http://www.jewishworldreview.com/0111/glick012111.php3

 

Jan. 21, 2011 / 16 Shevat, 5771 

How America treats its allies? 

By Caroline B. Glick 

 


Taken side by side, the first striking aspect of the US's fabricated Israeli
spy scandal on the one hand and its massive espionage operation against
Israel on the other hand is the shocking hypocrisy of it all. 

But hypocrisy isn't the real issue. The real issue exposed by the documents
is that the US is carrying out a deeply hostile policy against Israel in the
face of massive public support for Israel in the US 

 

http://www.JewishWorldReview.com | Two documents reported on this week shed
a troubling light on the US government's attitude toward Israel. The first
is a 27-page FBI search warrant affidavit from 2004 targeting then senior
AIPAC lobbyist Steve Rosen, published Wednesday in the Washington Times. The
second is WikiLeaks leaked secret State Department cable from October 2008
signed by then secretary of state Condoleezza Rice directing US officials to
spy on Israel. Both indicate that in certain quarters of the American
government Israel is viewed as at best a banana republic and at worst an
enemy of the US. 

The text of the FBI affidavit directed against Rosen makes clear that the
FBI had no particular reason to suspect that he was an Israeli agent or was
harming US national security. Rosen's activities during his tenure as
AIPAC's senior lobbyist as described in the affidavit -- meeting with
government officials, journalists and Israeli diplomats -- were precisely
the type of activities that lobbyists in Washington routinely engage in.
Despite this the FBI followed Rosen for five years and indicted him and his
AIPAC colleague Keith Weissman on felony charges under the all but forgotten
1917 Espionage Act. The FBI probe and subsequent trial harmed AIPAC's
reputation, destroyed both men's careers, and did untold damage to the
reputation of both the State of Israel and its American Jewish supporters.
That it took five years for the Justice Department to drop these outrageous
charges is a testament to the strength of the FBI's commitment to
criminalizing American Jewish advocates of a strong US-Israel alliance. 

And then there is Rice's secret cable. Just days before the 2008
presidential elections, the Secretary of State instructed US diplomats in
Israel, Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and Saudi Arabia as well as the DIA and the
CIA to conduct a massive espionage operation against Israel. The sought for
information covered all aspects of Israel's political system, society,
communications infrastructures and the IDF. 

Regarding the IDF for instance, among other things, diplomats and spies were
asked to gather intelligence on planned Israeli military operations against
the Palestinians, Lebanon, and Syria and probe the attitudes of military
commanders. They were also told to gather information on "IDF units,
equipment, maintenance levels, training, morale, and operational
readiness[;] IDF tactics, techniques and procedures for conducting
conventional and unconventional counterinsurgency and counterterrorist
operations[; and] Israeli assessment of the impact of reserve duty in the
territories on IDF readiness." As for political leaders, among other things,
Rice instructed diplomats and spies to provide detailed information about
government plans; influences on politicians; how politicians decide to
launch military strikes; what Israel's leaders think about the US and much
more. 

Rice also sought information about various aspects of Israeli society. Rice
instructed US diplomats and spies to gather information on everything from,
"Information on and motivations for any increased Israeli population
emigration from Israel," to detailed information on Israeli "settlers" in
Judea, Samaria and the Golan Heights. Regarding the "settlers," among other
things, Rice wanted information on, "Divisions among various settlement
groups[;] details on settlement-related budgets and subsidies[;] settlers'
relationships with the Israeli political and military establishment
including their lobbying and settlement methods." 

Rice expressed deep interest as well in all details related to Israel's
military and non-military communications infrastructure. For instance, she
directed US officials to gather information on "Current specifications,
vulnerabilities, capabilities, and planned upgrades to national
telecommunications infrastructure, networks, and technologies used by
government and military authorities, intelligence and security services, and
the public sector." 

Finally, Rice wanted personal data on Israeli leaders. She asked for
"official and personal phone numbers, fax numbers, and email addresses of
principal civilian and military leaders." 

Taken side by side, the first striking aspect of the US's fabricated Israeli
spy scandal on the one hand and its massive espionage operation against
Israel on the other hand is the shocking hypocrisy of it all. 


But hypocrisy isn't the real issue. The real issue exposed by the documents
is that the US is carrying out a deeply hostile policy against Israel in the
face of massive public support for Israel in the US. That is, whereas two
thirds of Americans support Israel, a minority constituency in the US
government treats Israel with scorn and hatred. And the question that arises
from this is how is this minority able to get away with it? Part of the
answer was exposed this week in the aftermath of Defense Minister Ehud
Barak's move on Monday morning to break ranks with the Labor Party. To
understand how the two issues are related it is important to understand the
plight of Labor since the demise of the peace process with the PLO in 2000. 

Since the peace process ended with the beginning of the Palestinian terror
war in September 2000, the overwhelming majority of Israelis have viewed
Labor's policies of appeasement at all cost as dangerous and wrong. That is,
since 2000, Labor's policies have been the policies of the political fringe.
This situation has only grown worse for Labor since Hamas's takeover of Gaza
and victory in the Palestinian elections held in the wake of Israel's
unilateral withdrawal from Gaza in 2005. 

Despite the fact that its policies are hugely unpopular, two factors have
enabled Labor to continue to present itself as a mainstream ruling party. 

The first factor has been the media. As has been their practice since the
birth of modern Israel, since the demise of the peace process, the media
have helped the likes of Labor by demonizing the Right, and rightist
politicians and particularly Likud. Working hand in glove with leftist
politicians, the media have implemented the politics of personal destruction
against right wing leaders. By demonizing the likes of Prime Minister
Binyamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman, they have
rendered the social cost of supporting Likud and the Right is too high for
many Israelis to bear. 

At the same time, the media have colluded with the Left to present Leftist
leaders as earthy, heroic, sophisticated and responsible statesmen. By
keeping the content of their policies firmly out of the discussion and
framing the debate instead around personal attacks and symbols, the media
have successfully kept rightist leaders on the defensive and shielded
leftist politicians from substantive attacks on their radical policies. 

The second reason that Labor was able to retain its mantle as a ruling party
is that it has enjoyed the energetic support of the State Department and
European governments which both support its radical policies. 

Until the formation of the Netanyahu government two years ago, Labor was the
State Department's favorite political party. Labor leaders from Shimon Peres
down were the objects of constant attention and praise. Labor's leaders in
turn were happy to help the Americans and Europeans hide their basic
hostility towards Israel by claiming that their anti-Israel policies were
actually pro-Israel policies. 

So it was that in 2003 Labor leaders actively colluded with the State
Department in drafting the so-called Roadmap plan for Israeli-Palestinian
peace despite then prime minister Ariel Sharon's opposition to the plan. 

Labor's importance took a hit with the formation of Kadima in late 2005.
Comprised of newly minted leftists from Likud led by Sharon and veteran
leftists from Labor like Peres, Kadima inherited Labor's mantle as the
Left's new ruling party. Labor was able to retain its relevance to the US by
joining Olmert's coalition and advocating even more radical policies than
those advocated by Olmert and Livni. 

But then Likud and the Right won the 2009 elections. Kadima, led by Livni,
went into the opposition and Labor, under Barak joined the coalition. 

As head of the opposition, Livni has become ever more vocal in advocating
the policies of the radical Left and the Obama administration. Livni has
placed the blame for the absence of the peace process and for the Obama
administration's sour relations with Israel squarely and entirely on
Netanyahu's shoulders. 

For his part, Barak has been stuck in an untenable situation. To justify his
partnership with Netanyahu, he worked closely with the Obama administration
and actively lobbied Netanyahu to adopt the US's favored positions. The
Obama administration rewarded him by regularly hosting him in Washington and
openly extolling him as its chosen "Israeli foreign minister." 

But given both his own party's radicalism and the Obama administration's
hostility towards Netanyahu, Barak was never able to fully satisfy either
his party or the Americans. He was never able to move to the Left of Livni. 

According to Haaretz and to Labor leaders who opposed Barak, the end of the
line for Barak came in late December with Haaretz's publication of a report
claiming that the Obama administration had soured on Barak due to his
failure to convince Netanyahu to extend the Jewish construction ban in Judea
and Samaria for an additional 90 days. Livni, Haaretzreported, had replaced
Barak as the Obama administration's favorite Israeli politician. 

Since the article was published, Barak could no longer maintain the
contradiction between Labor's radical policies and its protestations to
ruling party status. Without American support, there was no way to keep
Labor together. 

This is why, when he announced his break with Labor on Monday morning, Barak
explained that Labor had become a radical party that was home to
post-Zionists who believe that Israel alone is to blame for the absence of
peace. The post-Zionists rejected him when he lost his international
support. So he had nowhere to go but into Netanyahu's waiting Zionist arms. 

This is also why Livni and Kadima have so harshly attacked Barak. In an
interview with Army Radio on Tuesday, Livni - whose political career owes
entirely to her decision to betray Likud voters - called Barak's split from
Labor "the dirtiest act," in history. More importantly, the woman who claims
that Netanyahu is solely to blame for the absence of peace with the
Palestinians and that he is wrong not to bow to every US demand
protested,"For Barak to call whoever wants peace post-Zionist is unheard
of." 

This brings us back to the FBI's anti-Israel witch hunt and Rice's spy
cable. 

Barak lost his ability to serve as the puppet of the anti-Israel wing of the
US government because he was unable to both serve under Netanyahu and
overthrow him. By pressuring Barak to do the impossible, the anti-Israel
officials in the US government inadvertently caused the demise of the Labor
Party. 

However, with Kadima under Livni, these officials can take heart. Their
support for Livni makes her powerful. Owing to their support, Livni is able
to maintain her control over the largest party in the Knesset. 

And as long as Livni remains both powerful and loyal to their agenda, those
forces in the US government that despise the Jewish state will be able to
rest easy. Although the majority of Americans want their government to
support Israel, shielded by Kadima, these US government officials will be
able to continue to implement policies that treat Israel with the contempt
due to a banana republic. 

 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to