On Wed, 24 Mar 2021 at 14:48, Tomas Vondra
<tomas.von...@enterprisedb.com> wrote:
>
> AFAIK the primary issue here is that the two places disagree. While
> estimate_num_groups does this
>
> varnos = pull_varnos(root, (Node *) varshere);
> if (bms_membership(varnos) == BMS_SINGLETON)
> { ... }
>
> the add_unique_group_expr does this
>
> varnos = pull_varnos(root, (Node *) groupexpr);
>
> That is, one looks at the group expression, while the other look at vars
> extracted from it by pull_var_clause(). Apparently for PlaceHolderVar
> this can differ, causing the crash.
>
> So we need to change one of those places - my fix tweaked the second
> place to also look at the vars, but maybe we should change the other
> place? Or maybe it's not the right fix for PlaceHolderVars ...
>
I think that it doesn't make any difference which place is changed.
This is a case of an expression with no stats. With your change,
you'll get a single GroupExprInfo containing a list of
VariableStatData's for each of it's Var's, whereas if you changed it
the other way, you'd get a separate GroupExprInfo for each Var. But I
think they'd both end up being treated the same by
estimate_multivariate_ndistinct(), since there wouldn't be any stats
matching the expression, only the individual Var's. Maybe changing the
first place would be the more bulletproof fix though.
Regards,
Dean
