On Wed, 2004-11-24 at 01:32, Ilya A. Kovalenko wrote: > Greetings, > > Just note. > > Stateful inspection on gateway can hamper tcp-connections, when > inbound or outbound packets goes another route (i.e. when one of > directions not goes thru gateway). > > Connection works fine on low rate, but fast transfers stops on > each 64K (because suddenly PF stops passing packets). > > I guess, it is not bug, just some feature (like some > tcp-window-related state protection). So think, is there reasons to > correct this PF behavior. > > Thank you > > Ilya A. Kovalenko
stateful firewalls are built on the premise that the firewall is in-line between client and server; and therefore, sees all requests/replies. asymmetric routing violates that premise; and therefore, all bets are off. if you *_must_* do this--allow states to be created on non-SYN packets (note: this is an *awful* idea). i will assume that you do not have delusions that this should work with NAT-ed connections, because it most certainly will not. -j -- "Another day, another box of stolen pens." --The Simpsons