http://lawandsecurity.foreignpolicyblogs.com/2011/01/19/lawfare-on-trial-par
t-i/

 


Lawfare On Trial (Part I)


By Rob Grace <http://lawandsecurity.foreignpolicyblogs.com/author/robgrace/>


Wednesday, January 19 7:35 am EST

Every once in a while, FPA Afghanistan blogger Patrick Frost emails me an
article with which I very much disagree and I, in turn, write a post
criticizing it.  (See a post of mine from last year
<http://lawandsecurity.foreignpolicyblogs.com/2010/08/13/preventive-military
-action-still-a-terrible-idea/>  on preventive war.)  The tradition
continues with an interview, published by
<http://www.aviationweek.com/aw/generic/story_channel.jsp?channel=defense&id
=news/awx/2010/12/16/awx_12_16_2010_p0-277882.xml> AviationWeek, with Brooke
Goldstein, director of the nonprofit, The Lawfare Project
<http://www.thelawfareproject.org/> .  I’m very much interested in the
subject of lawfare, but I disagree with Goldstein’s take on it.  There’s
much to say about it, so I’ll tackle it in two parts.  I’ll post Part II
later in the week.  Let’s start with how Goldstein defines lawfare.  Here’s
what she says:

When I say lawfare, I denote the wrongful abuse of Western laws and judicial
systems to achieve military or political ends that undermine the principles
those systems stand for. I emphasize wrongful because lawfare is an
inherently negative undertaking; it consists of the negative exploitation of
the law to achieve a purpose other than or contrary to that for which the
law was originally enacted.

So what matters to Goldstein is intent.  To be a lawfare perpetrator, one
must intend to use the law somehow to undermine Western legal principles.
But for someone fixated on intent, she sure doesn’t seem very fixated on
intent.  She makes little to no effort to examine the intent of those
involved in the many examples of lawfare she provides.  But still, she
insists that intent is the thing that distinguishes those who engage in
lawfare from those who do not:

The delineation is not as simple as some may like to make it; that is, that
lawsuits against terrorists are good, and legal actions against the U.S. and
Israel are bad. The question is not ‘Who is the target?’ but ‘What is the
intention?’ behind the legal action: Is it to pursue justice, to apply the
law in the interests of freedom and democracy, or is the intent to undermine
the very system of laws being manipulated?

So one might think, to solidify her argument that the question is not ‘who
is the target,’ that she’d provide an example of a bad case in which a
terrorist, or a suspected terrorist, or someone suspected of aiding a
terrorist, is the target.  Or an example of a good case against the U.S. or
Israel.  But she does not.  All of the examples of lawfare she provides are
legal cases against U.S. and Israeli leaders and people speaking out against
Islam.  The question for her, it seems, is actually ‘who is the target,’
despite her statements to the contrary.

I very much prefer the definition offered by Charles Dunlap.  In a 2001
essay
<http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:2I52DRK9sf4J:www.duke.
edu/~pfeaver/dunlap.pdf+dunlap+lawfare+2001&hl=en&gl=us>  that Goldstein
cites (and which I discussed in my very first post
<http://lawandsecurity.foreignpolicyblogs.com/2011/01/19/2009/11/09/welcome/
>  on this blog), Dunlap defines lawfare as “a method of warfare where law
is used as a means of realizing a military objective.”  This seems to be a
more useful definition.  There’s nothing about an intent to undermine law or
democracy.  To Dunlap, lawfare simply means the use of law as a tool of
strategy.

Goldstein also incorrectly identifies the threats we face from lawfare.
Here’s a portion where she paints a grim picture of our current situation:

We live in a time when authors such as Mark Steyn are forced to defend
themselves before Canadian ‘human rights’ commissions for writing about
Islam and its demographics. When Swiss magazine editors are indicted for the
crime of ‘vilifying members of the Islamic religion.’ When U.S.-based
cartoon networks and a university printing press are too afraid to republish
any image deemed offensive to Islam. We are living in a time when a Danish
cartoonist is thrown into jail for printing images of the prophet Mohammad
in his own country.

The above passage may sound alarming.  The reader may conclude that freedom
of speech is, in fact, under a lawfare siege, as Goldstein asserts, and
perhaps this siege is affecting our ability to combat terrorism.  But
Goldstein doesn’t tell the full story.  The Canadian Human Rights Commission
dismissed
<http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/171809/complaint-against-steyn-dissmis
sed/mark-hemingway>  the Mark Steyn case, and he remains
<http://www.steynonline.com/>  a successful writer.  Roger Koppel, the Swiss
magazine editor to which she refers, is also still doing well for himself
and is publishing
<http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/0,1518,684220,00.html>
regularly.  The South Park incident was an example of self-censorship and
had nothing to do with the law.  I’m not sure which Danish cartoonist she
refers to, but the one who drew one of the the controversial Muhammad
cartoons, Kurt Westergaard, was never imprisoned, and has won his share of
awards since the incident, including a freedom of the press award given to
him by Angela Merke <http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE6873CC20100908>
l.  Meanwhile, the man who plotted an attack on Westergaard in retaliation
for the cartoons is now in prison
<http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/2010/03/19/2010-03-19_chicago_man_dav
id_coleman_headley_admits_scouting_for_mumbai_massacre_that_left_.html>  (he
also had a role in the Mumbai attacks).  And the man who published the
cartoons in 2005 reprinted them in a book last year
<http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/denmark/8033098/Danish-edi
tor-reprints-Prophet-Mohammad-cartoons.html> .  The ‘freedom of speech’
situation does not seem as dire as Goldstein claims.

Furthermore, Goldstein leaves out many examples that, were she to include
them, could demonstrate that the question is not ‘who is the target.’   She
doesn’t express concern about the Swiss minaret ban, despite the fact that
it would, I think, qualify as lawfare by her definition, as it threatens
freedom of religious expression.  Also, her concern about self-censorship,
as evidenced by her reference to the South Park incident, doesn’t seem to
extend to to the decision by Jyllands-Posten (the Danish newspaper that
published the Muhammad cartoons) to refrain from republishing
<http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/danish-paper-cancels-plans-to-rep
ublish-cartoons-about-israel-1.179657>  cartoons critical of Israel.  As the
newspaper stated, “for fear of being misunderstood, we canceled the plan at
the last moment.”

On international law, Goldstein asks the wrong questions. She states of the
2004 International Court of Justice (ICJ) advisory opinion
<http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/index.php?p1=3&p2=4&code=mwp&case=131&k=5a>
on the Israeli separation wall:

If an Israeli border-security fence is illegal under international law, as
the International Court of Justice (ICJ) decided in 2004, while ignoring the
fact that the fence contributed to a sharp decline in the loss of human
lives, what affect will such precedent have on a fence built on the
U.S.-Mexican border?

First, it’s not quite accurate to call the separation wall a
“border-security fence,” since it is not on the Israeli border.  That’s the
whole issue.  As the ICJ states in the opinion:

83. According to the report of the Secretary-General, in its northernmost
part, the wall as completed or under construction barely deviates from the
Green Line [which demarcates the 1949 armistice agreement that ended the
1948 Arab-Israeli War]. It nevertheless lies within occupied territories for
most of its course. The works deviate more than 7.5 kilometres from the
Green Line in certain places to encompass Settlements, while encircling
Palestinian population areas. A stretch of 1 to 2 kilometres West of Tulkarm
appears to run on the Israeli side of the Green Line. Elsewhere, on the
other hand, the planned route would deviate eastward by up to 22 kilometres.
In the case of Jerusalem, the existing works and the planned route lie well
beyond the Green Line and even in some cases beyond the eastern municipal
boundary of Jerusalem as fixed by Israel.

84. On the basis of that route, approximately 975 square kilometres (or 16.6
per cent of the West Bank) would, according to the report of the
Secretary-General, lit: between the Green Line and the wall. This area is
stated to be home to 237,000 Palestinians. If the full wall were completed
as planned, another 160,000 Palestinians would live in almost completely
encircled communities, described as enclaves in the report. As a result of
the planned route, riearly 320,000 Israeli settlers (of whom 178,000 in East
Jerusalem) would be living in the area between the Green Line and the wall.

This has caused all sorts of problems for the Palestinians enclosed within
the barrier, including restrictions on their freedom of movement, reduced
agricultural production, food insecurity, and reduced access to health
services, clean water, and schools.  So the lesson for the U.S., should it
ever seriously ponder a similar barrier on its border with Mexico, is that
such a structure should be built on U.S. soil, not 22 kilometers south,
where it could run through Mexican communities and disrupt the lives of
Mexican citizens, as the Israeli barrier does to Palestinians in the West
Bank.

And despite Goldstein’s insinuation, the ICJ did contemplate Israel’s
security situation:

137. To sum up, the Court, from the material available to it, is not
convinced that the specific course Israel has chosen for the wall was
necessary to attain its security objectives. The wall, along the route
chosen, and its associated régime gravely infringe a number of rights of
Palestinians residing in the territory occupied by Israel, and the
infringements resulting from that route cannot be justified by military
exigencies or by the requirements of national security or public order.

The Court doesn’t elaborate on what measures short of the wall would have
been sufficient.  However, the language used suggests that what the Court
has in mind is a wall along a different route, namely, one on Israeli
territory.

Goldstein also mentions the Goldstone Report, which, she claims,
“deliberately manipulates and misapplies international law and the law of
armed conflict to delegitimize Israel’s right to self defense and to protect
its citizens from terrorist activity.”  However, there’s no evidence of
which I know that those involved deliberately misapplied the law.  Also, in
terms of Israel’s “right to self-defense,” the report does not address
whether Operation Cast Lead was justified under Article 51 of the UN
Charter, as that question fell outside the scope of the fact-finding
mission’s mandate.  Goldstein warns against “accepting the report as legally
binding precedent,” but I don’t see any danger of this happening.  The
Goldstone Report was not a court ruling but rather a fact-finding mission
that recommended that these incidents be investigated by courts.  Even
Goldstone has stated <http://www.forward.com/articles/116269/> , “Ours
wasn’t an investigation, it was a fact-finding mission… If this was a court
of law, there would have been nothing proven.”

Goldstein overlooks what is, to me, the clearest example of the law
hampering the U.S. struggle against terrorism: Holder v. Humanitarian Law
Project <http://www.scotusblog.com/?p=21920> .  In this case, the Supreme
Court ruled that it is illegal to work with terrorists to develop
non-violent strategies to pursue their objectives.  As a RAND 2008 study
<http://www.rand.org/pubs/monographs/2008/RAND_MG741-1.pdf>  notes,
integrating terrorists into peaceful political processes is one of the best
ways to reduce terrorism.  So in this case, the law deprives the U.S. of one
of the most effective anti-terrorism tools.

Since Goldstein and I see the problem differently, as you may imagine, we
disagree on the appropriate solutions.  But I will broach these in Part II,
which I will post later this week

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, 
[email protected].
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[email protected]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [email protected]
  Unsubscribe:  [email protected]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to