by the way, do you have any evidence to your claims from German Ideology? 

Mine

Jim Devine wrote: 

>yes, it's true that the actual revolution in Russia turned into the kind
>of >sh*t that he and Engels predicted would occur if a revolution
occurred in >a >poor country (in the GERMAN IDEOLOGY). 

You have no slightest notion about what Engels is talking about
here!

German ideology is neither about a revolution in a "poor" country
nor is it about the kind of "shit" you are talking about. It is a
comprehensive statement of the materialist conception of history written
in 1845-46. Marx and Engels did NOT make predictions about revolution in
Russia here-- NOT IN THIS TEXT! Even assuming that they did, their
explanation would definetely be much more qualified than your "shit"
charecterization!


Mine Doyran, SUNY/Albany

Reply via email to