> How did you do that? Did you increase the number of rows, make the rows
> wider (by increasing the 'repeat' parameter in the script), or something
> else? Did you verify the table really is 1000x larger?
>
I increased the number of rows by 1000. I didn't really check the size of
the table, the time increase suggests that it was right.
> The "10k table row" means repeat('x',10000) when generating data? Oh, I
> see you're using some string_agg(), to make it not compress. But note
> that if it's TOASTed, it become entirely irrelevant for the prefetching
> test because it's in a separate relation.
>
sorry, 10k row table, for the payload I left a note
> [b] This time I used a (SELECT string_agg((i*j)::text, '+') FROM
> generate_series(1, 50)) instead of repeat('x', 100), just to prevent it
> from compressing to nothing when I try larger payloads, and hit the
> TOAST thresholds. I removed the primary key `id` because it was annoying
> to take 20 minutes to insert the data in the large scale test.
> Unfortunately, you have not included the new script, so we can't try
> reproducing your results.
>
Let me try to find something not so insane.
128kB shared buffers is a little bit ... insane. I refuse to optimize
> anything for this value, and I don't even call about regressions. Even
> 128MB is not really practical, any serious system caring about
> performance will use tens or hundreds of GBs of shared buffers.
>
I am not going to dispute that
> If the tests I am doing are pointless, should we consider having
> > something in the planner to prevent these scans from using prefetch?
> >
>
> How would you do that? Please explain.
>
I have no idea. But based on what you said I thought you would know. In my
head: "If my test seemed ridiculous to them all, they have some clear
boundaries in their mind that they could write in the planner".
> ... or you could modify the script to simply use sudo.
>
In that case sudo would request a password to the caller, and the caller is
a python script, no interaction there, of course I could do all the steps
manually, but it is more error prone (just my own mistakes are enough).
Regards,
Alexandre
