Perhaps we should just add documentation about incompatibility of the 1.1.x branch starting at 1.1.3 and recut the 1.1.4 release as 1.1.5.
I am very much against moving toward a 1.2.0 release. We should not get mired in a 1.2.x release cycle of a JSR-168 impl. We need to start moving toward jsr-286. The jsr-286 EG will be releasing a public draft soon that is feature complete. Torsten's work in the 286 branch has almost caught up with the draft spec. Both Exo and JBoss portal has preliminary (alpha/beta) jsr-286 releases. We should not be that far behind. /Craig Elliot Metsger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> 07/16/2007 10:00 AM Please respond to [email protected] To [email protected] cc Subject Re: [VOTE] Pluto 1.1.4 Release Looks like the changes snuck in between the 1.1.2 and 1.1.3 release with PLUTO-350 (r523130) - the relative URL provider. I'm thinking we could probably take it out, but I haven't taken a thorough look. Of course, since the change is out there with 1.1.3, 1.1.3 users who move to 1.1.5 will be broken. We could re-release this 1.1.4 candidate as a 1.2.0, and put a note on the website noting the 1.1.3 incompatibility. Or just release 1.1.5 and retract 1.1.3? Elliot David H. DeWolf wrote: > -1 > > 1.1.3 and 1.1.4 should be backwards compatible (binary and runtime > compat). This looks to me like we introduced an incompatibility. In the > meantime, is there a workaround we can use in order to get 1.1.5 > released without this incompatibility? > > This type of change can be added to 1.2.x BUT should be specifically > mentioned in an "upgrade" guide. > > David > > Charles Severance wrote: >> Elliot, >> >> Switching from 1.1.3 to 1.1.4 - Sakai compile fails with the following: >> >> /Users/csev/dev/sakai/portal/portal-render-impl/impl/src/java/org/sakaiproject/portal/render/portlet/services/SakaiPortalCallbackService.java:128: >> org.sakaiproject.portal.render.portlet.services.SakaiPortalCallbackService.SakaiPortletURLProvider >> is not abstract and does not override abstract method >> isSecureSupported() in org.apache.pluto.spi.PortletURLProvider >> class SakaiPortletURLProvider implements PortletURLProvider >> >> Has an API changed? I am happy to update Sakai, adding methods or >> whatever - let me know if this was an intentional change. >> >> /Chuck >> >>
