"Fears that immigrants will wreck
our economy are probably the biggest reason substantial barriers to legal
immigration remain on the books. But immigrants don’t take our jobs,
lower our wages or depress the American economy."
Why Is Immigration Illegal
Anyway?
By
Benjamin W. Powell,
Art Carden
Sun. November 20, 2011
Also published in Birmingham News
As two economists interested in immigration, one an Alabamian by birth,
we’ve kept an eye on the fury surrounding the Alabama’s new immigration
law. Proponents tout it as a matter of law and order and promise it will
“save jobs.” There’s a larger question at stake, though: Should we even
be restricting immigration in the first place?
American immigration restrictions have a long history, but they have
never been a good idea. Economist Thomas Leonard documents how even some
Progressive Era economists supported immigration restrictions and minimum
wages because they wanted to shut members of what they called “low-wage
races” out of the American labor market. American reformers who pulled up
the ladder in the early 20th century condemned many potential immigrants
and native-born Americans to poorer, less fulfilling lives than they
would have had if the United States had welcomed more
immigrants.
Fears that immigrants will wreck our economy are probably the biggest
reason substantial barriers to legal immigration remain on the books. But
immigrants don’t take our jobs, lower our wages or depress the American
economy.
Virtually all economists who study immigration find that it provides a
small but positive impact on the economy. It should be obvious that
immigrants don’t steal jobs from the native-born. Since 1950, the labor
force has more than doubled but long-run unemployment is essentially
unchanged. As we’ve added more workers, we’ve added more jobs.
Immigrants tend to be either high-skilled or low-skilled; Americans tend
to be more toward the middle of the skill distribution. This means that
immigrants aren’t substitutes for American labor but, instead, free up
American labor to do jobs where it is more productive. That’s one reason
economists don’t find that immigration depresses the wages of the
native-born.
As a number of economists have pointed out, immigrants don’t “do jobs
Americans won’t do.” They do jobs that wouldn’t exist if the immigrants
weren’t there to do them. By making life harder for a population of
undocumented immigrants, the state government has ensured that future
generations of Alabamians will be poorer than they would otherwise
be.
The last refuge of the defenders of the new Alabama legislation is to
protest that this is not about immigration per se, but about illegal
immigration. Perhaps you acknowledge that we are a nation of immigrants
but protest that your ancestors came here legally. That dodges the issue.
To move to the United States legally in the 19th century and to move to
the United States legally in the 21st century are two very different
undertakings. We are willing to bet that our ancestorsand yourswould
find themselves in the same position as many potential immigrants today:
effectively denied entry by layers and layers of red tape.
Defenders of restrictions might insist that the restrictions are still
the law, but lots of immoral and unwise thingslike slavery and Jim
Crowused to be “the law.” Simply repeating “what part of ‘illegal’ don’t
you understand?!” misses the real question: Why does the law make it
illegal to migrate here? Immigrants are a boon to our economy and
restrictions on immigration seem as immoral as many other past laws. Yes,
the “illegal” part of illegal immigration is a problem. Alabama’s
legislators are addressing it the wrong way. As our friend Mark LeBar, a
philosopher at Ohio University, has put it, illegal immigration is one of
very few issues that really has a magic wand solution: Legalize
it.
http://www.independent.org/newsroom/article.asp?id=3188
--
--
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum
* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls.
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "PoliticalForum" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
