Literacy lessons have been fatal for English, says teachers' leader

Tim Ross, Education Correspondent
09.04.09

THE drive to improve literacy in schools has killed the subject of English and left a generation of children unable to speak properly, a teachers' leader warned today.

Pupils no longer read whole books or write in class for pleasure, but instead analyse "extracts" for tests, according to Mary Bousted, the general secretary of the Association of Teachers and Lecturers. She said children had lost the chance to learn how to talk and listen to others under the Government's literacy strategy.

There is growing concern among authors over the erosion of literature studies and employers have complained about school-leavers' weak communication skills.

Pupils are no longer required to study whole Shakespeare plays in detail but can rely on revising sections from extracted scenes. Inspectors have warned that poetry is a dying subject in too many schools, while Michael Rosen, the Children's Laureate, has criticised the Government for failing to promote reading for fun.

Speaking at ATL's annual conference in Liverpool, Dr Bousted, a former English teacher, criticised the Government's literacy strategy, begun while David Blunkett was education secretary, for failing to include verbal communication skills.

"My subject, English, is no more. It has been replaced by a newcomer - literacy," she said. "Literacy as a subject is based on the naming of parts. Children rarely read whole books. They read parts of books - extracts. These extracts are mined for adjectives and adverbs, and active verbs and nouns.

"Where has the concept of pleasure gone? Where has the personal response to a book or a poem disappeared to? Where is the experience of children choosing what it is they want to write about?"

Despite opposition from teachers' unions, ministers have overhauled the teaching of reading in primary schools, bringing in the use of "phonics", in which children learn to blend individual letter sounds to form whole words.

Link to: Digg RedditDelicious Facebook

Reader views (22)

 Add your view | Show all

Here's a sample of the latest views published. You can click view all to read all views that readers have sent in.

I was at school during the forties & fifties and I learnt to read when I was five years old & in a very serious & disciplined manner. I don't recall having much in the way of teaching before starting school either. So - why is it that this subject was considered so important & absolutely essential in the olden days but is treated so casually now?!

- Dawn Bonham, Northampton

Yes indeed. Education policy, modern teaching methods and dumbing down of exams are all downsizing our language. But also, how do you encourage a child to read for pleasure when he has his
X-Box, his PC and his mobile phone to occupy his time? Yet the teenagers all say " I have nothing to do in the evenings. "

Nao

- Naomi Sajeri, Manchester

Years ago I went to school, in a building bomb torn shred and shattered,
Reading and writing was all very good; but it was the free school milk that mattered.

Teachers were often thin on the ground, but books in libraries were always around,
Reading made me constantly think, and my writing was always done in ink.

I left my dilapidated school one day, without any qualifications of merit,
This was just the start of my education; which I sought out like a ferret.

I carried on reading and learning all I could, from those that had the knowledge,
This is the best a working class kid could do, without ever going to college.

I am old today and often look back at the happy life I have had,
I learned very young to help myself, and for that I am more than glad.

I could have blamed everyone else around, for failing to reach my peek.
Yet as old as I am every day I learn, knowledge is there for all to seek.

Teachers and parents can only go so far, after that it is up to you,
To my children I give this advice I have learned; always remain true to you.

- Mickyinlondon, london


Add your comment

Show all

 

Reply via email to