Brother Chris,

Did you discover this from the viewfinder or from finished shots?  Did
you notice that there was a difference when wide open vs. stopped
down?  As I will be in a position to use this combination on the
upcoming NorCal PDML outing, I am most curious.

Thanks for the info.


Brother Bruce



Thursday, September 11, 2003, 5:59:48 AM, you wrote:


CS> Oh bugger,

CS> I have just discovered that my Cokin P-series polariser vignettes on the
CS> 55mm f/4 for the 6x7 :-( This is using a cut-down holder (*).

CS> I am most dischuffed about this 'cos the same setup doesn't vignette
CS> with grad NDs on the 55mm or with anything on the 24mm f/2.8 for 35mm. So
CS> my question is, what have other 55mm owners done? Used a standard 77mm
CS> polariser? A narrow 77mm polariser? Bit the bullet and gone for a 100mm
CS> modular system like Lee? The price of the polariser for the Lee system
CS> makes my eyes spin and I probably can't justify that outlay at the
CS> moment. The only thing I don't want to do is buy an ordinary 77mm
CS> polariser and find it still vignettes - so, your experiences please?

CS> Chris

CS> (*) in true Cotty-esque fashion, slice off the outer grooves of the
CS> holder so it only holds one square or one circular filter.


Reply via email to