On Fri, Dec 31, 2021 at 5:45 PM David Rowley <dgrowle...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Fri, 3 Dec 2021 at 20:36, Michael Paquier <mich...@paquier.xyz> wrote: > > Two months later, this has been switched to RwF. > > I was discussing this patch with Andres. He's not very keen on my > densehash hash table idea and suggested that instead of relying on > trying to make the hash table iteration faster, why don't we just > ditch the lossiness of the resource owner code which only records the > first 16 locks, and just make it have a linked list of all locks. > > This is a little more along the lines of the original patch, however, > it does not increase the size of the LOCALLOCK struct. > > I've attached a patch which does this. This was mostly written > (quickly) by Andres, I just did a cleanup, fixed up a few mistakes and > fixed a few bugs. > > I ran the same performance tests on this patch as I did back in [1]: > > -- Test 1. Select 1 record from a 140 partitioned table. Tests > creating a large number of locks with a fast query. > > create table hp (a int, b int) partition by hash(a); > select 'create table hp'||x||' partition of hp for values with > (modulus 140, remainder ' || x || ');' from generate_series(0,139)x; > create index on hp (b); > insert into hp select x,x from generate_series(1, 140000) x; > analyze hp; > > select3.sql: select * from hp where b = 1 > > select3.sql master > > drowley@amd3990x:~$ pgbench -n -f select3.sql -T 60 -M prepared postgres > tps = 2099.708748 (without initial connection time) > tps = 2100.398516 (without initial connection time) > tps = 2094.882341 (without initial connection time) > tps = 2113.218820 (without initial connection time) > tps = 2104.717597 (without initial connection time) > > select3.sql patched > > drowley@amd3990x:~$ pgbench -n -f select3.sql -T 60 -M prepared postgres > tps = 2010.070738 (without initial connection time) > tps = 1994.963606 (without initial connection time) > tps = 1994.668849 (without initial connection time) > tps = 1995.948168 (without initial connection time) > tps = 1985.650945 (without initial connection time) > > You can see that there's a performance regression here. I've not yet > studied why this appears. > > -- Test 2. Tests a prepared query which will perform a generic plan on > the 6th execution then fallback on a custom plan due to it pruning all > but one partition. Master suffers from the lock table becoming > bloated after locking all partitions when planning the generic plan. > > create table ht (a int primary key, b int, c int) partition by hash (a); > select 'create table ht' || x::text || ' partition of ht for values > with (modulus 8192, remainder ' || (x)::text || ');' from > generate_series(0,8191) x; > \gexec > > select.sql: > \set p 1 > select * from ht where a = :p > > select.sql master > drowley@amd3990x:~$ pgbench -n -f select.sql -T 60 -M prepared postgres > tps = 18014.460090 (without initial connection time) > tps = 17973.358889 (without initial connection time) > tps = 17847.480647 (without initial connection time) > tps = 18038.332507 (without initial connection time) > tps = 17776.143206 (without initial connection time) > > select.sql patched > drowley@amd3990x:~$ pgbench -n -f select.sql -T 60 -M prepared postgres > tps = 32393.457106 (without initial connection time) > tps = 32277.204349 (without initial connection time) > tps = 32160.719830 (without initial connection time) > tps = 32530.038130 (without initial connection time) > tps = 32299.019657 (without initial connection time) > > You can see that there are some quite good performance gains with this > test. > > I'm going to add this to the January commitfest. > > David > > [1] > https://www.postgresql.org/message-id/CAKJS1f8Lt0kS4bb5EH%3DhV%2BksqBZNnmVa8jujoYBYu5PVhWbZZg%40mail.gmail.com Hi, + locallock->nLocks -= locallockowner->nLocks; + Assert(locallock->nLocks >= 0); I think the assertion is not needed since the above code is in if block : + if (locallockowner->nLocks < locallock->nLocks) the condition, locallock->nLocks >= 0, would always hold after the subtraction. Cheers