I've included below my second set of comments on the proposed names as
described here
http://defect.opensolaris.org/bz/attachment.cgi?id=3269
It covers packages starting with SUNWlcms and ends with everything
under the "service" hieraechy.
SUNWlcms library/lcms
library/liblcms?
SUNWlibcroco library/libcroco
SUNWlibdaemon library/libdaemon
SUNWlibexif library/libexif
SUNWjpg library/libjpeg
SUNWmusicbrainz library/libmusicbrainz
SUNWlibdiscid library/libmusicbrainz/discid
SUNWneon library/libneon
SUNWpcre library/libpcre
SUNWpng library/libpng
SUNWlibpopt library/libpopt
SUNWslang library/libslang
SUNWtecla library/libtecla
SUNWlxml library/libxml2
SUNWlxsl library/libxslt
SUNWmfrun library/motif
OK
SUNWxwdxm library/motif/dps
library/motif/libdpstkXm
SUNWnet6 library/net6
library/libnet6
SUNWobby library/obby
library/libobby
SUNWperl-authen-pam library/perl5/authen-pam
SUNWpmdbi library/perl5/database
SUNWperl-net-ssleay library/perl5/net-ssleay
SUNWperl-pmtools library/perl5/pmtools
SUNWpmdbdpg library/perl5/postgres-dbi
SUNWsvn-perl library/perl5/subversion
SUNWperl-xml-parser library/perl5/xml-parser
OK
SUNWcups-libs library/print/cups
library/print/libcups?
SUNWpycups library/print/cups/python
library/python2/pycups
SUNWfoomatic-db library/print/foomatic-db
SUNWfoomatic-db-engine library/print/foomatic-db-engine
SUNWffilters library/print/foomatic-filter
SUNWfppd library/print/foomatic-ppd
It would be good to get input from Norm Jacobs on this. It
seems to be that SUNWfoomatic-db-engine should really be
command/foomatic and the others should be under
library/print/foomatic?
SUNWippcore library/print/ipp
library/print/libipp
SUNWpapi library/print/libpapi
OK
SUNWpsm-ipp library/print/open-printing/ipp-module
SUNWpsm-lpd
library/print/open-printing/rfc1179-module
SUNWpsf library/print/postscript-filter
OK
SUNWpython24-ctypes library/python/ctypes-24
SUNWpywbem library/python/pywbem
Why are these under library/python instead of library/python2?
SUNWpython-cherrypy library/python2/cherrypy
SUNWpython26-coherence library/python2/coherence-26
SUNWcompizconfig-python library/python2/compizconfig
SUNWpython26-cssutils library/python2/cssutils-26
SUNWPython-extra library/python2/extra
SUNWPython26-extra library/python2/extra-26
SUNWgnome-python-desktop library/python2/gnome2
SUNWgnome-python26-desktop library/python2/gnome2-26
SUNWgst-python library/python2/gstreamer
SUNWgst-python26 library/python2/gstreamer-26
SUNWpython-imaging library/python2/imaging
SUNWpython26-imaging library/python2/imaging-26
SUNWlogilab-astng library/python2/logilab-astng
SUNWlogilab-common library/python2/logilab-common
OK
SUNWpython-lxml library/python2/lxml
SUNWpython26-lxml library/python2/lxml-26
SUNWpython-mako library/python2/mako
SUNWpython-notify library/python2/notify
SUNWpython26-notify library/python2/notify-26
SUNWgnome-python-libs library/python2/pygtk
SUNWgnome-python26-libs library/python2/pygtk-26
SUNWsexy-python library/python2/pygtk-sexy
SUNWpython-pyopenssl library/python2/pyopenssl
SUNWpython26-pyopenssl library/python2/pyopenssl-26
SUNWpython-setuptools library/python2/setuptools
SUNWpython26-setuptools library/python2/setuptools-26
SUNWpython24-simplejson library/python2/simplejson-24
SUNWpython26-simplejson library/python2/simplejson-26
SUNWsvn-python library/python2/subversion
SUNWpython-twisted library/python2/twisted
SUNWpython26-twisted library/python2/twisted-26
SUNWpython-twisted-web2 library/python2/twisted-web2
SUNWpython26-twisted-web2 library/python2/twisted-web2-26
SUNWpython-xdg library/python2/xdg
SUNWpython26-xdg library/python2/xdg-26
SUNWpython-zope-interface library/python2/zope-interface
SUNWpython26-zope-interface library/python2/zope-interface-26
OK
SUNWkrb library/security/kerberos-5
service/security/kerberos5?
SUNWlibgpg-error library/security/libgpg-error
SUNWopenssl library/security/openssl
SUNWopenssl-fips-140 library/security/openssl-fips-140
OK
SUNWspnego library/security/spnego
system/library/security/gss/spnego
SUNWtss library/security/tss
library/security/trousers (or
system/library/security/trousers?)
SUNWima library/storage/ima
SUNWtltk library/tooltalk
OK
SUNWlxml-python library/xml-python
library/python2/libxml?
SUNWlxml-python26 library/xml-python26
library/python2/libxml-26?
SUNWlxsl-python26 library/xslt-python26
library/python2/libxsl?
SUNWevolution mail/evolution
SUNWfetchmail mail/fetchmail
SUNWmutt mail/mutt
SUNWprocmail mail/procmail
SUNWthunderbird mail/thunderbird
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-de-DE mail/thunderbird/locale/de
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-es-ES mail/thunderbird/locale/es
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-extra mail/thunderbird/locale/extra
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-fr-FR mail/thunderbird/locale/fr
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-it-IT mail/thunderbird/locale/it
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-ja-JP mail/thunderbird/locale/ja
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-ko-KR mail/thunderbird/locale/ko
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-pl-PL mail/thunderbird/locale/pl
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-pt-BR mail/thunderbird/locale/pt_BR
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-ru-RU mail/thunderbird/locale/ru
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-sv-SE mail/thunderbird/locale/sv
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-zh-CN mail/thunderbird/locale/zh_CN
SUNWthunderbirdl10n-zh-TW mail/thunderbird/locale/zh_TW
SUNWthunderbird-calendar mail/thunderbird/plugin/lightning
OK
SUNWncft network/ftp/ncftp
OK
SUNWgnutls network/gnutls
library/gnutls?
SUNWipf network/ipfilter
driver/network/ipfilter?
SUNWnmap network/nmap
OK
SUNWpppd network/ppp
driver/network/ppp
SUNWpppg network/ppp/pppdump
OK
SUNWroute network/routing
SUNWrsync network/rsync
SUNWssh network/ssh
OK
SUNWvrrp network/vrrp
network/routing/vrrp
SUNWipkg package/ips
Why not package/pkg?
SUNWipkg-brand package/ips-brand
system/zones/brand/ipkg
SUNWipkg-gui package/ips-packagemanager
package/pkg/packagemanager?
SUNWipkg-gui-l10n package/ips-packagemanmager-l10n
Obsolete.
SUNWipkg-um package/ips-updatemanager
package/pkg/updatemanager?
SUNWrpm package/rpm
SUNWpkgcmds package/svr4-packaging
package/svr4?
SUNWos86r platform/i86pc/base
driver/network/misc?
SUNWcpc platform/i86pc/driver/cpc
Also available on SPARC so perhaps
platform/kernel/cpu-counters?
SUNWcakr platform/kernel
SUNWa2ps print/a2ps
OK
SUNWscplp print/compat-sunos4
Or print/compat-usb?
SUNWcups print/cups
OK
SUNWcups-manager print/cups-manager
print/cups/cups-manager?
SUNWgutenprint print/gutenprint
OK
SUNWhpijs print/hp-inkjet
Please check with Norm Jacobs but this comes from the upstream
"hplip" project so perhaps print/hplip?
SUNWmp print/mp-filter
SUNWppm print/print-manager
SUNWpsutils print/psutils
OK
SUNWsolnm release/base
release/name?
SUNWdistro-license-copyright release/copyright
SUNWgetting-started-guide release/getting-started
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-de release/getting-started/de
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-es release/getting-started/es
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-extra release/getting-started/extra
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-fr release/getting-started/fr
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-it release/getting-started/it
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-ja release/getting-started/ja
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-ko release/getting-started/ko
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-ptBR release/getting-started/pt
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-ru release/getting-started/ru
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-sv release/getting-started/sv
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-zhCN release/getting-started/zh_CN
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-zhHK release/getting-started/zh_HK
SUNWgetting-started-l10n-zhTW release/getting-started/zh_TW
SUNWopensolaris-welcome release/opensolaris-welcome
OK
SUNWn2cp service/crypto/h2cp
driver/crypto/n2cp
SUNWdcaf service/dcaf
driver/crypto/dca
SUNWstosreg service/distro/registration
Although this delivers a service, it seems more tied to
"release". Perhaps, release/registration?
SUNWfmd service/fmd
SUNWdesktop-cache service/gnome2/cache
OK
SUNWvgl service/graphics/virtualgl
image/virtualgl?
SUNWhal service/hal
OK
SUNWhal-cups-utils service/hal/cups-utils
library/print/cups/hal?
SUNWrmvolmgr service/media-volume-manager
OK
SUNWndmp service/ndmp
service/storage/ndmp?
SUNWcns service/network/common
service/network/legacy?
SUNWdhcsb service/network/dhcp/bootp-data
XXX
SUNWdhcs service/network/dhcp/bootp-server
service/network/dhcp?
SUNWcsdhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/cs
SUNWddhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/de
SUNWedhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/es
SUNWfdhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/fr
SUNWidhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/it
SUNWjdhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/ja
SUNWkdhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/ko
SUNWsdhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/sv
SUNWcdhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/zh_CH
SUNWhdhcm service/network/dhcp/locale/zh_TW
As these are associated with the DHCP manager and not the
service, I would put them under network/dhcp/dhcpmgr/locale.
SUNWdhcm service/network/dhcp/manager
network/dhcp/dhcpmgr
SUNWbind service/network/dns/bind
OK
SUNWdsd service/network/dns/multicast
OK or service/network/dns/mdns?
SUNWftp service/network/ftp
OK
SUNWnfss service/network/nfs/server
Why not just service/network/nfs or service/storage/nfs?
SUNWnis service/network/nis/client
Yes, this does contain the client service but it seems strange
to have it under the "service" component. What isn't this just
system/network/nis?
SUNWyp service/network/nis/server
And this service/network/nis?
SUNWntp service/network/ntp
OK
SUNWsmba service/network/samba
OK or service/storage/samba?
SUNWser service/network/ser
service/network/sip/ser?
SUNWserweb service/network/ser-web
service/network/sip/ser/admin?
SUNWslp service/network/slp
OK
SUNWsmbfs service/network/smb/client
Yes, this does contain the client service but it seems strange
to have it under the "service" component. What isn't this just
system/network/smb or system/storage/smb?
SUNWsmbs service/network/smb/server
service/network/smb or service/storage/smb?
SUNWsndm service/network/smtp/sendmail
OK
SUNWmibii service/network/snmp
Another thing that should be removed. I would put this under
service/network/snmp/mibiisa for now.
SUNWsshd service/network/ssh
SUNWtnetd service/network/telnet
SUNWtftp service/network/tftp
SUNWbnu service/network/uucp
SUNWwpa service/network/wpa
OK
SUNWpciaccess service/pciaccess
command/scanpci?
SUNWpicl service/picl
OR or service/picl?
SUNWipmi service/platform/i86pc/ipmi
system/command/ipmitool?
SUNWpostrun service/postrun
OK
SUNWpc service/print/client
Not a service - command/print/lp?
SUNWippl service/print/ipp-listener
OK
SUNWps service/print/lp/server
service/print/lp?
SUNWrcap service/rcap
service/resource-cap?
SUNWrds service/rds
driver/infiniband/rds
SUNWpool service/resource-pools
OK
SUNWrsmo service/rsmo
system/kernel/rsmops
SUNWgss service/security/gss
library/security/libgss?
SUNWgssc service/security/gss/config
service/security/gss?
SUNWkdc service/security/kerberos
More of a client package - system/kerberos5?
SUNWtlsd service/security/network/devel
SUNWtlsu service/security/network/utils
In some sense they need to be combined and in some sense,
refactored. They don't belong under "service" - maybe under
"legacy/iplanet" :-)
How about system/library/libnss/headers and
system/library/libnss respectively?
SUNWpampkcs11 service/security/pampkcs11
Another candidate for library/security/pam/modules? As in
library/security/pam/modules/pkcs11?
SUNWstunnel service/security/stunnel
OK
SUNWscm service/storage/cache-management
service/storage/avs/cache-management?
SUNWcfpl service/storage/fibre-channel
service/storage/fibre-channel/fc-fabric?
SUNWiscsit service/storage/iscsi/comstar
service/storage/iscsi/comstar/target?
SUNWiscsidm service/storage/iscsi/data-mover
Not a service. How about storage/iscsi/comstar/data-mover?
SUNWiscsi service/storage/iscsi/initiator
SUNWiscsitgt service/storage/iscsi/target
SUNWisns service/storage/isns
OK
SUNWmda service/storage/volume-manager/assistant
system/command/metassist?
SUNWadmr service/sysidtool
service/identity/sysidtool?
SUNWudaplt service/udapl/tavor
Not a service - I would suggest storage/udapl/tavor.
SUNWvscan service/virus-scan
Why not service/storage/virus-scan?
SUNWxwplr service/x11
OK
_______________________________________________
pkg-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/pkg-discuss
