Thanks a lot Madusudanan, Igor, Lutz and Jeff for your suggestions.
What I can confirm is that the UNION ideas runs extremely fast (don't
have access to the db right now to test the subquery idea, but will
check next week as I travel right now). Thanks again! :)
I was wondering: would it be possible for PostgreSQL to rewrite the
query to generate the UNION (or subquery plan if it's also fast) on it's
own?
Thanks,
Sven
On 22.09.2016 16:44, lfischer wrote:
Hi Sven
Why not do something like
SELECT * FROM big_table
WHERE
id in (SELECT big_table_id FROM table_a WHERE "table_a"."item_id"
IN (<handful of items>))
OR
id in (SELECT big_table_id FROM table_a WHERE "table_b"."item_id"
IN (<handful of items>))
that way you don't need the "distinct" and therefore there should be
less comparison going on.
Lutz
On 22/09/16 14:24, Sven R. Kunze wrote:
Hi pgsql-performance list,
what is the recommended way of doing **multiple-table-spanning joins
with ORs in the WHERE-clause**?
Until now, we've used the LEFT OUTER JOIN to filter big_table like so:
SELECT DISTINCT <fields of big_table>
FROM
"big_table"
LEFT OUTER JOIN "table_a" ON ("big_table"."id" =
"table_a"."big_table_id")
LEFT OUTER JOIN "table_b" ON ("big_table"."id" =
"table_b"."big_table_id")
WHERE
"table_a"."item_id" IN (<handful of items>)
OR
"table_b"."item_id" IN (<handful of items>);
However, this results in an awful slow plan (requiring to scan the
complete big_table which obviously isn't optimal).
So, we decided (at least for now) to split up the query into two
separate ones and merge/de-duplicate the result with application logic:
SELECT <fields of big_table>
FROM
"big_table" INNER JOIN "table_a" ON ("big_table"."id" =
"table_a"."big_table_id")
WHERE
"table_a"."item_id" IN (<handful of items>);
SELECT <fields of big_table>
FROM
"big_table" INNER JOIN "table_b" ON ("big_table"."id" =
"table_b"."big_table_id")
WHERE
"table_b"."item_id" IN (<handful of items>);
As you can imagine we would be very glad to solve this issue with a
single query and without having to re-code existing logic of
PostgreSQL. But how?
Best,
Sven
PS: if you require EXPLAIN ANALYZE, I can post them as well.
--
Sent via pgsql-performance mailing list (pgsql-performance@postgresql.org)
To make changes to your subscription:
http://www.postgresql.org/mailpref/pgsql-performance
