Israel’s crisis and the historic contradictions of Zionism
By Bill Van Auken
16 May 2008

Israel marked the 50th anniversary of its founding under conditions of
mounting political and social crisis within the Zionist state and
escalating tensions with the Palestinian people in the territories
still occupied by Israeli forces, as well as with the surrounding Arab
world.

None of the official commemorations organized in Israel itself, nor
the glitzy and superficial celebrations staged by Israel’s friends in
the U.S. and elsewhere, even touched upon the profound historical
questions underlying the foundation of the Israeli state.

Within Israel’s birth and evolution are concentrated the great
unresolved contradictions of the 20th century. Its essential origins
lie in one of history’s greatest crimes against humanity, the Nazi
Holocaust. The extermination of six million European Jews was, in
turn, the terrible price paid for the crisis of the working class
movement brought on by the Stalinist degeneration of the Soviet Union
and the Communist International. Stalinism’s crimes and its domination
over the workers movement prevented the working class from putting an
end to the crisis-ridden capitalist system, which found in fascism its
last line of defense.

The defeats of the working class, the crimes of Stalinism and the
horrors of the Holocaust created the historical conditions for
Israel’s creation and the Zionist movement’s largely successful
attempt, aided both by US imperialism and Stalinism, to equate Zionism
with world Jewry. It was a movement and a state founded ultimately on
discouragement and despair. Stalinism’s betrayals produced
disillusionment in the socialist alternative that had exercised such a
powerful appeal to Jewish working people all over the world. The
crimes of German fascism were presented as the ultimate proof that it
was impossible to vanquish anti-Semitism in Europe or anywhere else.
Zionism’s answer was to get a state and an army and beat the
historical oppressors of the Jewish people at their own game.

The tragic irony of this supposed solution is Israel’s association of
the Jewish people—traditionally and historically connected with the
struggle for tolerance and freedom—with the brutal suppression of
another oppressed population.

David Ben-Gurion read out the declaration of Israel’s independence on
May 14, 1948, the day before Britain’s mandate over Palestine was to
expire. Within less than a year, Israeli military forces had succeeded
in carving out the country’s present internationally-recognized
borders, while over three-quarters of a million Palestinian Arabs were
driven from their homes in a systematic campaign of terrorism and
intimidation.

Ben Gurion described the realization of Israeli statehood as the
“culmination of the Jewish revolution.” It represented the achievement
of the central political aim of Zionism, the Jewish nationalist
movement founded in the latter part of the 19th century. Before World
War II, Zionism had remained a relatively isolated movement, drawing
its support primarily from sections of the Jewish middle class. Even
within Palestine, there existed among Jewish workers a powerful class
sentiment for uniting Jewish and Arab workers in a common movement
against capitalism.

While it took the Holocaust to turn Zionism into a state power, the
real relations between the crimes carried out by Nazism against
European Jewry and the Zionist movement have been the subject of
systematic historical distortion. Israel is portrayed as the necessary
haven for Jews fleeing the German death camps. Yet the attitude of
Zionism toward the struggle to save Jews from extermination was not so
simple.

This is one of many subjects which Israeli historians have begun to
examine. Known as the “new historians,” the “post-Zionist” or
“revisionist” school, the emergence of this critical attitude toward
Israel’s history is one of the most profound signs of the growing
crisis of Zionism as an ideology and of Israel as a society.

Among these new historians is Zeev Sternhell, the author of The
Founding Myths of Israel, recently published in English. Sternhell’s
book debunks some of Zionism’s most powerful myths, principally that
those Zionist leaders who founded Israel were attempting to establish
a new type of society based upon egalitarian principles and even
socialism.

This historian establishes that Zionism was by no mean unique. It
arose as a peculiar expression of the trend of eastern European
nationalism of the 19th century; one based not on universal democratic
principles, but rather on exclusivist conceptions of racial, religious
and linguistic hegemony. Ironically, a movement that claimed to stand
for the liberation of Jews found substantial common ground with anti-
Semites and right-wing nationalist precursors of German fascism.

Zionism, he writes, “was from the beginning the preoccupation of a
minority, which understood the Jewish problem not in terms of physical
existence and the provision of economic security, but as an enterprise
for rescuing the nation from the danger of collective annihilation.”
It perceived the greatest danger of annihilation as coming from the
assimilation of Jews into modern society, particularly through the
attraction of growing numbers of Jewish workers to the socialist
movement.

To the extent that the founders of the Zionist state attempted to
identify Zionism with the labor movement, equality and socialism it
was, Sternhell writes, a “mobilizing myth,” designed to win working-
class Jews to the cause of nationalism. He makes the case that this
use of socialist phraseology had much in common with other “national
socialist” movements seeking nationalist revival in Europe, ultimately
giving rise to Nazism.

Certainly the case can be made that many other nationalist movements
in the course of the 20th century, including Arab nationalism, which
has represented itself as socialist and egalitarian, have utilized
such a “mobilizing myth.” In every case, such ideologies have the
purpose of covering up the interests of the national bourgeoisie and
suppressing the independent struggle of the working class.

As for Israel’s justification as the sole possible haven for Jews
fleeing Nazi oppression, Sternhell, as well as other historians—Tom
Segev, author of The Seventh Million, the Israelis and the Holocaust,
for example—have presented ample evidence that the rescue of European
Jewry was never a primary concern for Zionism as a movement, and that
Ben-Gurion and other Zionist leaders reacted with indifference.

At the outbreak of the Second World War, with Nazism’s threat to the
Jews of Europe becoming ever clearer, Ben-Gurion spelled out the
principle which was to guide the Zionist movement’s attitude
throughout the Holocaust: “Zionist considerations take precedence over
Jewish sentiments...we should act according to Zionist considerations
and not merely Jewish considerations, for a Jew is not automatically a
Zionist.” Throughout the war he argued successfully against those who
suggested that the Jewish Agency in Palestine turn its attention from
the building of “Eretz Israel” to the rescue of Jews from Nazism.

At the same time the Zionists lost no time in making use of the
catastrophe in Europe for their own ends. Their efforts were
successful, as Europe’s stateless and homeless surviving Jewish
population was directed to Palestine for very definite geopolitical
reasons. Washington, which had closed US borders to Jews fleeing Nazi
oppression, saw the emergence of the Jewish state in the Middle East
as an instrument for asserting its own hegemony in the region at the
expense of the old colonial powers, Britain and France.

Founded in the struggle to wrest control of the land from its Arab
inhabitants, Israel was from its origins a militarized state, with the
army serving as the central pillar of society. Surrounded by hostile
Arab states and posturing as a new form of society, founded upon
equality and vaguely socialist principles, the new state was widely
perceived as an underdog, deserving of popular sympathy.

Both realities and perceptions underwent change, however, with the
growth of Israel into the undisputed military force and sole nuclear
power in the region. First came the 1956 Suez war, in which Israel
briefly seized the Sinai Peninsula. The 1967 war redrew the map of the
Middle East once again, setting the parameters of the current
conflict. With US backing, Israel invaded Egypt, Syria and Jordan,
laying hold of the West Bank of the Jordan River, the Golan Heights
and the Gaza Strip, which it occupies to this day. Zionism and the
state of Israel emerged as a force of aggression and expansionism.
Israel has fought further wars in Lebanon, where it continues to
occupy a “security zone” in the south.

Israel’s initial military expansion was made possible by a massive and
continuous infusion of US economic and military aid. Underlying the $3
billion in annual aid, Washington’s “special relation” with Israel has
nothing to do with shared principles or sympathy for the historic
oppression of the Jewish people. Rather, it backs Israel as a garrison
state which serves to suppress the revolutionary strivings of the
masses of the Middle East, while providing a means of extending US
influence in this strategically vital oil-producing region.

Israeli militarism went hand in hand with the growth of reactionary
political and social tendencies within Israel itself. Israel’s
occupation and administration of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip,
exercising a political dictatorship over roughly a million
Palestinians, not only exposed the oppressive character of the Israeli
state, but brought to the surface all of the contradictions embedded
in Zionism as a movement.

In 1968 Zionist settlements were begun in the occupied West Bank and
Gaza, on the theory that these paramilitary outposts would serve as a
line of defense against attacks by Palestinian guerrillas on Israel
proper. While the Labor Party government initially presented the
settlements as no more than a defensive parameter, which would not
preclude the handing back of the territories to Jordan and Egypt, the
issue of the status of the West Bank and Gaza quickly became the focal
point of Israeli politics.

The right-wing opposition under the leadership of Menachem Begin
demanded that the territories be brought under Israeli sovereignty on
the grounds that they were the Biblical lands of Samaria and Judea,
promised by God to the Jewish people. Thirty years later the issue has
yet to be resolved, despite the much-heralded Middle East peace
brokered by the Clinton administration and signed by both Israel and
the Palestine Liberation Organization. One hundred and forty four
settlements are scattered throughout the territories, inhabited by
160,000 settlers, many of them extreme nationalists and religious
zealots who are heavily armed.

The settlements continue to grow at the rate of 9 percent a year,
despite the agreement signed with the PLO. The Israeli government
insists that its forces must control the access roads to these
enclaves and their connection to Israel itself. This alone exposes the
largely token character of any “independent” Palestinian state that
might emerge from this process. The Palestinian Authority is left to
police small patches of land, mostly impoverished cities, while it
remains surrounded and cut off by Israeli troops. As the stalemate in
the US-brokered talks makes clear, the Israeli state is not prepared
to make any fundamental alterations in the present situation.

Israel’s motivation for signing the Middle East accord was, in the
first place, to forestall a revolutionary uprising by the Palestinian
masses in the occupied territories, which had taken embryonic form in
the intifada which began in 1987. Despite sustained and brutal
repression, Israel proved incapable of putting down this rebellion
without seeking the direct collaboration of the PLO.

At the same time, the Israeli ruling class was anxious to escape the
punishing economic and social costs associated with the occupation,
both in terms of military expenditures and the pariah status which
Israel acquired throughout the Arab world and elsewhere.

But as the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin in November 1995 and the
subsequent return to power by the Israeli right under Benjamin
Netanyahu have shown, it is not so easy to escape the historical
contradictions of Zionism. The settlement policy begun by the Labor
Party spawned a right-wing nationalist, semi-fascist layer, which
produced the assassin that claimed Rabin’s life. Increasingly, the
debate over the future of the settlements, as well as the associated
question of the increasingly bitter conflict between religious and
secular Israeli Jews, is spoken of in terms of a “civil war.”

Wielding disproportionate power in the government, Israel’s ultra-
Orthodox political parties have increasingly imposed the dictates of
Jewish religious law in areas previously deemed secular. All
administrative control over births, marriages and burial arrangements
has been placed in the hands of the Orthodox rabbinate, much to the
consternation of Conservative, Reform and secular Jews. Orthodox
members of the Knesset, who play a pivotal role in cobbling together
coalition governments, are demanding laws that would close down roads
and force an end to flights by El Al, the national airline, on
Saturdays. Many communities have become bitterly divided between
Orthodox and secular Jews, reaching the point of physical
confrontation.

No less deep are the social chasms that have emerged in Israel. In a
country that once claimed to need every Jewish immigrant for the labor
of national construction, 8.2 percent of the population is unemployed,
according to the official figures. The ranks of the jobless are
concentrated in impoverished “development towns,” like Ofkim in the
Negev. Rioting broke out there six months ago after the town’s
unemployment rate reached 14.3 percent.

Ethiopian Jews also rioted last year over their treatment as second-
class citizens. The resentment of Sephardic Jews, those originating in
the Arab world, against the Ashkenazic, or European Jewish,
establishment, has emerged as a volatile and pivotal factor in Israeli
politics. Menachem Begin was able to manipulate this resentment in a
rightward direction, to no small degree because of the glaring
contradiction between the socialist pretensions of Israel’s Zionist
founders and the immense social polarization which exists in Israeli
society today.

An essential economic contradiction continues to undermine both the
Zionist project and the conception underlying the Middle East peace
accord of a new economic partnership between the Israeli bourgeoisie
and its Arab counterparts. The fastest growing sector within Israel is
the high-technology industry, which produces neither for the national
nor the regional market. Fully 96 percent of Israel’s exports and 93
percent of its imports are conducted with areas outside the region.

While the impasse over the occupied territories has largely frozen the
growth of Arab-Israeli economic ties, the development of such
relations would ultimately take place at the expense of the masses of
working people, Arab and Jewish alike. The Arab world offers the
Israeli capitalist the prospect of new reserves of cheap labor to
further depress the living standards of workers in Israel itself.

Within the areas administered by the PLO in Gaza and the West Bank,
meanwhile, the Palestinian workers are finding that their conditions
of social oppression have only continued to worsen, while a small
layer of government bureaucrats and businessmen with political
connections are seeking their fortunes.

Fifty years after Israel’s founding, the reactionary Zionist utopia of
a national state in which the Jews of the world could find sanctuary,
unity and equality has been realized in the form of a capitalist state
created through the dispossession of another people and maintained
through war, repression and social inequality at home. As the
assassination of Rabin and other violent acts by the extreme right-
wing forces cultivated by the Zionist state have shown, there is a
danger that Israel itself will reproduce the conditions of
dictatorship and civil war from which an earlier generation of
European Jews fled.

The dead-end of Zionism is a peculiar expression of the failure of all
movements that have based themselves on the perspective of nationalism
to resolve any of the fundamental questions confronting the masses of
working people. This is no less true for the Arab countries, where
ruling cliques have manipulated nationalist sentiments and bitter
resentment of Israel in order to divert the social struggles of the
working class.

There is only way out of the malignant contradictions of Israeli
society. That is to unite Arab and Jewish workers in a common struggle
against capitalism and for the building of a socialist society, which
would tear down the artificial borders which divide the peoples and
economies of the region. Only in this way can the region liberate
itself from war and oppression, fueled by the profit drive of foreign
capitalists and the native ruling classes



On Nov 19, 10:57 am, Visual Purple <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> VIDEO: Israel is a Nazi Enterprise/Experiment
>
> The terrible, and for Jews unthinkable, truth about the State of
> Israel.
> The legitimate aims of the Zionist Movement, as formulated by Theodore
> Herzl, was undermined first by the Rothschild family (Herzl chronicled
> this fact) and then, from the 1930s, was overrun by the Nazis who were
> smuggled in, passed themselves off as German-speaking Jews and
> infiltrated every vital office and service in the fledgling Jewish
> settlement.
>
> http://tinyurl.com/6x2rlj
>
> Erratum: One of the families that I recommend doing resreach on spells
> their name Dangoor. I was too literal in the transliteration in the
> video. The other is Sassoon.
>
> Please help me disseminate this video.
>
> Doreen Ellen Bell-Dotan, Tzfat
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum

* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/  
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. 
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to