Sara , Oh Sara ! where have you gone ?  oh sweet tongued one The GOP
needs you
THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter

http://www.buzzflash.com/articles/carpenter/240


It's official. Bill Kristol has gone mad. Humbuggingly mad.
Wretchedly, distressingly mad.


Ever since Election Day, you see, Mr. Kristol has played his own
Elmer
Gantry to the GOP's Sister Sharon Falconer. As political flimflammery
goes, no problem there.


Yet the boy seems genuinely, even savagely smitten. What's worse, the
nation's unrequited love for his comely evangelist has thrown him
into
an absolutely irrational tizzy. It's a trifle pathetic, but
titanically obvious.


Writing, for instance, in the imposing-sounding "11/24/2008, Volume
014, Issue 10" edition of The Weekly Standard, our love-struck Mr.
Kristol sets the preposterous stage:


GOP revivals depend on fresh and bold thinking at the national level.
Figures like Jack Kemp redefined Republican economic policy between
1977 and 1980. By 1994, Newt Gingrich and Co. had brought into being
a
very different Republican party from that of the last days of the
first Bush administration. Who are the Kemps and Gingriches today?
The
field is wide open for the ambitious and the daring.


OK, so you know the punch line. You know what's coming. But that
attenuates not its hilarity. And here it comes:


[P]olitics isn't just -- or even mostly -- about ideas. It's also
about political leadership. To see Sarah Palin at the Republican
Governors Association was to wonder at a natural politician. Among
her
peers she may be in a class by herself -- like Reagan or Barack
Obama.


So the GOP's comeback depends on new ideas, especially bold ones; on
the other hand politics isn’t really about ideas. And that's the kind
of exceptional thinking that allows Mr. Kristol to compare Sarah
Palin
to Ronald Reagan and Barack Obama.


But there's a villain in this love story. "Can she rise to the
occasion?" asks Kristol. "The media," he answers -- I knew it, damn
them to hell I just knew it -- "remain desperate to deny that she
can,
and even to deny her a chance to try."


Putting that demonstrable silliness aside -- as a post-election news
feature, Ms. Palin has dwarfed everyone and everything but Barack
Obama and the economy -- Kristol then moves on to attempt a serious
point. And it was this maneuver -- not his undying if embarrassing
love for Ms. Palin -- that caught my attention, gave me pause and
prompted this piece.


"Palin is a phenomenon, and her future is unpredictable," he rightly
observes of unpredictable futures. However "there are plenty of other
Republican governors and ex-governors who would be competent and
plausible nominees in 2012."


Did you like that? Merely "competent and plausible"? That was
Kristol's way of segueing and looping back to the boring business of
politics as ideas, should his party be so foolish as to shun his true
love, the idea-less one. And here's what he had to say about that:


One pillar of any Republican comeback will surely be successful
practical governance at the state level. The Republican revival of
the
early and mid-1990s … was due in part to the examples of effective
state governance by Tommy Thompson in Wisconsin and John Engler in
Michigan, to say nothing of Rudy Giuliani's efforts in New York City.


Kristol was of course obligated to also throw George W. Bush into
that
gubernatorial mix. Yet it was Bush, above all, who proved not only
the
non sequitur of state competence morphing naturally into national
competence, but the gross incompatibility of modern conservative
thinking and national governance itself.


Perhaps state and local governance is indeed within conservative
capabilities -- microgovernance, you might say -- but the day
Republicans attempt federal governance -- macrogovernance -- is the
day they surpass not so much their level of competence, maybe, but,
for sure, their level of interest. It's like granting a medical
license to a physician who doesn't like sick people and goes out of
his way to avoid them and their unwelcome problems.


Nevertheless Mr. William Kristol finishes with yet another
incomparable flurry of rhetorical whiplash. Having started from the
premise that "politics isn't just -- or even mostly -- about ideas,"
he concludes by writing that this rather troublesome economic wicket
in which we're stuck "invites urgent new thinking."


Why is that? Why, we must "fight to save free-market capitalism from
the Obama administration."


Oh my, Bill, you poor thing. That woman has you so discombobulated
you
don't even know who's doing what these days. And you're one of your
party's more preeminent strategists.


The GOP is in big, big trouble.





--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum

* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/  
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. 
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to