Extinguishing Physician Conscience
By Mary L. Davenport, MD

The largest generational cohort in American history, the Baby Boomers, will be 
the first Americans to be denied available effective life-saving treatments for 
reasons of cost. The seeds for this mass liquidation have already been planted.


Imagine that it is 2016, and you are a 65 year old boomer. You have been 
admitted to your local community hospital with malaise, fatigue, vomiting and 
cloudy mental status. You have had blood pressure problems and diabetes for a 
few years, and have just been diagnosed with renal failure. As you drift in and 
out of consciousness, you are vaguely aware your old family practice physician, 
who had taken care of you for 20 years, is not around. A religious man, he 
quietly retired from medical practice in 2014, after the full force of the 
Obama administrationā€˜s removal of conscience protection for physicians in 
February, 2009, came into effect. 


You feel vaguely uncomfortable as you are placed in a darkened room in the 
Comfort Care wing of the hospital. In moments of lucidity, you wonder if you 
shouldn't have some oxygen, an IV or SOMETHING! But the appropriate therapy, 
kidney dialysis, is not on the approved list of treatments for patients over 
65, having been deemed too expensive. The new regulations from the Department 
of Health and Human Services were presented just last month to your hospital's 
Futile Care Committee. It was decided at the highest levels that for those over 
65 years of age, renal dialysis would not be a beneficial treatment, that the 
alternatives of a kidney transplant were too expensive, and that your quality 
of life on chronic dialysis would be too diminished.

Your children wonder why you are not in an ICU. They are told that you will be 
placed on a morphine drip to make you more comfortable as you pass away, and 
that this is the highest standard of care for your diagnosis and age. It is 
called terminal sedation. You signed an advanced directive indicating that you 
did not want extraordinary care for a terminal condition, and under the new 
protocols renal failure, although treatable, qualifies as a terminal condition.


Your children frantically try to find their old family doctor. But your health 
plan replaced him with a large group of younger physicians, the hospital's 
Consortium for Health, a private-public foundation that was created to promote 
efficiency and reduce wasteful spending in medical care. By 2014 when he left, 
your family doctor was a dinosaur, having been trained in an earlier era. His 
medical school was one of the last to retain the original Hippocratic Oath.  It 
affirmed the covenantal relationship between the physician and patient, 
overseen by God, and that whatever the physician did would be for the patient's 
benefit.  You had felt safe entrusting your health to Dr. O'Brien's 
professional judgment. 


Not only did the Hippocratic Oath your doctor took decades ago took 
specifically forbid physician assisted suicide and abortion, it also 
established patient confidentiality so that your secrets would never be 
disclosed. That is, until 2012, when physicians participating in the national 
healthcare system, which included ALL licensed physicians, were mandated to 
submit your visits to the unified electronic medical record system.  This data 
base was created in 2003 to coordinate medical care, detect emerging health 
threats, and exchange clinical information. Your doctor was very uncomfortable 
with this policy despite reassurances that HIPAA regulations would maintain 
your privacy. 


But forces beyond any individual's control began to erode your relationship 
with your doctor long before he left the practice of medicine. The insurance 
companies stopped paying him in the late 1990's for hospital care, preferring 
to hire "hospitalists" or "intensivists" for greater efficiency in reducing 
hospital stays. Since office visits were reimbursed at lower and lower rates, 
your doctor had to see more and more patients in the office to just stay even. 
So although O'Brien knew you well and was trained to treat conditions such as 
renal failure or pneumonia, he stopped treating patients in the hospital. 


Around 2007 both the hospital and office physicians began to be paid by a 
formula that rewarded them for saving money on medical care.  When your family 
doctor was forced to join the Consortium in 2012 because the health plans 
stopped contracting with individual physicians, a powerful new computer system 
tracked each doctor's prescribing habits, referrals to specialists, and 
utilization of expensive lab tests. But your doctor was an "outlier" in this 
new system, having been brought up in Hippocratic tradition of doing what was 
necessary for the individual patient, rather than the Greater Good, the newer 
communitarian ethic followed by the younger doctors. He was financially 
penalized for doing too much for his patients, since the formulas based 30% of 
physician income on "efficiency."


Your old doctor could tolerate the erosion of his income, but had trouble with 
the new regulations that insisted that he discuss and refer for "all legal 
procedures." Since by 2013 physician assisted suicide was legal in 21 of 50 
states, the Consortium enumerated the conditions that mandated the "euthanasia 
talk", including multiple sclerosis, metastatic breast cancer, and many others. 
He could never actually bring himself to violate his original Hippocratic Oath 
that not only forbade assisting his patients in committing suicide but also 
prohibited even mentioning it. It was impossible to rid himself of the idea 
that a physician's role was to assist in healing and that medical killing was 
antithetical to his professional integrity. 


Back in 2007, ACOG, the ob/gyn's professional organization, issued Ethics 
Committee Opinion 385, contending that ob/gyn doctors had the duty to either do 
abortions or have offices in close proximity to abortion doctors to whom they 
would refer patients. There was an outcry from professional organizations of 
pro-life ob/gyns, Catholic physicians,  and other Christian doctors. Especially 
troubling to many was the assertion in  Committee Opinion 385 that defined 
conscience as a sentiment, and measured its "authenticity" by the degree to 
which a provider would suffer "guilt, shame or loss of self esteem" if it were 
violated. Your doctor and many of his colleagues regarded medical killing as 
anathema, and were incensed by describing their integrity as a physicians as a 
"feeling". But by 2013 the protests had died down, and the ethics committee 
recommendation for ob/gyn's had evolved into a mandate for family practice 
doctors under new rules enforced by the Department of Health and Human 
Services. 


The final blow came in early 2014. Back in 2008, in Benitez v North Coast 
Women's Care Medical Group, the California Supreme Court ruled against ob/gyn 
doctors who did not want to provide intrauterine insemination to a lesbian 
couple because of their religious beliefs. Although most European nations did 
not allow the buying or selling of eggs or sperm, and restricted fertility 
therapies to heterosexual married couples, the California courts not only 
permitted but required health care providers to cooperate in any reproductive 
therapies for any patient regardless of sexual orientation or marital status. 


Although the birth of octuplets in 2009 with assisted reproductive technology 
to a single woman with six other children initially created a brief public 
uproar, ultimately no legislation was passed protecting physicians who did not 
want to participate in a patient's procreative endeavor. Your physician had a 
68 year old bipolar single male patient who wanted to have an heir. The patient 
requested that your doctor appeal to the Consortium to provide him with a 
donated egg and surrogate mother for his desired offspring. Since your doctor 
did not want to be used as a tool in his patient's peculiar agenda and was 
legitimately afraid of an expensive lawsuit that would decimate his dwindling 
retirement funds if he refused, he decided at this point to quit medicine 
altogether and move to a sunny warm state. 


Your family doctor had been inspired as a young man by study of the U.S. 
Constitution and other foundational documents that he thought would forever 
ensure his liberty. He had studied the same "Rules of Civility" that the young 
George Washington had encountered in 1747.  One of the most memorable of these 
maxims was "Labor to keep alive in your breast that little spark of celestial 
fire called conscience." It was clear to him that conscience here referred to 
man's innate understanding of moral right and wrong. When the American Founders 
would later declare independence from Great Britain in 1776, it was by virtue 
of this "spark of celestial fire" that they would establish the principles of 
human equality, unalienable rights, and government by consent as the 
foundations of American constitutional government. 


Just before he left for his retirement home, your doctor was deeply disturbed 
to see the concept of conscience mocked in the New England Journal of Medicine 
by University of Wisconsin law professor R. Alta Charo in her article "The 
Celestial Fire of Conscience - Refusing to Provide Medical Care."  Charo's 
presentation did not acknowledge that many Americans do not believe that 
abortion, assisted suicide, and embryonic stem cell therapies are legitimate 
medical care in the first place. Her article also did not distinguish between 
emergency and elective care, and merely regards the health care provider as a 
tool for whatever ends the patient wants to achieve. Attorneys such as Ms. 
Charo claimed the right to take whatever cases they want, but seem deny the 
same basic right to physicians. Patients can always seek the care of other 
providers. 


Your doctor (and many other Americans) believed that failure to protect 
physician conscience will destroy the trust and accountability that is 
essential to the physician patient relationship. If the physician and patient 
cannot freely collaborate, ultimately another agenda -- that of the health plan 
or state -- will replace it, to everyone's detriment.


Dr. Davenport is an obstetrician/gynecologist in private practice in El 
Sobrante, California. 

Page Printed from: 
http://www.americanthinker.com/2009/03/extinguishing_physician_consci.html 

--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum

* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/  
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. 
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to