Andrew Dunstan wrote:
Tom's idea of making a temp copy of the repo and patching that would work,
but if you're going to do that why do a vpath build anyway?

In this case, the answer is to make sure that your patch works when *someone else* does a vpath build.

Regarding the idea of a list of approved patch authorisers, don't we have
such a group now? i.e. "committers".

Right, and if committers or others are willing to put in the time required to verify that patches aren't nasty before going onto the blessed patch queue, the idea could quite possibly work and provide some value. Note that all we really need to test for here is that the patch isn't malicious; patches that are bad design or whatever are unlikely to open security holes or fry your box. A major point of the queue is that the appropriate committer often doesn't have the time to review the patch right now. There might be some benefit in allowing a wider set of contributors to bless patches as non-nasty for testing purposes, rather than waste the limited time of qualified committers. Maybe such an army doesn't exist, though.

Cheers

Tom




---------------------------(end of broadcast)---------------------------
TIP 4: Have you searched our list archives?

              http://archives.postgresql.org

Reply via email to