In order to make a Disability Rights movement we have to consider the spectrum of all these disabilities into a framework that currently is barbaric toward disabled people.
I absolutely agree, and furthermore, I believe that 'framework' is barbaric to *most* people. The 'modern world' has created a unique set of stressors in society, and socialism points towards better solutions than drugs, OR therapy, for a problem that could be resolved simply by putting "work worth doing, with a paycheck worth working for" in the community we reside in, rather than requiring a long stressfull commute along with thousands of other stressed commuters. I had an interesting discussion with a Psych professor a year or so ago about the Amygdala gland, PTSD, and Adrenaline (or a precursor to Adrenaline secreted by the Amygdala, details lost.). The discussion revolved around research being done wherein the medical community has come to believe that PTSD is caused by the Amygdala being overworked, and eventually it becomes slack in it's ability to ...return to it's 'resting' state. I pointed out that earlier in human history, one might perchance meet a large predatory animal or person on occasion that would trigger the gland... but now, almost every time a person crosses the street (for instance) the fight or flight reaction is triggered, and I proposed that most urban humans have a certain degree of PTSD... I would venture IED/Rage too. I've seen IED in bicyclists and skateboarders! My overweening concern is the mix of a 5,000 lb potentially lethal weapon and a person (16 million persons +-) prone to rage while operating motor vehicles... I would never doubt the validity OF that rage, or underestimate the *inability* of the medical community to correctly diagnose and treat it in a manner constructive to the sufferer/victim. If indeed it is resolvable in the current societal context. At one trucking company I worked for, the examiner/trainer, after perusing my resume, simply said: "You're kinda short... can you reach the pedals?" and waited for a response. My response was: "I bring my own pedal blocks". He liked my sense of humor, and I was hired. If I had said something akin to.. "Hey! Didn't you see my resume and work experience? Of course I can reach the pedals!" I'm sure he would have passed. In a similar vein, the lowly traffic cop is a much better judge of the potential for rage in any given motorist than a psychiatrist. Doyle Saylor wrote:
Greetings Economists, On Jun 5, 2006, at 3:31 PM, Leigh Meyers wrote: As a truckdriver, I was quite fond of suggesting psychological profiles for motorists when applying for, or renewing their DLs. Doyle, My Father had that problem. Says below the quote the average for someone is 43 incidents in a lifetime. My Father had I would estimate (because who was counting) something like 2000 moments of Explosive Rage when I was growing up that I witnessed. Only people with mental illnesses have no rights at all in this culture. Now my Father had a hidden disability so he didn't have to put up with the extreme oppression pointed at mental illnesses. I rather think it impossible to have a profile of anyone that says they have road rage because the science is really wack. Most of that sort of DSM IV stuff is very very imprecise about what is being symptomized. In other words the persons are being labeled with medical jargon about who they as a disorder are in roughly the same way the cops label people under capitalism. Now my Father was abusive. So I have a particular interest in seeing 'justice' about abuse. However is abuse really dealt with by the 'law'? The law is slow, is unfair, is punitive when the real issue is social structure. So we took Sabri's question about information and I apply his query here. Does information have a value (explosive rage)? I see disorders as forms of information production, kinds of work processes. Their functionality depends upon how well a society frames the mental work that disorders represent. This society cannot bring it self to consider fundamental parts of this work process, those parts we call abuse. Because the abuse is emotion structure and dealing with emotion structure is still a primitive work process that can't be folded into large scale corporate profits. Pseudo scary rage in the movies makes money, but the whole range of emotion is left to founder upon the unskilled and unschooled public to work out. In order to make a Disability Rights movement we have to consider the spectrum of all these disabilities into a framework that currently is barbaric toward disabled people. So I see stopping abuse structures inherent in the call for Disabled Rights. But only the context that disability is surrounded by a society that frames society as a whole that does not exclude disabled people from rights period. In other words to end the wholesale loss of rights that mental illness brings upon human beings. Not to scape goat IED but to free and liberate all disablilty within a socialist context. thanks, Doyle Saylor
