this business about Mark Jones being "wrong" or "right" isn't about MJ at all. It's
because MJ was chosen as a symbol. Some people on pen-l used MJ as a name to hang on
the assertion that "because of long-term natural constraints, we're running out of oil
now!" while others said "no we're not -- it's a short-term problem, not for natural
but for political-economic reasons."
jd
-----Original Message-----
From: Sabri Oncu [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Mon 6/21/2004 12:28 AM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc:
Subject: Re: [PEN-L] Mark Jones Still Wrong
soula avramidis:
> Mark could not have been wrong.
Whether Mark was wrong or right is debatable.
Yet, Mark can neither be right or wrong today.
He is gone for long!
Being an unfaithful thermodynamist by trait, I always had issues with his
thermodynamics and nor had I any interest in this Huppert peak thing but I
loved him.
Not because I agreed with him all the time but because of the side he chose,
which happened to be my side.
Can we please leave him alone with his and his fellows' struggles in
wherever they are?
Best,
Sabri
