I have used the Waring video in my classes, in particular Women and
the Canadian Economy, very effectively.  It is very good on
the issue of the degrading of women's contribution to the economy
and *as a result*, the degredation of the environment.  But it
is shallow on the question of capitalism as the cause of the
problem and her environmentalism is very "Tory" -- the old
golden pastoral age of sheep and dung.  In fact she was here
promoting her most recent book a couple of weeks ago ( I missed
her as I was in Cuba) but my students who attended on my
recomendation were not impressed -- she had reduced all her analysis
to shit (dung).

Within limits, therefore, her video is useful.
But it is no substitute for analysis.

Paul Phillips


Reply via email to