Sorry for the double post, here's the godbolt link regarding the claim of very similar assembly: https://godbolt.org/g/uAJsRw
> On 9. Aug 2018, at 12:52, Alexander Matz <[email protected]> wrote: > > Hi PicoLisp Community! > > I'm working on a macOS system, where clang is the system compiler and so I'm > interested in getting PicoLisp to work there. > The current code uses a barely documented, non-standard GCC extension, name > vla-members in structs inside of functions. > This is a minimal demonstration of the feature: > void f() { > struct { > int vla[g()]; // vla-member, int array of size g() > } s; > } > > This feature is not, and will not be, supported by clang, see > http://releases.llvm.org/6.0.0/tools/clang/docs/UsersManual.html > <http://releases.llvm.org/6.0.0/tools/clang/docs/UsersManual.html> unter > "Intentionally unsupported BCC extensions". > VLA-Members is not to be confused with flexible array members ("<type> > <name>[]" as the last member), which are a valid C99 feature. > > The patch attached translates all uses of bindFrame as an anonymous struct > with a VLA-member to a combination of a regular byte-vla for memory and a > bindFrame pointer into that memory. > This requires the bindFrame uses in question to use indirection, rendering > the patch a bit noisy. > As far as I'm aware and able to test, the behavior is identical. > The assembly generated by gcc is very similar, albeit slightly different. > > Overall the code is slightly shorter because the bindFrame struct is not > redefined as an anonymous struct 11 times throughout the code. > > I'm not able to fully test everything because I'm struggling with the test > suite; I don't know whether this is due to me using macOS or misusing > PicoLisp. > Cursory tests were successful however. > > The patch is generated from the git mirror but applies to the source in > picoLisp-18.6.tgz > > I'm happy about all feedback. > > Best Regards, > Alexander Matz > > <0001-no-vla-member-in-anonymous-bindFrame-clang-compatibi.patch>
