ID: 19545 Comment by: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reported By: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Status: Open Bug Type: Feature/Change Request Operating System: Windows 95 PHP Version: 4.2.3 New Comment:
Oh, I would if I could. But I'm afraid I do not have any competence at all for that. I started programming only one year ago. I know nothing of C, for example, except that PHP inherited a lot from it so they look alike sometimes. I wouldn't know where to start. I have no intention to put up any "battle". I just miss the feature very often, never saw any mention of it anywhere, not even in this bug/feature request section, and thought that maybe it was time someone asked for it. But if that's how the development team feels about it, case closed. Again, thanks for the reply. Luciano Espirito Santo [Note to passers-by and occasional readers: reading my previous message again, I noticed that I claim to "spend a lot of time writing in Perl". It sounds as if I actually spend a lot of time writing in Perl and that I am a Perl expert. What I actually meant was that I take too long to write anything in Perl, because I do not feel comfortable with it.] Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-11-10 23:59:21] [EMAIL PROTECTED] You really have nothing to complain about until you submit a patch with this functionality. Then you can argue its technical merits. Asking us to implement a feature that none of us need is a rather impossible battle for you. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-11-10 23:52:38] [EMAIL PROTECTED] I'm disappointed to hear that. PHP is "intented primarely for web" (sic), but that doesn't have to rule out other uses. Several articles about the use of PHP as a shell scripting language have been written. I think it is just a natural step for anyone who makes extensive and intensive use of PHP. What is the point of php-cli.exe, anyway? I've been messing with several other languages lately, only in search of better integration with the Windows environment, so I can make better use of shell and/or automation scripts. I've tried Perl, Ruby, Tcl, Python and even stinky VB, and a few of these languages support the Windows clipboard. Not only that, they handle CGI functions but also seek better integration with the Windows environment. Especially Python. But I don't like Python. I don't want to write in Python. I could write in Perl and not feel miserable, but I spend a lot of time writing in Perl. I know PHP, that is the one I know. I feel comfortable writing in PHP. It is an excellent language, IMO superior to all others in several aspects, why does it (still) have to be regarded as a "Web-only" language? Why can't it extend into other territories, like Python is doing and becoming ever more popular as we speak? GTK is a good point. But GTK slows everything down a little, and not all shell applications require a GUI. I think it is just natural for any of these languages to evolve and extend its functionalities. PHP knows that. That's why PHP-cli was made, that's why its OOP (classes) implementation has been getting so much attention, that's why some effort has been made towards developing and improving its XML, COM and Windows API functions. Anyway, if there is any other reason for not implementing clipboard functions in PHP, fine. But let it be a more reasonable one. Because if clipboard functions are "completely off topic", what to say of COM and Windows API? And if it's "for Web use only", then why bother with PHP-cli? Thanks for the reply, at any rate. Luciano Espirito Santo ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-11-10 18:10:44] [EMAIL PROTECTED] PHP is intented primarely for web - such feature would be completely off topic. I can only picture GTK using something like that... ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-09-21 23:12:35] [EMAIL PROTECTED] -- ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-09-21 17:29:30] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Hi. I've always wanted to be able to read from and write to Windows' clipboard. It is possible in Perl, but I prefer to use PHP. I do not intend to manipulate a Web site visitor's clipboard through CGI, I know it is impossible. It is for shell scripting only. PHP has such an incredible number of functions, it surprises me that no such functions have been made yet. Many thanks, Luciano Espirito Santo ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=19545&edit=1
