Salut Alain,

i just realized that you seem to have removed a couple of bogus files
from your mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz distribution tarball.

While i certainly appreciate your effort to actively maintain the
mtools software, i should like to respectfully draw your attention
to the fact that changing published distribution files in place
may cause problems for software packagers and redistributors,
even when the changes themselves are apparently harmless.  For
example, the OpenBSD ports tree implements automated file size
and checksum tests in order to assure distfile integrity before
using or unpacking any distribution file dowloaded from the Internet.
For that reason, it is generally preferable to publish changed
distribution files under different names even when the changes
themselves are trivial.

How are we going to proceed now?
Is someone going to replace mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz on the OpenBSD
mirror network, patching /usr/ports/sysutils/mtools/distinfo at
the same time?

Thank you very much for your consideration,
  Ingo

P.S.
In case i misinterpreted the situation, sorry for the noise...

-- 
Ingo Schwarze <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

 $ mkdir knaff; cd knaff
 $ ftp http://www.tux.org/pub/knaff/mtools/mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz 
Trying 129.13.186.3...
Requesting http://www.tux.org/pub/knaff/mtools/mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz
  (via http://proxy.rz.uni-karlsruhe.de:3128/)
100% |**************************************************|   342 KB    00:00    
Successfully retrieved file.
 $ ll mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz                                      
-rw-r--r--  1 schwarze  wsrc  351077 Apr  8 08:50 mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz

 $ cd ..; mkdir linux; cd linux
 $ ftp http://mtools.linux.lu/mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz
Trying 129.13.186.3...
Requesting http://mtools.linux.lu/mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz
  (via http://proxy.rz.uni-karlsruhe.de:3128/)
100% |**************************************************|   342 KB    00:00    
Successfully retrieved file.
 $ ll mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz                                      
-rw-r--r--  1 schwarze  wsrc  351077 Apr  8 08:56 mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz

 $ cd ..; mkdir openbsd; cd openbsd
 $ ftp ftp://ftp.openbsd.org/pub/OpenBSD/distfiles/mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz
Connected to openbsd.sunsite.ualberta.ca.
[...]
150 Opening BINARY mode data connection for mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz
  (387208 bytes).
100% |**************************************************|   378 KB    00:04    
226 Wow, that seems to have worked.
387208 bytes received in 4.53 seconds (83.51 KB/s)
221 Goodbye.
 $ ll mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz                                      
-rw-r--r--  1 schwarze  wsrc  387208 Apr 16  2005 mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz

 $ cd ../knaff; tar -xzf mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz                   
 $ cd ../openbsd; tar -xzf mtools-3.9.10.tar.gz                 
 $ cd ..; diff -ur openbsd/mtools-3.9.10 knaff/mtools-3.9.10
Only in openbsd/mtools-3.9.10: .#fat_size_calculation.tex.1.1
Only in openbsd/mtools-3.9.10: .#mtools.spec.1.4
Only in openbsd/mtools-3.9.10: .#mtools.texi.1.11
Only in openbsd/mtools-3.9.10: .#patchlevel.c.1.18

Reply via email to