Hi hackers,

Relcache errors from time to time detect catalog corruptions. For example, 
recently I observed following:
1. Filesystem or nvme disk zeroed out leading 160Kb of catalog index. This type 
of corruption passes through data_checksums.
2. RelationBuildTupleDesc() was failing with "catalog is missing 1 attribute(s) 
for relid 2662".
3. We monitor corruption error codes and alert on-call DBAs when see one, but 
the message is not marked as XX001 or XX002. It's XX000 which happens from time 
to time due to less critical reasons than data corruption.
4. High-availability automation switched primary to other host and other 
monitoring checks did not ring too.

This particular case is not very illustrative. In fact we had index corruption 
that looked like catalog corruption.
But still it looks to me that catalog inconsistencies (like relnatts != number 
of pg_attribute rows) could be marked with ERRCODE_DATA_CORRUPTED.
This particular error code in my experience proved to be a good indicator for 
early corruption detection.

What do you think?
What other subsystems can be improved in the same manner?

Best regards, Andrey Borodin.


Attachment: v1-0001-Add-corruption-error-codes-to-relcache-entries.patch
Description: Binary data

Reply via email to