"Limbaugh was even more misleading when
he screeched and whined over and over that Scheuer supposedly said that
"It’s the United States’ fault!" "It’s America’s
fault!" No, Rush, it’s not "America’s" fault. It is the
fault of the several dozen or so political connivers, liars, manipulators
and empire builders who call themselves "statesmen." The
average American never has anything whatsoever to do with the
"diplomacy" that gets us into never-ending, perpetual wars for
perpetual peace. As Randolph Bourne wrote in his famous essay, "War
is the Health of the State," [A]ll foreign policy, the diplomatic
negotiations which produce or forestall war, are . . . the private
property of the Executive part of the Government, and are equally exposed
to no check whatever from popular bodies, or the people voting as a mass
themselves."
"It is not "America" that is responsible for the killing
of hundreds or thousands of Muslim civilians with drone strikes or
other weapons of mass destruction. War always originates, wrote Bourne,
when "the government, with no mandate from the people,
without consultation of the people, conducts all the negotiations, the
backing and filling, the menaces and explanations, which slowly bring it
into collision with some other government, and gently and irresistibly
slides the country into war" (emphasis added). Contrary to what
Limbaugh insinuates and what Barack Obama has similarly declared, the
government is not us. The government is the government; it is the
largest instrument of organized plunder ever known to man. We are
the plundered, duped, and misled into catastrophic, bankrupting war after
war that has nothing to do with "national defense.""
Limbaugh’s 'Big Lie' Strategy
by Thomas J. DiLorenzo
Rush Limbugh recently threw a fit on his radio show over an appearance by
Michael Sheuer on the FOX News Channel (as did Sean Hannity, who was even
more apoplectic than Limbaugh). Michael Sheuer is the former CIA head of
the bin Laden unit. Limbaugh was at his sarcastic and bombastic
name-calling worst in responding to Sheuer’s comments.
What on earth did Michael Sheuer say to cause such an emotional explosion
of bombast?, one might ask. Well, when asked by the host of a FOX News
show about what might motivate Muslims from the Middle East to harm
Americans, the man the CIA put in charge of the "bin Laden
unit" said, "People don’t like being invaded or bombed,"
and they sometimes retaliate. This of course is perfectly reasonable and
understandable. It’s called "blowback." He reminded the FOX
host that Muslims have long protested the American military presence in
the Muslim country of Saudi Arabia; the invasion and occupation of Iraq;
the killing of thousands of Iraqi civilians; the statement by U.N.
Ambasador Albright that a half million dead Iraqi children was "a
price we are willing to pay" to achieve our political
objectives; the U.S. government’s support for the government of Israel in
its wars against Muslims; and the bombing and killing of civilians in
numerous other Muslim countries, most recently in Mali and Libya under
the Obama regime.
"We are trying to impose democracy . . . and parliamentary
government . .. on a people who don’t want it," said Sheuer. All of
this is perfectly true, which is why Limbaugh did not spend one second of
air time disputing anything that Michael Sheuer actually said. He did not
because he could not. Instead, Limbaugh attacked a straw man by
reinterpreting Sheuer’s words to supposedly mean that "Islam has
nothing to do with it" and "It’s the United States’
fault!!!!!!"
Scheuer never said "Islam has nothing to do with it." Limbaugh
said that. What Sheuer has said is that many Muslims resent the
never-ending attempts by the U.S. government to impose our culture of
"democracy" on them at gunpoint and at the cost of thousands of
Muslim lives. Limbaugh was never a CIA agent like Scheuer, but one might
think of him alternatively as an FIB agent of the state.
Limbaugh was even more misleading when he screeched and whined over and
over that Scheuer supposedly said that "It’s the United States’
fault!" "It’s America’s fault!" No, Rush, it’s not
"America’s" fault. It is the fault of the several dozen or so
political connivers, liars, manipulators and empire builders who call
themselves "statesmen." The average American never has anything
whatsoever to do with the "diplomacy" that gets us into
never-ending, perpetual wars for perpetual peace. As Randolph Bourne
wrote in his famous essay, "War is the Health of the State,"
[A]ll foreign policy, the diplomatic negotiations which produce or
forestall war, are . . . the private property of the Executive part of
the Government, and are equally exposed to no check whatever from popular
bodies, or the people voting as a mass themselves."
It is not "America" that is responsible for the killing of
hundreds or thousands of Muslim civilians with drone strikes or
other weapons of mass destruction. War always originates, wrote Bourne,
when "the government, with no mandate from the people,
without consultation of the people, conducts all the negotiations, the
backing and filling, the menaces and explanations, which slowly bring it
into collision with some other government, and gently and irresistibly
slides the country into war" (emphasis added). Contrary to what
Limbaugh insinuates and what Barack Obama has similarly declared, the
government is not us. The government is the government; it is the
largest instrument of organized plunder ever known to man. We are
the plundered, duped, and misled into catastrophic, bankrupting war after
war that has nothing to do with "national defense."
What really set Limbaugh off was Michael Scheuer’s mockery of the
standard neocon line that "they hate us because of our
freedoms." Muslims are not motivated to harm Americans because
"you and I can have a beer after work," Sheuer said to the FOX
host. He called this theory "insane," and he was
right.
Those who really hate our freedoms are those who supported the
PATRIOT Act, the National Defense Authorization Act, warrantless
wiretapping, internet eavesdropping, and the creation of what William F.
Buckley approvingly described as a "totalitarian bureaucracy within
our shores" with a gigantic FBI and CIA complex, a massive military,
and the militarization of society into a police state. (Buckley –
Limbaugh’s hero of heroes – once said that all of that was necessary in
his day to fight the Cold War). Rush Limbaugh would be at the top of the
list of supporters of such a freedom-destroying regime.
Randolph Bourne would be even more cynical about war had he lived to
witness the gargantuan army of squawking chickenhawks on TV and talk
radio, led by the likes of Limbaugh and Hannity, whose cheerleading for
war is many orders of magnitude greater that that produced by the
chickenhawk journalists of Bourne’s day (the World War I era). The role
of today’s squawking chickenhawks is to serve as the propaganda
megaphones of the warfare state and the military-industrial complex. In
return, they are paid eye-popping salaries for their mediocre talents and
turned into "celebrities" of a sort. Their job is to make sure
that the nightmarish reality of the warfare state as described by
Randolph
Bourne becomes or remains a reality. With the onset of war, said Bourne,
"the patriot loses all sense of the distinction between state,
nation, and government" and "the individual becomes almost
identical with his society." This of course is what the Limbaughs of
the world want when they falsely accuse people like Michael Sheuer of
saying "America" is at fault for terrorist attacks.
With war, "minority opinion" becomes "a case for
outlawry," and at times "the minorities are either intimidated
into silence, or brought around slowly by a subtle process of persuasion
. . . " That again is the job of the squawking chickenhawks. They
are in reality a part of "the whole terrific force of the
state" which is "brought to bear against heretics,"
a.k.a., the proponents of peace and prosperity as opposed to war and
impoverishment of the masses.
As soon as Barack Obama took office Limbaugh, Hannity, Levin, and the
rest of the squawking chickenhawks totally reversed their personas.
During the Bush regime they sounded like Benito Mussolini in their
denunciations of the Constitution in the name of "safety."
"9/11 changed everything" was their mantra. Translation: To
hell with the Constitution. Liberty Schmiberty. But with a Democrat in
office they began sounding more like Thomas Jefferson, even writing books
about liberty and freedom for a change. But their true personalities are
revealed whenever a genuine Jeffersonian like Ron Paul, or a genuine
advocate of American peace and prosperity like Michael Sheuer becomes
prominent. In such instances the claws come out, the microphones are
turned up, and they reveal their true selves as the propaganda
mouthpieces for the state, which Randolph Bourne described as
representing "all the autocratic, arbitrary, coercive, belligerent
forces within a social group," a "sort of complexus of
everything most distasteful to the modern creative free spirit, the
feeling for life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. War is the
health of the State."
http://lewrockwell.com/dilorenzo/dilorenzo253.html
--
--
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum
* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls.
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "PoliticalForum" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.
