On Thursday 08 December 2011 16:01:33 Xavier Sythe wrote: > Nearly two months ago, I contacted him, and asked him to reverse the > controversial commit. > He has yet to reply. Please understand that not each developer has the time to answer personal requests. You state yourself that it is controversial. Just imagine each user disliking the feature sending a mail to Kevin. That just doesn't scale.
Asking to revert the feature is to be honest non-constructive criticism. Like all other decisions on the default user interface they are done with care. The breadcrumbs add high value to Kickoff. It makes navigation in a folder like structure like the application menu more convenient and much more consistant with other parts of KDE applications, e.g. Dolphin's breadcrumb navigation. Just because you (and others) dislike the new feature it does not justify to revert the commit. There are also users liking the feature, so how should we suit both groups? Now please don't state that we need an option for that. This is not possible as the code gets too complex and too difficult to maintain. > > When I asked the #KDE IRC channel about this, I was told to contact the > members of this mailing list, to see if I could get the commit reversed. Reverting the commit is clearly not an option. But what would you say about improving the breadcrumbs in Kickoff? Getting them into a state that you want to use them and not the out-of-place back button? Have a look at my recent blog post [1] about the work on Kickoff for 4.9. It is easy to give this version a try, it installs alongside the existing Kickoff. I personally do not see any need for the back button any more. Kind Regards Martin Gräßlin New Kickoff Maintainer after branch merged into master [1] http://blog.martin-graesslin.com/blog/2011/12/experience-from-porting- kickoff-to-qml/
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
_______________________________________________ Plasma-devel mailing list Plasma-devel@kde.org https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/plasma-devel
