This topic is being discussed under two different threads, so I am starting fresh new thread,
I am not a maintainer of qqc2-breeze-style but more of user let's say "end-user" for the qqc2-breeze-style, and honestly I am saddened by tone of discussion we are seeing here :( I will try to answer some questions here, - Was qqc2-breeze-style rushed for Plasma Mobile? Yes, Plasma theme was simply *not* performant on mobile device, we had this issue known from very start that Plasma qqc2 theme have performance issues, one of issue was SVG cache which is now solved in plasma-framework master, performance issues were known back from very first Plasma Mobile sprint back in 2019, that even desktop style provided better performance then what Plasma qqc2 theme provided. We were meant to ship few thousand mobile devices with Plasma Mobile to end-users and performance shown by Plasma qqc2 theme was simply not acceptable, we even performed several benchmarks on all styles including desktop style and Plasma theme and qqc2-breeze-style was clear winner there. So yes, I take full responsibility for approving usage of qqc2-breeze-style on Plasma Mobile and I think that was necessary, I'd rather have a small bugs then completely 20-30 FPS UI on mobile which Plasma theme was offering in some cases. - Was qqc2-breeze-style rushed for Plasma release schedule/inclusion? I honestly do not think so, Noah sent message about moving of qqc2-breeze-style to kdereview on Jan 7, and Jonathan moved it out of kdereview, 3 weeks of time is *enough* to raise any objections, but we got simply 0 emails, in parallel, several issues were found and several issues were fixed when discussing in Plasma Mobile chat and other private mediums, but no objections I know were raised in public thread at all. - Is qqc2-breeze-style better choice for the Plasma Desktop? I do not know and I personally have no stakes here, Marco has raised perfectly valid technical points in his email, and I think those should be discussed/solved. Regards. -- Bhushan Shah http://blog.bshah.in IRC Nick : bshah on Freenode GPG key fingerprint : 0AAC 775B B643 7A8D 9AF7 A3AC FE07 8411 7FBC E11D
signature.asc
Description: PGP signature
