as foolishly determined as Payne to cast Rauf as a "tea
partier," this also adds necessary context to Rauf's sudden infatuation with
democracy. In his father's native Egypt, real popular elections would likely
vault the Muslim Brotherhood into power - just as it has served to empower
Hamas in the Palestinian territories, to make Hezbollah (and its backers in
Iran and Syria) the power center of Lebanon, and to put Shiite Islamists in
charge in Iraq.

In 1977, before he had useful idiots around to carry his water, Feisal Rauf
wrote a letter <http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3947698,00.html>
to the New York Times urging Muslims to give the new peace treaty between
Israel and Egypt a chance. "Learn from the example of the Prophet Mohammed,
your greatest historical personality," he counseled, adding: "After a state
of war with the Meccan unbelievers that lasted for many years, he acceded,
in the Treaty of Hudaybiyah, to demands that his closest companions
considered utterly humiliating. Yet peace turned out to be a most effective
weapon against the unbelievers."

It was effective, alas, because by camouflaging himself as a man of peace,
Muhammad was able to portray his detractors as extremists and enemies of
peace. That bought him the time he needed to rearm and prepare his followers
for battle. When they were ready, they broke the treaty and returned to
conquer the unbelievers, the start of decisive campaigns in which Islam was
spread by intimidation and the sword.

Imam Rauf is not hard to figure out. You just have to listen to what he says
rather than pretend that he didn't say it. National Review is the last place
where Henry Payne should have gotten away with pretending he didn't say it -
and with accusing someone who refuses to pretend of libel.

- Andrew C. McCarthy, a senior fellow at the National Review Institute, is
the author, most recently, of The Grand Jihad: How Islam and the Left
Sabotage America
<http://www.nationalreview.com/redirect/amazon.p?j=1594033773> .

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to