On May 3, 2014, at 5:46 PM, Mark Roberts <[email protected]> wrote:

> Godfrey DiGiorgi wrote:
> 
>> But was it Leica's fail even? All reports that the lenses were without 
>> correction stem from the DPR new product report, nowhere else that I've 
>> found. All the other reports copied theirs almost word for word. 
>> 
>> Someone made an error. A stupid error. Never underestimate the power of 
>> stupidity. 
> 
> Leica is relying on software to correct for barrel distortion (and
> other aberrations) - even in the electronic viewfinder. IMO there's
> absolutely nothing wrong with that. (Hell, I think that the correction
> being rendered in the EVF is friggin' cool! That's a major advantage
> that EVFs have over optical viewfinders.) But it's completely
> predictable that Leica fanboys would throw a fit over Leica's failure
> to be completely transparent about it. How long has Leica been in
> business now? They should know their own customers at least that well.
> 
> Yes, it was a stupid error.

I would say that Leica is correcting the lenses the best way possible. Barrel 
distortion and corner/edge falloff are the easiest and least destructive 
corrections to make after capture with software. It's better to engineer a lens 
leaving a lot of simple spherical rectilinear aberration and falloff if you 
have that way been able to remove longitudinal chromatic aberration, 
astigmatism, "mustache" distortion, etc. Those are the hard things to correct 
in software. 

The stupidity was that someone is said to allege that the lenses were designed 
to be "perfect" without correction, and then follows with a big expose that 
they depend upon software correction. What the Leica goofballs (both the 
fanboys and the haters) are up in arms about is that DPR purports that Leica 
"lied" to them, and like complete idiots, they give DPR 100% credit for that 
statement and Leica none.

The stupid error was likely that someone at DPR mis-heard or mis-understood 
what someone at Leica said, or that someone at Leica misspoke about the 
corrections. Based on what two reviewers who had pre-release cameras in their 
hands had to say, it was never in question that software correction was 
embedded in the image files for these lenses. It only makes sense: these lenses 
are specifically for use on this camera system, and nothing else. What matters 
is the system output, not whether a lens is "optically pure" or not. 

A big pile of nonsense over something that carries not one iota of 
significance. 

So did you have to dispense this stupidity to the PDML, Cotty? Was it REALLY 
necessary?

G

-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
[email protected]
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.

Reply via email to