I did a little web research, and ended up deciding on the HP Photosmart 8450. One sellingpoint for me was that with the HP model, the jets are built into the replacable ink tanks. That means that although tank replacements are a little more costly, at least having a clogged printhead isn't going to mean I have to give up on the printer.
I also bought because of the nice review on Steve's Digicam website, and another site that links off of Steve's. Other deciding factors included network capability built-in, separate 4x6 tray, built-in card readers, built in PictBridge compatibility, the view screen (so if I'm in a rush I can bypass that whole Photoshop rigormorol), and the print quality raved about on the various web reviews I've read.
Hopefully I made the right decision. The printer should arrive in a few days: $199 at buydig.com (I decided to give pricegrabber.com a try, and BuyDig was the lowest price with a reasonable reputation.)
Anyone have any comments or tips for this printer?