Tori,
Your paper seems to be based on a misreading of Peirce which assumes that in his semiotic, the object component of the triadic sign relation is "thought of either as a material thing or as an idea" (omitting events, processes, facts etc., which can all be objects of Peircean signs). As near as I can make out, your solution to this pseudo-problem is to make all reference self-reference, i.e. to eliminate Secondness from sign relations. But you can't have a genuine Thirdness without genuine Secondness. If you think I've "reversed my opinion" on this issue, you must have missed my reply to your most recent message about it, so I've pasted that in below (along with your message). gary f. From: VN A [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of VN Alexander Sent: 26-Mar-14 4:41 PM Jon, I make the argument in "Creativity: Self-Referential Mistaking, Not Negating" that "object" in the triad should be thought of as an objective of the interpreting system. I give a number of reasons why the "object" should not be thought of either as a material thing or as an idea. This may not be so obvious in human semiosis, but biosemiotics doesn't work unless the object is defined as the objective. If I recall correctly there was quite a bit of resistance to my theory from several listers, esp Gary F (who has since reversed his opinion, I believe.) In that paper I also relate the object to the intentional object and to the emergent whole. You can view the paper here http://www.academia.edu/2109842/Creativity_Self-Referential_Mistaking_Not_Ne gating or here http://www.researchgate.net/publication/232702090_Creativity_Self-Referentia l_Mistaking_Not_Negating Tori ________________________ From: Gary Fuhrman [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 19-Mar-14 1:04 PM To: 'VN Alexander' Subject: RE: [biosemiotics:5428] Re: What kind of sign is a "gene"? Tori, It didn't occur to me at the time that by the "objective" of a process, you meant the process itself! I guess that does make a kind of sense, since self-maintenance is obviously a recursive process. But it's also likely to cause confusion, it seems to me, to refer to a dynamic process as an "objective". It would be like referring to a race as the finish line. In the case of a "gene" which is an indexical sinsign, I would regard its dynamic object as the previous iteration of the recursive process. Looking at it as a legisign, as the type of that gene, I could say that the process in general (including future iterations) is its object. But I still wouldn't call that its "objective" because, to me, the "objective" of a currently running process can only be in futuro. - Or rather, the only kind of process which can have an objective actually represented before it runs is a consciously intended, planned process. That's what makes it consciously intentional, the fact that we can say what its objective is. I don't think the self-maintenance of most organisms is planned in that way. gary f. From: VN A [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of VN Alexander Sent: 19-Mar-14 11:42 AM To: Gary Fuhrman Subject: Re: [biosemiotics:5428] Re: What kind of sign is a "gene"? Gary, Maybe I misremember our exchange on the list some months ago, but didn't you reject my idea that the "object" in the triadic sign relation be thought of as the objective of self-maintenace? Below you assert my argument exactly. Its dynamic object can only be the dynamic process which produced it, Tori _________________________________ Victoria N. Alexander, PhD www.dactylfoundation.org www.biologistsmistress.com On Mar 19, 2014, at 9:26 AM, Gary Fuhrman wrote: DNA molecule can be regarded as an indexical sinsign (which is a replica of a legisign); but its object is certainly not a cell. Its dynamic object can only be the dynamic process which produced it, which is of the type that generates DNA molecules of a structure which includes that gene. And like the gene, that process can only make sense (or exist) in its context, which includes both its (cellular) environment and the evolutionary history of that type of process. It's indexical because it has a real (causal) relation to that object, which determines it to determine its interpretant (say, a protein).
----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .
