To Vote Is To Choose Your Masters
Posted by David D'Amato on Mar 9, 2011
Yesterday, The Washington Post ’s Peter Wallsten reported that “voting-related bills being pushed by newly empowered Republican state lawmakers across the country” have provoked a partisan “clash over voting laws.” Critics of the new proposals, which (among other things) would make it more difficult for college students to vote in their schools’ locals, charge that they are to attempts “to rig elections” and wage a “war on voting.”
“One side,” observes the Pew Center on the States’ Doug Chapin, “is convinced fraud is rampant; the other believes that disenfranchisement is widespread.” Carrying on the statist tradition, the arguments of both sides are predictably confined to the politically-acceptable margins, taking no notice of even deeper structural problems with American democracy.
In America, democracy, vaguely defined and isolated from meaningful debate, is a guiding mantra, the inviolable linchpin of American political life. Like all concepts with social or political import, however, “democracy” subsumes a diverse cluster of disparate, even contradictory, ideas. When anarchists speak of the “free market,” we’re aspiring to something quite different from the state capitalism of today, and the same is true for democracy, with direct democracy often regarded as a key ingredient in a stateless society.
Coinciding with a formulation of democracy that regards it as an egalitarian triumph stationing political power in the common man is a more bleak understanding of democracy often overlooked. Common misgivings about democracy, going back to James Fenimore Cooper’s The American Democrat and before, center on the notion of the tyranny of the majority the concern that the will of the masses might be allowed to withdraw the freedoms of minority groups. Legitimate reasons for such worries exist, with dominant and intolerant cultural blocs often essaying to use the political process to severely restrict the rights of persecuted members of society.
At the same time, hand in hand with the tyranny of the majority problem, American democracy can be considered as facilitating the tyranny of the minority. Where, as in the United States, political debate and electoral politics are confined to what are almost universally inconsequential minutiae, the present incarnation of democracy can be seen as a mere safety valve; it allows the broad majority of the population to “blow off steam” and feel involved in the political decision-making that is actually confined to a small minority of elites whose power is well out of popular reach.
Voting, then reduced to an empty exercise designed to be incapable of changing anything important about the statist framework becomes a device for legitimizing the state’s hierarchies. As George H. Smith articulated it, elections become “the mechanism by which political sanctification occurs.”
Counter to the statist categories of democracy that exist to give (in mainstream political jargon) a “mandate” to coercion, free market anarchists favor voluntary democracy. Leaving each individual free within her own sphere of decision-making autonomy, market anarchism contemplates group decisions based on the consent and participation of all involved.
Cooperatives, mutuals, and any number of other, peacefully-organized groups could without the violent imposition of state interference make decisions for collective action. With individuals left the power to withdraw their consent from institutions founded on free agreement, democracy would become a valid, organic process.
Today, democracy and all of its many accoutrements make up an extravaganza for celebrating and purifying the acts of the modern, total state. Free market anarchism simply calls for a democratic ideal wherein unchained individuals would resolve problems and come to conclusions through nonviolent channels of action. Regardless of the details of bills moving about in state legislatures, the democracy of the state will always be of the state, by the state and for the state.
http://c4ss.org/content/6395 --
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum
* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls.
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
- To Vote Is To Choose Your Masters MJ
- To Vote Is To Choose Your Masters Jonathan Ashley
