ID: 39465 User updated by: raven7370 at yahoo dot com Reported By: raven7370 at yahoo dot com Status: Assigned -Bug Type: Unknown/Other Function +Bug Type: Scripting Engine problem Operating System: Win32 (XP SP2) PHP Version: 5.2.0 Assigned To: derick New Comment:
i guess this category fits better... Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2006-11-10 20:42:51] raven7370 at yahoo dot com forgot the OllyDbg pics.. not sure if they help, just in case: original: (problem area is highlighted) http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem.PNG <img src="http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem.PNG";> bad quick fix: http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem_badFix.PNG <img src="http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem_badFix.PNG";> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2006-11-10 16:13:28] raven7370 at yahoo dot com Description: ------------ zend_strtod infinite loop In Short: What causes the problem: Script A stores data in a session, creates two images that call Script B that reads the session data to create two different graphs. The problem: During the unserialize of the session data retrieval the zend_strtod function is called, when multiple concurrent threads unserialize the same data there is (in my experience) a 10% chance that: A: one of the thread crashes (apache error box, main apache thread and other thread still runs) or B: that the zend_strtod function hangs in an infinite loop for both threads. The second (the infinite loop) is far worse since both Threads hang and completely maxes out the two CPUs. Leaving the main Apache thread with so little cpu cycles that any other page request will never finish. The code that hangs in an infinite loop at the end of the zend_strtod function is: for (i = 0; i <= Kmax; i++) { Bigint **listp = &freelist[i]; while ((tmp = *listp) != NULL) { *listp = tmp->next; free(tmp); } freelist[i] = NULL; } while (p5s) { tmp = p5s; p5s = p5s->next; free(tmp); } It either hangs in the first while or the second while loop (most of the time on the first). The reason for the infinite loop is that somehow the next pointer references create a circular loop every time I have seen it, it is just a two link loop, i.e. A->B and B->A and both threads are affected and looping in the same position. This is not just on the debug version but also on the stable 5.1.6 and 5.2 binary release files. Using OllyDbg the code is: If I circumvent the code execution described above (using the stable binary release files) with a two byte short jmp, I no longer have any infinite loop hanging the server or crashes BUT apparently a memory leak since I have removed what appears to be a clean up of a linked list. So this is a really BAD fix but it is still BETTER then the infinite loop.. dont you think? Important note: (apparently only HT / multi cpu/core have this problem) I have these problems on a cpu with HT, not a true multi core or multi cpu.. but another system with a normal (single core, non HT cpu) does not have the problem.. I think only one thread might be created by php since windows only shows one cpu. Anyway.. a true fix would be really great since iI have no idea what excluding the above code REALLY means I am somewhat hoping that when a thread is killed that windows cleans up.. but does it? And even if it does, when is a php worker thread killed? Btw.. thread safety is ON when this problem occurs. (and this is as short as i could make it ;) Thanks for any help!!! Reproduce code: --------------- Well its a thread interaction problem that is very hard to reproduce on command, I tried to create a script that maximizes the occurrence (one php script that sores some random x & y values in an array and that creats html that continuously loads two images from another php script that uses the session data to draw random images.. But with that I couldnt reproduce the bug at all the original script gets the data from a mysql database using adodb and the data stored in the session is more complex.. not sure what exactly makes this go off or not and unfortunately I cant post the original script and database since it is work related :( But I tried to narrow the problem down as much as I could and hope that someone might have a clue on what goes wrong where Expected result: ---------------- Well i would expect multiple concurrent session unserializations of the same data to NOT cause the server to die in a horrible infinite loop >_> Actual result: -------------- well it does.. die.. well ok it just hangs with 100% cpu makeing everything else go 0.00001x speed but that makes a server and everything running on it useless :( i mean apache can't even answer the request for a new plain unrelated html anymore! thanks for any help!!! and please do help! ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=39465&edit=1
![http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem.PNG"](http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem.PNG"){kind=link}
![http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem_badFix.PNG"](http://raven.is-a-geek.net/PostInfo/php5ts_zend_strtod_problem_badFix.PNG"){kind=link}