Q: Is this a good lens?

A: No; it's a great lens. I use it during my lunchtime walk around a lake.

Q: How is its flare control?
A: I've never had problems with the multicoated K-mount version; the M42
version was single-coated. I used to own it but never aimed it toward a
bright light, so I couldn't say.

Q: Distortion and optical quality?
A: I've never noticed distortion in it; I'm too busy admiring its wide-open
sharpness and pleasing bokeh. 

Q: How does it compare to 135mm Pentaxes?
A: I used to own the pentax SMC 135/2.5K. The pentax has better saturation
and contrast, and bokeh that's at least as good. The Vivitar, however, is
sharper from f/2.5 until about f/8, when the sharpness of the two lenses
evens out. Also, the Vivitar focuses closer, at 3 feet (1:4.5
magnification). 

Q: How about other 135mm lens of today?
There are no longer any third-party 135s made for SLRs. The Rikenon P
135/2.8 (also sold as Sears and maybe JC Penney) scored consistent Very
Goods in Amateur Photographer in the mid 1980s. The Sears 135/2.8 Close
Focus-a different lens--was supposed to be quite respectable, especially
considering its price. Likewise the Vivitar 135/2.8 close focus, though not
in the same class as the Series One. 

The only third-party lens that rivaled the Vivitar 135/2.3 was the Soligor
C/D 135/1.8 and 2.0 (differing from each other only in their baffling.) If
you want a 135/1.8K or M42-mount lens at less than $150, you can usually
find one on German ebay (Porst, Computar, or Revuenon). Spiratone made two
135/1.8s; only the multicoated version was excellent.

Q: Which is the best pentax 135mm?
A: The pentax 135/1.8 PKA* is probably the best 135 ever made, but it sells
for $1300 or more.when you can find one. The Pentax FA 135/2.8FA is said to
be an underrated jewel. It also focuses closer than any of the 135s
discussed above. The 135/2.3K is so scarce (I've seen only three for sale in
five years) that I nearly bought a PDML member's for $200 last year just to
have a spare! If I were buying today I'd probably get the FA, even though
all my gear is manual focus. 

[EMAIL PROTECTED]


Reply via email to