Hello, I am developing a dynamic abstraction that depends on arguments.
As I am dynamically deleting objects, the abstraction is opened, and then closed again using [; $1 menuclose(, with $1 being the name of the canvas set before with [namecanvas $0-r]. This is working well, but when I close a patch with the abstraction included, Pd prompts me to save the opened abstraction. I have also tried different float values as additional parameters for menuclose. (https://github.com/residuum/Puredata-abstractions/blob/master/glue/switch-matrix.pd#L182) I am not sure if this is an error by me or if I have found a bug. If I have found one or even two, I will report them. Reading the source of g_editor.c (https://github.com/pure-data/pure-data/blob/master/src/g_editor.c#L1974), I see that 1 should disable the check for modified content (no call to glist_finddirty(x)), but on closing Pd still asks me for confirmation. Using 3 will close Pd, which of course is undesired. Using 2 does segfault: Program received signal SIGSEGV, Segmentation fault. 0x080962c4 in pd_symbol () (gdb) backtrace #0 0x080962c4 in pd_symbol () #1 0x08098d8c in outlet_symbol () #2 0x080d4fe2 in ?? () #3 0x08098bd3 in outlet_bang () #4 0x080d884b in ?? () #5 0x080d8b51 in ?? () #6 0x08098d07 in outlet_float () #7 0x08097fef in ?? () #8 0x08098d07 in outlet_float () #9 0x080d883b in ?? () #10 0x080d8b51 in ?? () #11 0x08098d07 in outlet_float () #12 0x080d76ae in ?? () #13 0x08098e23 in outlet_list () #14 0x08098e23 in outlet_list () #15 0x080d87d9 in ?? () #16 0x08098e23 in outlet_list () #17 0x080d7e30 in ?? () #18 0x08098d07 in outlet_float () #19 0x08097fef in ?? () #20 0x08098d07 in outlet_float () #21 0x08098d07 in outlet_float () #22 0x080d4c62 in ?? () ---Type <return> to continue, or q <return> to quit--- #23 0x08098bd3 in outlet_bang () #24 0x080d884b in ?? () #25 0x080d8bd2 in ?? () #26 0x08098bd3 in outlet_bang () #27 0x080978d9 in pd_typedmess () #28 0x08097aaa in pd_vmess () #29 0x0805966a in canvas_loadbangsubpatches () #30 0x080596e3 in ?? () #31 0x08059690 in canvas_loadbang () #32 0x080978d9 in pd_typedmess () #33 0x08097aaa in pd_vmess () #34 0x0809626a in pd_doloadbang () #35 0x080a0568 in glob_evalfile () #36 0x080a2dd7 in ?? () #37 0x080a3d62 in glob_initfromgui () #38 0x0809f324 in binbuf_eval () #39 0x080a65f1 in socketreceiver_read () #40 0x080a5bcc in ?? () #41 0x080a2a78 in m_mainloop () #42 0x080569bb in main () I have found the same behaviour in Pd vanilla 0.46 Debian and Windows and Pd extended 0.42 Debian and Windows Thanks, Thomas -- "Prisons are needed only to provide the illusion that courts and police are effective. They're a kind of job insurance." (Leto II. in: Frank Herbert, God Emperor of Dune) http://www.residuum.org/ _______________________________________________ Pd-list@lists.iem.at mailing list UNSUBSCRIBE and account-management -> http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-list
