Milburn rejects Bevan's NHS vision 

Health secretary attacks Labour hero's centralist legacy

David Walker
Wednesday October 24, 2001
The Guardian

Nye Bevan, paid-up hero of Labour history and founder of the national
health service, will be pushed off his plinth tomorrow by the
health secretary, Alan Milburn. 

Mr Milburn will burnish his credentials as a Blairite moderniser by
attacking the "centralist" legacy of the Welsh socialist and his
preoccupation with "nationalisation". 

Bevan, the minister of health in Attlee's government from 1945-51 - he
resigned over the imposition of charges for glasses - once
famously said that the sound of a bedpan dropped on an NHS ward would
reverberate around Whitehall. Mr Milburn will say in his
speech - no longer, the bedpan gets dealt with locally not by the
centre. 

The speech, to be delivered at the Fabian Society in London, has been
strongly influenced and in part written by the minister's
special adviser, Paul Corrigan, the partner of chief whip Hilary
Armstrong. Ms Armstrong is not renowned as an advocate of
decentralisation within the parliamentary Labour party, as Paul Marsden
and other backbenchers will testify. 

Mr Corrigan, formerly an Islington councillor and a leading light in the
New Local Government Network, is in favour of devolving power
and responsibility within the NHS to trusts and primary care groups. 

A believer in giving local managers more not less say in how things are
run, he was seen to wince when his chief attacked NHS
"bureaucracy" during the recent Labour party conference. 

This week's speech argues for more local innovation and responsiveness
within the NHS, effectively strengthening the role of
managers in making decisions about who gets treated, when and how. 

Some of Mr Milburn's language echoes Labour's national plan for the
health service published in the summer of 2000, which was
followed earlier this year by the launch of an NHS modernisation agency.


But Mr Milburn is keen to be seen to be offering a more personal vision
of the future, portraying an NHS that will be much more
flexible and closer to patients. He will claim credit for giving up
rights of nomination to various health boards and committees. 

Bevan made the NHS too much like a nationalised industry, Mr Milburn
will say, and a new model is needed - not like Railtrack but
something appropriate to the times. Devolution to the frontline, he will
say - using a phrase borrowed from the prime minister in his
recent big public service speech - will encourage diversity and "local
creativity". 

Despite a previous promise to "shift the centre of gravity in the NHS
from Whitehall to frontline services", Mr Milburn is not finding it
easy. On one side he has been accused of cutting vital work done at the
centre on research and development. But on the other, the
money does not seem to be arriving in doctors' surgeries or hospital
wards.

Full article at:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/guardianpolitics/story/0,3605,579673,00.html

Michael Keaney
Mercuria Business School
Martinlaaksontie 36
01620 Vantaa
Finland

[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to