ID: 45008 Updated by: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reported By: bruno dot caillaud at cndp dot fr Status: Open Bug Type: *General Issues Operating System: Windows XP PHP Version: 5.2.6 New Comment:
Just a note about bug #42814: "No feedback" is not same as "Closed" in which case there would be an entry in the NEWS file about a fixed bug.. Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2008-05-15 14:41:48] bruno dot caillaud at cndp dot fr Description: ------------ I read the Bug #42814 which is supposed to be closed, however, I have reproduced this bug in the last version 5.2.6 this is a sample code : <?php class Base { private $basePrivateProperty; protected $baseprotectedProperty; function getProperties () { return get_object_vars ( $this ); } } class Child extends Base { private $childPrivateProperty; protected $childprotectedProperty; } echo "Base :<br/>\n"; $father = new Base(); var_dump($father->getProperties()); echo "<br/>Child :<br/>\n"; $children = new Child(); var_dump($children->getProperties()); ?> Running this sample code Result on different versions of php 5: PHP version 5.2.0 to 5.2.3 : Base : array(2) { ["basePrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } Child : array(3) { ["childPrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["childprotectedProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } PHP version 5.2.4 to 5.2.6: Base : array(2) { ["basePrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } Child : array(3) { ["childprotectedProperty"]=> NULL ["basePrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } I think the good behaviour is the one returned by versions 5.2.0 to 5.2.3. in 5.2.4 version and up, the child can access to his parent's private property but not to his own private property Reproduce code: --------------- <?php class Base { private $basePrivateProperty; protected $baseprotectedProperty; function getProperties () { return get_object_vars ( $this ); } } class Child extends Base { private $childPrivateProperty; protected $childprotectedProperty; } echo "Base :<br/>\n"; $father = new Base(); var_dump($father->getProperties()); echo "<br/>Child :<br/>\n"; $children = new Child(); var_dump($children->getProperties()); ?> Expected result: ---------------- Base : array(2) { ["basePrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } Child : array(3) { ["childPrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["childprotectedProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } Actual result: -------------- Base : array(2) { ["basePrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } Child : array(3) { ["childprotectedProperty"]=> NULL ["basePrivateProperty"]=> NULL ["baseprotectedProperty"]=> NULL } ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=45008&edit=1